Renaissance

Why Winckelmann Belongs in Pater’s Renaissance

An eighteenth-century scholar becomes Pater’s “last fruit” of the Renaissance by making ancient Greece newly available.

Pater uses the same words for Renaissance humanists and for Winckelmann’s pursuit of Greek art. His final study asks how a desire can outlive the conditions in which it first took shape and pass on to someone else.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A Renaissance outside its datesWinckelmann lived in the eighteenth century. Pater places him among Renaissance humanists because he pursued Greek art and thought with a similar devotion.
  • The same desire takes a new formThe opening chapter values the love of intellect and imagination for their own sake. The Preface returns to that phrase to describe what Winckelmann has in common with earlier humanists.
  • A different route to antiquityWinckelmann reached Greek art through books, collections, Roman works, and the support of patrons. His route shows how a revival can take shape under conditions quite different from Florence’s.
  • The last fruit carries a seedPater opens the Winckelmann chapter with Goethe’s debt to a teacher he never met. The earliest essay Pater dated becomes the last study and points toward another generation of readers.

Pater sounds almost apologetic when he explains, “I have added an essay on Winckelmann, as not incongruous with the studies which precede it, because Winckelmann, coming in the eighteenth century, really belongs in spirit to an earlier age.” Johann Joachim Winckelmann was born in 1717, the son of a poor cobbler in Prussia, studied Greek despite limited means, reached Rome in 1755, published his history of ancient art in 1764, and was murdered in Trieste in 1768. Winckelmann’s chronology traces his route from Stendal to Rome. He arrives in this book two centuries after Michelangelo, and Pater’s defense comes in one striking sentence, “He is the last fruit of the Renaissance, and explains in a striking way its motive and tendencies.”

Start with how Winckelmann belongs, since he obviously can’t belong by date. Pater says he is in sympathy with the earlier humanists “by his enthusiasm for the things of the intellect and the imagination for their own sake, by his Hellenism, his life-long struggle to attain to the Greek spirit.” Now turn to the first chapter, where Pater defines what he means by the Renaissance, and you find “a many-sided but yet united movement, in which the love of the things of the intellect and the imagination for their own sake” makes itself felt. It’s the same phrase, so Winckelmann qualifies by the book’s own definition, and membership in Pater’s Renaissance turns out to be a matter of what you love for its own sake and how hard you work to reach it.

Then there’s the fruit, which is a more precise image than it looks. A tree flowers first and fruits later, and the fruit is in some sense what the tree was for, the thing that tells you what kind of tree you were looking at. The Gospel puts it plainly when it says that by their fruits ye shall know them, and Pater’s claim that Winckelmann “explains” the Renaissance’s motive runs on the same logic, in which the fruit explains the tree. A last fruit is also a late one, ripening after the leaves have fallen, and Winckelmann ripened in the age of the Enlightenment, when Germany had no Florence to offer him and the season for Renaissances was supposed to be over.

That lateness is exactly why he explains so much. In fifteenth-century Florence the love of antiquity comes tangled up with banking, politics, church commissions and fashion, so it’s hard to see the motive on its own. Winckelmann came to antiquity by a different route, through books, collections in Dresden, and the statues in Rome. A stipend from Saxony helped him reach Rome, and Cardinal Albani later became his patron. The comparison shows how the desire Pater describes could take shape under different conditions.

The Diotimos introduction makes the same move in plainer words, saying that Winckelmann comes at the end because his encounter with Greek sculpture gives Pater “a much later instance of a past becoming newly available.” That phrase is the key to Pater’s whole idea of a renaissance. If rebirth means a past becoming available again, then it isn’t a period at all but an event that can happen whenever someone wants an old world badly enough to reach it, which is why the book can stretch from twelfth-century France to eighteenth-century Rome without breaking its own rules. It also means the Renaissance is never finished, since there will always be somebody, somewhere, for whom a forgotten world suddenly opens.

Fruit also carries seed, and that’s the other half of the metaphor. The Winckelmann essay opens with Goethe, who, in Pater’s words, spoke of him as “the teacher who had made his career possible, but whom he had never seen,” and through Goethe the last fruit of the Renaissance becomes the seed of German classicism and, eventually, of the nineteenth century’s whole love affair with Greece, Pater’s own included. So the image that seems to close the story actually passes it on, and placing Winckelmann at the end of the studies sets him up as the link between the old revivals and the modern program the Conclusion is about to announce.

The book’s own dates add a nice twist, since the Winckelmann essay is dated 1867, which makes it the oldest piece in the volume, older than the Conclusion of 1868 and the Leonardo of 1869. Pater put his earliest-dated study last and followed it with a Conclusion that bears the next year’s date, so the book closes on its author’s own beginnings. The last fruit of the Renaissance was the first fruit of Pater, and the order quietly suggests that his own career is one more late ripening of the same old appetite, carried from Winckelmann’s Rome to Oxford. Whether or not Pater meant the arrangement as a self-portrait, it works as one, and it gives the phrase “last fruit” a personal edge it would lack if the essay had simply been tacked on.

I think the belonging works, on Pater’s terms, because his Renaissance is defined by an appetite and not by a date, and Winckelmann has the appetite in its purest form. The fruit metaphor matters to the book’s sequence because it makes the last study explain the whole and also carry the story forward, into Goethe and into the Conclusion. The cost is that Pater’s Renaissance becomes roomy enough for anyone with enough hunger to join it, from a cobbler’s son in Prussia to an Oxford don, and that seems to me to be exactly the point he wanted to make.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article argue that Winckelmann qualifies for membership in Pater’s Renaissance despite living in the eighteenth century?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.