Renaissance

Why the Laocoön Comes Before a Word About Venice

Lessing explains why a poem and a sculpture tell a story differently. Pater brings that distinction into the gallery to ask what line and color can do.

A German treatise on Homer and an ancient sculpture sets up Pater’s argument for looking closely at how a Venetian painting is made.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Different means of imitationLessing distinguishes forms and colors arranged in space from the sounds of verse that unfold in time.
  • Homer makes action visibleThe making of Achilles’ shield and the elders’ response to Helen show how a poet can reveal a thing or a person through action.
  • Pater’s next questionPater asks what the handling of line and color contributes beyond the action or bodies that a painting depicts.
  • Titian takes a figure from sculptureThe reveler tangled in snakes in Bacchus and Ariadne shows what a painter can make of the antique Laocoön pose.

You’d expect an essay called “The School of Giorgione” to open in a gondola, or in a dark church with an altarpiece glowing over the candles, but Pater opens in a library, with a long-dead German critic and a book about a marble group of the Trojan priest Laocoön and his sons in the coils of sea serpents. Gotthold Ephraim Lessing published Laokoon oder über die Grenzen der Malerei und Poesie in 1766, which means Laocoön, or On the Limits of Painting and Poetry, and limits is the word to hold onto, because the book asks how the different means of visual art and poetry guide what each can represent. Pater calls it “an important contribution” to the philosophy he’s after and then says right away that it isn’t enough, the kind of compliment that tells you a correction is coming.

Lessing’s case is simple enough to fit on a napkin, and that’s a big part of why it stuck. A painting sets out figures and colors side by side in space, while a poem lays out sounds one after another in time, so each art is built for a different kind of subject, with painting suited to bodies that exist together and poetry suited to actions that unfold. A poet who describes a body inch by inch is fighting his own medium, and Lessing shows how Homer stays out of that trap, because instead of describing Achilles’ shield as a finished object he shows the god of fire hammering it into being, and instead of listing Helen’s features he shows the old men of Troy watching her pass and deciding nobody could blame the armies for fighting over her. It’s a useful insight, because it ties what an art can do to the stuff it’s made of.

Lessing was picking a fight, and knowing who he was fighting tells you why Pater wants him in the room. His preface goes after critics who notice that a poet and a painter have treated the same story differently and promptly call the difference a fault, and later he takes apart the Comte de Caylus, a French antiquarian who in 1757 had proposed ranking poets by how many good pictures a painter could get out of them. That’s the habit Pater attacks as his essay opens, and he says it does the most damage in galleries, since it’s “in popular judgments on pictures” that “the false generalisation of all art into forms of poetry is most prevalent,” which is a bit like scoring every movie by how faithfully it adapts the book.

The split comes when you ask what Lessing does with his insight. Lessing treats figures and colors as signs arranged side by side. His argument then asks what kinds of subjects these signs can represent and which moment can imply a larger action. Pater takes up a different question about the same material. What Pater wants a critic to catch is “that true pictorial quality which lies between” mere skill and mere sentiment, the “inventive or creative handling of pure line and colour,” which is so often “quite independent of anything definitely poetical in the subject it accompanies.”

That’s why Pater says a true appreciation is possible “only in the light of a whole system of such art-casuistries,” and the word is a cheeky choice. Casuistry was the old practice of moral reasoning case by case, what confessors did when a general rule met a messy life, and it had a slippery reputation, so Pater borrows it with a wink. Lessing hands you something like a constitution, and Pater wants the case law, the critic working one picture at a time and asking what this painter did with this blue and that contour. His own examples show the switch, because he reaches for Dutch painting and for “Titian or Veronese,” painters whose best effects often have little to do with the story in the frame.

There’s a detail that makes the detour feel less like a detour. The marble group Lessing wrote about came out of the ground in a Roman vineyard in 1506, while Giorgione was alive and painting in Venice, and roughly two decades later Titian put a version of it into the Bacchus and Ariadne he painted for Alfonso d’Este, as a reveler in the foreground who wraps snakes around himself, which means Titian took the most famous image of agony in Rome and gave its contorted pose to a reveler in Bacchus’s procession. Lessing used the statue to fix the limits of the arts, while the Venetians treated it as a shape to lift out of stone and remake in paint.

In fairness to Lessing, he never said color doesn’t matter, and his book is better than its reputation as a rulebook, because its best pages are close readings of Homer that work case by case. Pater even shrinks him a little, calling his subject “the spheres of sculpture and poetry” when Lessing explicitly let the word painting cover every visual art, though the shrinking suits a book named after a statue. You could also argue that Pater’s “pictorial quality” is just the old mystery of talent with a nicer name, while Lessing at least gave critics a principle they could argue over. I’ll grant all of that, and Pater’s complaint still stands, since once you ask a painting only which bodies it shows, the handling that makes a Titian look like a Titian drops out of the conversation.

So the Laocoön comes before Venice because Pater needs its central idea, that every art answers to its own material, and needs just as badly to show that the question of suitable subjects leaves room for another question about the look of the painted surface. Venice is where the payoff is biggest, since the painters Pater is about to praise made pictures whose subjects people still can’t agree on and whose color nobody mistakes, and a viewer trained on Caylus’s scoreboard would rank them near the bottom. Pater keeps Lessing’s attention to the medium and directs it toward the particular charm of an artwork. That is the lens he needs before he says a word about Venice.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the main difference between Lessing’s and Pater’s uses of an artwork’s material qualities?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.