Philosophy
Why the Gym?
At the gym, Socrates sets out to examine Charmides’ soul—and finds his own self-control put to the test.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesPlato could have set a dialogue about self-control anywhere. He picked the one spot in Athens where everybody was half-naked and everybody was looking, and that was no accident.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The SettingCharmides 153a; 154c–155e
- The Central QuestionSocrates could have run into Charmides anywhere, but Plato puts them in a palaestra, the wrestling-school of a guy named Taureas, across from the shrine of a local goddess called Basile.
- A Closer LookThe timing matters too. Socrates walks in the day after getting home from the siege of Potidaea, and the gym was where Athens got its young men in shape for exactly the kind of fig
- The Wider ViewThe word Plato uses for statue is agalma, which mostly meant the statue of a god in a temple, so these kids aren’t just checking him out but practically worshipping him.
Socrates could have run into Charmides anywhere, but Plato puts them in a palaestra, the wrestling-school of a guy named Taureas, across from the shrine of a local goddess called Basile. Think of a palaestra as the neighborhood gym, a sand court for wrestling with rooms around it, where young guys stripped down and trained while older men hung out, talked and watched, so that working out and showing off happened in the same room. Plato knew the scene well enough to set another dialogue about love, the Lysis, in a brand-new palaestra, and in the Charmides he makes the setting do real work from page one.
The timing matters too. Socrates walks in the day after getting home from the siege of Potidaea, and the gym was where Athens got its young men in shape for exactly the kind of fighting he just survived, so he’s literally walking out of a real battle and into the practice space for battles, where sure enough the first thing the regulars want is war news. Then the talk turns to the young and the gym shows its other side, as a crowd of admirers comes in ahead of Charmides and every eye locks on the kid the moment he shows up. Socrates says the grown men gawking wasn’t that surprising, and that what really got him was the boys, because not one of them was looking anywhere else, “not even the littlest,” and they were all gazing at him “as if he were a statue.”
The word Plato uses for statue is agalma, which mostly meant the statue of a god in a temple, so these kids aren’t just checking him out but practically worshipping him. It fits the setting perfectly, because a palaestra was full of bodies meant to be looked at. Chaerephon asks Socrates whether the kid doesn’t have a lovely face, and then tops himself with “If he were willing to strip, you’d think he had no face at all, his figure is so perfectly beautiful.” Anywhere else that’s an outrageous thing to say out loud, but at the gym it’s just describing what usually happens next, since athletes trained naked and the guys on the benches had come to watch.
This is where you get to watch Socrates work, because he takes the gym’s own move and flips it. The boy would be unbeatable, he says, “if he has just one little thing more,” meaning a well-made soul, and since a kid that age must enjoy a good conversation, “why don’t we strip that very part of him, and take a look at it before we look at his figure?” He reuses Chaerephon’s verb, the ordinary word for undressing to work out, and nothing about the proposal breaks the gym’s rules except what’s getting undressed. It’s the first time the dialogue shows us what philosophy does, and instead of running away from the gym’s culture of looking people over, it takes that same frank looking and aims it at something your eyes can’t reach.
The gym also makes the whole meeting possible, because Critias has a setup ready. Charmides has been complaining that his head feels heavy when he gets up in the morning, so Critias sends a servant to tell him there’s a doctor here to see him, and Socrates is supposed to play along and pretend he knows “a remedy for the head.” The trick only works because of the gym’s mixed, easygoing crowd, where a teenager can be called over to sit with a bunch of older men and nobody thinks twice about it. A conversation about temperance needs exactly that, a young guy close enough to question and an audience close enough to hear every word.
Easygoing, though, is the one thing this gym can’t promise. When Charmides arrives he causes “a great deal of laughter,” because every man on the bench, Socrates included, shoves the guy next to him to make space, until one man at the end has to stand up and the guy at the other end gets tipped off sideways in a bit of pure slapstick. Charmides sits down right between Socrates and Critias, and Socrates realizes that the swagger he walked in with, “sure as I was that I would talk to him with the greatest of ease,” has been “knocked clean out of me.” Then Charmides gives him a look Socrates calls “beyond words,” the whole gym comes “swirling round us in a ring,” and Socrates catches a glimpse inside the kid’s cloak. “I was on fire,” he tells his friend, “and was no longer in my own possession.”
The gym even hands Plato the words for Socrates getting wrecked. He’s thrown before the first round even starts, his confidence knocked out of him in the one place in town where guys got knocked down for practice, and the man who just proposed looking at a soul before a body gets taken out by one look at a body. What he does next is grab a line of poetry to steady himself, Cydias’ warning to a lover who comes “a fawn, into the lion’s presence, to be caught as a portion of meat,” and then do the one thing that can save him, which is answer the kid’s question and start talking. Plato plays it for laughs, but the point is serious, because you can’t define temperance somewhere it never gets tested. Socrates has to practice the virtue in the exact spot where it’s easiest to lose, with a crowd watching, before he’s earned the right to ask anyone what it is.
That’s the real reason this dialogue starts at the gym. The palaestra was where Athens trained the body, the place where boys learned to control their limbs and where grown men’s eyes were the least controlled thing in the room, and Plato puts his conversation about temperance right where those two facts collide. The gym gives him his metaphors of stripping, sizing up and getting thrown, and it also gives him something better, a running test. Every argument that follows happens on a crowded bench next to a gorgeous kid in a room full of people watching, and every answer about what temperance is can be checked against how the man asking the questions is holding up.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does Socrates transform the palaestra’s customary practice of examining bodies into a philosophical activity?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If temperance must be tested under pressure rather than merely defined in words, what should count as convincing evidence that a person possesses it?→
- Does Socrates successfully redirect attention from Charmides’ body to his soul, or does his own reaction reveal limits to that philosophical transformation? Why?→
- How might the conversation about temperance change if it occurred in a private or less physically charged setting, and what would be gained or lost?→