Renaissance
Wistful Marble in a Room Built for Prayer
Pater finds uncertainty in Michelangelo’s reclining figures. Their chapel also gave the living a place to pray for the dead.
The Renaissance (1893)Night and Day can leave the viewer wondering what follows death. The altar and the Medici tombs put that uncertainty inside a room with a clear religious purpose.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater hears the statues as he would musicThe names Night, Day, Dawn and Dusk feel too definite to him. The reclining figures suggest shifting thoughts he cannot hold still.
- Michelangelo gives Night another voiceHis verse asks to remain asleep or in stone while shame and harm last. The figure can carry anger and grief as well as Pater’s wistfulness.
- The altar belongs to the interpretationThe New Sacristy housed Medici burials and gave worshippers a place to offer prayers for the dead. The statues were made for that setting.
- The figures and the chapel can make different claimsThe carved bodies can keep the afterlife hard to picture. The building gives the living a concrete way to act on their hopes for the dead.
The Renaissance · The Poetry of Michelangelo, pp. 65–67, the New Sacristy and the afterlife · The Poetry of Michelangelo, note 166
Walk into the New Sacristy at San Lorenzo and you’re in a cool, tall box of gray stone and white marble, lit from a lantern high above, with two Medici dukes sitting in niches and four huge figures sprawled across the lids of their tombs. The room is small enough that you can’t get away from the figures, and tall enough that the light seems to come from somewhere you’ll never reach. Pater’s response to the room is unusually blunt for a writer so fond of soft focus. “I suppose no one would come to the sacristy of San Lorenzo for consolation,” he writes, “for seriousness, for solemnity, for dignity of impression, perhaps, but not for consolation.” It is, he says, “a place neither of consoling nor of terrible thoughts, but of vague and wistful speculation,” and he builds a whole theory of Michelangelo’s attitude to death on that impression.
Pater says that “what hope he has is based on the consciousness of ignorance,” and Pater ends the essay with a run of images for what that hope can picture. After the body’s relapse into formlessness and the rush of pity, there comes, “far off, thin and vague,” the new body, “a passing light, a mere intangible, external effect, over those too rigid, or too formless faces,” then “a dream that lingers a moment,” then “a thing with faint hearing, faint memory, faint power of touch; a breath, a flame in the doorway, a feather in the wind.” Every image is weaker than the last, like a radio signal fading out on a night drive.
So do the figures encourage hope, sustain a question, or register how hard it is to imagine life after death? The case for sustaining a question is strong, and Pater makes most of it himself. Pater says the traditional titles, Night and Day, Dusk and Dawn, are “far too definite” for figures that work less like symbols than like “the promptings of a piece of music,” and the statues help him out. Day’s face is left rough and unfinished, Night sleeps with an owl and a mask beside her, and the two dukes appear in idealized likenesses. Those faces give us little basis for identifying a particular mood.
There’s also a darker case, that the figures register difficulty more than hope. In a short poem, Michelangelo gives two of them a voice, beginning “El Dì e la Notte parlano, e dicono” (Day and Night speak, and say), in which the pair admit that their swift course has carried Duke Giuliano to his death, and complain that the dead man has taken his revenge by closing his eyes and putting out their light. In a verse reply to an admirer, he gave Night her own words, starting “Caro m’è ’l sonno, e più l’esser di sasso,” which means sleep is dear to me, and dearer still to be stone, because not seeing and not feeling is a mercy while shame and harm last. That’s not wistful at all, and it’s closer to grief and anger than to speculation.
Then there’s the room itself, which Pater barely looks at. The New Sacristy was built as a funeral chapel where masses and prayers would be offered continually for the souls of the Medici dead, so the altar at one end was the working heart of the place. On the wall facing it sits Michelangelo’s Madonna and Child, and beneath her lie Lorenzo the Magnificent and his brother Giuliano, murdered in 1478. Pater says the tombs commemorate not “any of the nobler and greater Medici” but two young dukes “noticeable chiefly for their somewhat early death,” yet the greatest Medici of all is buried in that same room, in a plain grave under the Virgin, looking toward the altar.
That makes one of Pater’s sentences look very strange indeed in this setting. He says Michelangelo is “so ignorant of the spiritual world, of the new body and its laws, that he does not surely know whether the consecrated Host may not be the body of Christ,” and he says it about a chapel designed so that the Host would be raised for the dead over and over, year after year. The building has a very definite theory of what helps a soul after death, the kind of firm, almost childlike belief Pater assigns to Dante, who thinks “the dead will hear if you cry loud enough.” Whatever Michelangelo privately thought, he was building a place where prayers could be offered for the dead.
So the honest answer is that the place divides the labor. The marble figures, restless on their curved lids as if they might slide off, really do sustain a question, and Pater reads them beautifully, catching how they hover between sleep and death without telling you which. The room around them answers the question with the oldest Catholic hope there is, that the living can pray the dead forward, and it does so with an altar, a Madonna and a daily rite. Pater keeps the statues and loses the chapel, which is a bit like reviewing the soundtrack of a film without mentioning the story.
Here’s where I come down on the chapel, then, after all of that. A tomb can make room for hope grounded in ignorance, and this one does, in its stone figures, which are as uncertain about what comes after as anything Michelangelo ever made. But it sets that uncertainty inside a building that isn’t uncertain at all, and the two together are truer to the man than either alone. Pater’s flame in the doorway and feather in the wind describe the statues perfectly, while the chapel gives prayer a place to go on even where Pater’s images give out.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author think Pater’s interpretation is incomplete?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does the author’s claim that the chapel and sculptures “divide the labor” change the way we might interpret an artwork within its architectural and ritual setting?→
- Does uncertainty necessarily weaken hope, or can Pater’s idea of “hope grounded in ignorance” represent a meaningful kind of faith? Why?→
- How should Michelangelo’s poems about Day and Night influence our reading of the statues: as authoritative explanations, competing interpretations, or something else?→