Explained supporting records

Horn, wood, stone, sowing, and harvest

Horn / Holtz / Stein; seen / erndten

The Way of Truth compares using arbitrarily chosen substances to sowing horn, wood, or stone and expecting a harvest of grain.

From the book

The Sophic Hydrolith, Water Stone of the Wise

Anonymous and companion authors · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Meaning

The Way of Truth compares using arbitrarily chosen substances to sowing horn, wood, or stone and expecting a harvest of grain. The force is not that all transformation is impossible, but that the expected result must have a fitting natural ground: the speaker locates the art in the essence of the natures, not in any imagined starting substance. The dialogue's alchemist independently warns sophists not to reap where they have sown nothing. Both agricultural expressions criticize an unjustified expectation of results. Neither gives a rule that every mineral reproduces like a seed-bearing plant, a proposition the dialogue expressly disputes elsewhere.

Places to read

  1. Way of Truth · unit 11Sowing horn, wood or stone and expecting grain illustrates impossible matter selection.
  2. Nature’s Demonstration to the Erring Alchemist · unit 18Sophists are rebuked for hoping to harvest where they have not sown.
  3. Nature’s Demonstration to the Erring Alchemist · unit 17The alchemist explicitly rejects universal mineral reproduction; the Via’s sowing comparison must not erase that separate position.

Attested forms

Horn; Holtz; Stein; seen; Korn; erndten; samblen