Being and explanation

Active or productive

ποιητικός

poiētikos

Poiētikos concerns producing or bringing something about.

From the book

Stobaeus, Volume I

John Stobaeus · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordPoiētikos concerns producing or bringing something about.
  • In StobaeusThe report under Pythagoras’s name couples the productive cause with the formal cause and identifies this side with intellect or god.
  • In this edition“Productive” suits causal contrasts; “active” may suit a direct opposition to passive.
  • A place to beginProductive and formal causation are aligned with intellect.
English renderings
productive; active; capable of making

Meaning

Poiētikos concerns producing or bringing something about. In causal explanations it marks the agent’s role rather than merely the possession of an activity.

Use in the book

The report under Pythagoras’s name couples the productive cause with the formal cause and identifies this side with intellect or god. The receptive and material side is distinguished from it. The contrast explains complementary causal roles; it does not require every instance of making to be divine creation.

Places to read

  1. I.10.12.10Productive and formal causation are aligned with intellect.
  2. I.10.12.5The silversmith illustrates the acting cause required alongside material.

Translation in this edition

“Productive” suits causal contrasts; “active” may suit a direct opposition to passive. “Poetic” would mislead in these passages.

Source note

Wachsmuth, volume I, printed pp. 123–125. The silver-cup example is the reporter’s criticism of a purely material explanation, not a quotation from Anaximenes.