DiotimosReading Desk

Argument and disputation

Universality and presence in all things

IN JEDEM aber IST ER NICHT CATHOLISCH; Synopticè-Catholicè; Kurtz-begrifflich

This conceptual headword gathers the distinction between being present everywhere and being present universally in a suitable subject.

From the book

Heinrich Khunrath’s Magnesia Catholica Philosophorum

Heinrich Khunrath · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThis conceptual headword gathers the distinction between being present everywhere and being present universally in a suitable subject.
  • In KhunrathThe opponents' reasoning at pp. 16–172 begins with a cosmological continuity: all matter comes from the universal first matter, and the most secret Spirit of the World, Nature or the World's Soul, is in all things.
  • In this editionThe English keeps the Latin adverb where Khunrath's German explanation follows.
  • A reading distinctionThe primary margin at p. 20 cites Wisdom 12:1. This is an authorial source reference rather than a biblical parallel supplied solely by the modern editor.

Meaning

This conceptual headword gathers the distinction between being present everywhere and being present universally in a suitable subject. The crucial adverb Synopticè is glossed by Khunrath as Kurtz-begrifflich, comprehended-in-brief. “Catholic” describes the mode in which the Spirit is present, not simply the number of places where it may be found.

Use in the book

The opponents' reasoning at pp. 16–172 begins with a cosmological continuity: all matter comes from the universal first matter, and the most secret Spirit of the World, Nature or the World's Soul, is in all things. Khunrath does not deny this continuity. At p. 20 he emphatically accepts it, then adds the restriction on which the book depends: the Spirit is not catholic in each thing. In ordinary specified bodies, particular formative sparks have determined matter toward particular kinds. Their common source does not undo that determination.

Magnesia differs because Nature has left it catholic and ensouled it with a synoptically catholic spark. It therefore provides a comprehensive instance of the universal power needed for the work. “Comprehended-in-brief” should not be taken as a statement of physical volume, concentration or measurable density. The text explains it through universality, natural constitution and the absence of vegetable, animal or mineral specification.

The distinction returns with unusual force in the rebuke to those who would catch the Spirit from the air. The Spirit already has an appropriate material lodging by divine ordinance. Artists are not to impose a lodging of their own devising. Khunrath quotes Wisdom's declaration that God's incorruptible Spirit is in all things and immediately tells his reader to recognize its catholic dwelling. The biblical universal proposition leads to discrimination between subjects, not indiscriminate choice of any subject whatever.

At pp. 92–932 the same argument supports regeneration: in the Chaos the fifth essence or world-spirit dwells comprehensively, catholicly, bodily and naturally. Those final adverbs matter. The universal is available through a natural material subject, and the contrast cannot be solved by abandoning matter for an abstract or externally summoned spirit. The issue is the right mode of embodiment.

Places to read

  1. 1599 p. 16The opponent introduces shared origin as a reason for multiplying universal subjects; the Spirit premise follows on p. 17.
  2. 1599 p. 20Khunrath accepts universal presence while rejecting catholic presence in every individual thing.
  3. 1599 p. 21The distinction is explained through particular sparks and one synoptically catholic spark.
  4. 1599 p. 85The Spirit has already chosen and prepared a fitting material lodging.
  5. 1599 p. 86Wisdom 12:1 is invoked immediately before the command to seek the catholic dwelling.
  6. 1599 p. 93The Spirit’s comprehensive presence is explicitly bodily and natural.

Translation in this edition

The English keeps the Latin adverb where Khunrath's German explanation follows. Collapsing both into “everywhere” would remove the argument. The apparatus's language of gathering the Spirit whole is explanatory; the primary text supplies no quantitative account of concentration.

Source note

The primary margin at p. 20 cites Wisdom 12:1. This is an authorial source reference rather than a biblical parallel supplied solely by the modern editor.