Renaissance

Working Out for the Gods

Pater sees Greek athletes trying to resemble their gods and sculptors giving the gods the bodies of athletes. Xenophon’s dinner guests make the resemblance harder to take for granted.

Athletic victories had a place in Greek worship, but the evidence is less settled than Pater’s picture of a victorious wrestler. An ancient joke and a later restoration show where it can mislead.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A body models a godPater imagines athletes working toward divine beauty and sculptors using trained human bodies to give the gods their visible forms.
  • Victory at a sanctuaryOlympia shows how athletic competition, public honours and worship could occupy the same place.
  • A boast at dinnerIn Xenophon, Critobulus says he prefers beauty to a king’s power before Socrates challenges him in a comic contest.
  • What the restored arms suggestThe raised arms of the Berlin bronze are later additions, so they cannot establish that the original figure thanked a god for victory.

Pater has a lovely picture of a feedback loop, and it starts in the gym. “The Greek system of gymnastics originated as part of a religious ritual,” he says, and “The worshipper was to recommend himself to the gods by becoming fleet and fair, white and red, like them.” Then the loop closes, since “The beauty of the palaestra, and the beauty of the artist’s workshop, reacted on one another,” and “The youth tried to rival his gods; and his increased beauty passed back into them.” It’s an elegant idea, a kind of upward spiral in which training makes bodies godlike, statues make gods bodylike, and each round raises the bar for the next. The question worth arguing is what that spiral actually does, whether it turns exercise into devotion, turns divinity into a social standard, or quietly blurs two things the Greeks themselves kept apart.

The case for devotion is stronger than you might expect. The Olympic games took place in Zeus’s sanctuary. Pausanias distinguishes between some objects dedicated to gods and statues that honoured the victors. The distinction gives us an idea of how closely religion and competition could coexist without having identical purposes. Pater’s phrase “fleet and fair, white and red” even sounds like the Song of Songs, where the beloved is “white and ruddy,” and whether he meant the echo or not, it suits a world in which the body could be both admired and dedicated.

The case for divine beauty turning social is just as good. Once statues of the gods began to look like the best young men of the city, the gods became the ultimate fitness standard, and Hegel, whom Pater quotes a page later, pushes the idea all the way, saying that in the age of Pericles statesmen, poets and philosophers were all “ideal artists of themselves,” shaped like works of art. Hegel even throws in Phryne, the famous courtesan who, at a festival before “assembled Greece,” walked naked into the sea. In Athenaeus’s account of Phryne’s trial, her advocate bares her breasts before the judges, who are moved to pity and afraid to condemn a woman he likens to a servant of Aphrodite. That is the force of the story as Athenaeus tells it.

That last story is where the blur becomes visible, because it shows beauty acting as a kind of religious credential in a courtroom, within a story that survives as an anecdote rather than a record of the proceedings. Pater’s own key witness is shakier still, once you look at where it comes from. His Greek quotation, “I take the gods to witness, I had rather have a fair body than a king’s crown,” comes from Xenophon’s Symposium, where a rich young man named Critobulus says it at a drinking party, and Pater calls it “the form in which one age of the world chose the higher life.”

Read in context, the line is party banter, and the scene that follows is a comic beauty contest between Critobulus and Socrates, the most famously ugly man in Athens. Socrates argues with a straight face that his bulging eyes are more beautiful because they see sideways, that his snub nose is better at catching smells and that his thick lips are made for kissing, and when the votes are counted Critobulus wins every ballot. Xenophon lets the joke turn on whether a good feature is one that looks beautiful or one that does its work well. That is a more unsettled picture of beauty than Pater takes from the boast on its own.

Pater’s other emblem of the athlete as worshipper has a hidden flaw too. He calls the bronze in Berlin the adorante, “a youth who has gained the wrestler’s prize, with hands lifted and open, in praise for the victory,” and it’s a gorgeous description. The Berlin museum’s catalogue identifies the arms as later additions. The gesture that makes a victorious wrestler easy for Pater to imagine is also the part that offers the least secure evidence of the original pose.

None of this makes Pater’s loop imaginary, and it’s worth saying so plainly. Greek religion really did put beautiful bodies at the center of festivals, and Greek sculpture really did draw on the gymnasium for its models, so training, worship and art could matter to one another. The question is whether that traffic made the activities identical, and here the evidence says no, since Greeks argued in their own texts about whether beauty was a real good, joked about men who preferred a fair body to a throne and told stories about beauty getting a defendant off as signs of how odd things could get.

My verdict is that the reciprocal process Pater imagines captures a connection among practices that individual Greeks had reason to understand differently. Physical training could be devotional in setting without being devotional in spirit, and divine beauty became a public standard without anyone forgetting that a statue was a statue and a wrestler a wrestler. Pater’s ideal Greece tends to merge the gym, the temple and the studio into one bright continuum, and the texts he draws on keep showing the seams, from Xenophon’s laughing symposium to the restorer’s arms on the boy in Berlin.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Which interpretation best captures the author’s final assessment of Pater’s “feedback loop” among athletics, religion, and art?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.