Renaissance

Wishing a Painter Dead Sooner

Pater hoped Botticelli had died earlier. The records place his death in 1510, and the surviving paintings fill out his last years.

Botticelli’s accepted death date of 1510 answers one question. His late religious paintings offer a separate answer to the idea that he spent his last years idle.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Pater questions the received dateThe essay gives 1515 as the accepted date in Pater’s day. Pater wonders whether a document might shorten the long, inactive old age he imagines.
  • The record establishes 1510Botticelli died in 1510 and was buried at Ognissanti. The date alone tells us little about his state of mind.
  • A late work speaks for itselfThe Mystic Nativity links its scene to troubles in Italy and to the Apocalypse, showing Botticelli at work on an ambitious religious picture around 1500.
  • A wish and its evidencePater’s unease gives him a reason to ask a good question. The surviving record gives a firmer answer than the story he wanted.

Pater’s account of the last years is brief and gloomy. Botticelli fell under Savonarola’s influence, he says, “passing apparently almost out of men’s sight in a sort of religious melancholy, which lasted till his death in 1515, according to the received date.” Then comes an unusual confession for a critic to make in print. “Vasari says that he plunged into the study of Dante, and even wrote a comment on the Divine Comedy. But it seems strange that he should have lived on inactive so long; and one almost wishes that some document might come to light, which, fixing the date of his death earlier, might relieve one, in thinking of him, of his dejected old age.” The edition’s note supplies the answer, which is that the accepted date is now 1510.

An early account records his death on 17 May 1510, at about sixty-five. He was buried in the church of Ognissanti, near the home where he had lived for much of his life. Vasari, writing two generations later, had him die in 1515 at seventy-eight, and painted his old age in the darkest colors, poor, unable to stand upright, hobbling on two sticks and dependent on the charity of friends. The surviving evidence leaves the details of his last years less certain than Vasari’s account makes them sound.

Look closely at what Pater’s wish actually wants, because it isn’t a historical wish, since he has no evidence and says so, but a narrative one, a wish that the life should end close to its last great work, with the flame going out at its brightest rather than guttering for years. That’s the shape Pater admires elsewhere in this book, where Giorgione dies young, Pico’s “brief existence flamed itself away,” and the Conclusion urges us to burn always with a hard, gem-like flame. It’s the same impulse that turns rock musicians who die at twenty-seven into legends, the sense that a life is more beautiful when it ends before its decline.

Then the correction came, and the date shrank by five years, which looks like a wish granted. But the evidence and the wish agree only on a number. The burial record says nothing about whether the last years were dejected, and even the corrected date leaves a full decade after 1500. A critic who wanted a shorter melancholy got a shorter life, which isn’t quite the same thing, and if he had taken the new date as proof that his feeling about the story had been right all along, he would have been confusing a coincidence with a confirmation.

The more important correction is to Pater’s premise that the painter “lived on inactive.” Scholarship since Pater has found a busy late Botticelli. The Mystic Nativity in London, with its Greek inscription placing the picture at the end of 1500 amid the troubles of Italy and the prophecies of the Apocalypse, is one of the most intense religious images of the period, and its inscription anticipates the devil’s defeat, and little demons flee into cracks in the foreground, which is hardly the work of a man who had stopped caring about anything. Works associated with the later part of his career include the stories of Virginia and Lucretia, the panels on the life of Saint Zenobius, and the great series of drawings for Dante made for Lorenzo di Pierfrancesco de’ Medici. They belong to projects that stretched over a period longer than the final decade. Vasari’s own claim that he plunged into Dante describes work, not idleness.

That points to something genuinely good in Pater’s method, which is that he marks his wish as a wish. “One almost wishes” is a confession, not a claim, and the suspicion behind it, “it seems strange that he should have lived on inactive so long,” is the kind of narrative implausibility that sometimes catches an error before the documents do. Detectives work this way, and so do good historians. A story that doesn’t sit right is a reason to go looking, and in this case the looking found that the received date was wrong and that surviving work complicates the legend of an idle old age.

There’s a cost to the wish as well, and it should be said plainly. Wishing away the last years of a real man so that his portrait will have a better ending treats a life as if it were a picture, and the old painter on his sticks, if he existed, had as much claim on our sympathy as the young one at the height of his fame. It’s also a little odd coming from this critic, who finds Botticelli’s melancholy so beautiful in the pictures that he builds his whole essay around it, and yet can’t bear to imagine that melancholy filling the painter’s actual days.

My verdict is that the correction vindicates Pater’s suspicion and not his reason. His wish was narrative and the date was archival, and the two met by luck at the number 1510. The happier outcome is that the evidence went further than the wish, showing that Botticelli continued to paint around 1500 and leaving much of his last decade open to question, so Pater got the more satisfying life he wanted by a better route, not a shorter old age but a fuller one. A critic is allowed to wish, as long as he labels the wish and lets the documents decide, and Pater did both.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author say the corrected death date vindicates Pater’s suspicion but not his reason?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.