Renaissance
Why the Artist’s Work Can Leave the Viewer Calm
Pater says an artist has to enter the life of the senses to give a viewer relief from it. Winckelmann’s ease with sculpture makes him a special case.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater separates what happens to a person looking at art from what it takes to make that art. His examples ask how close a critic can get to the artist’s work.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Repose is the viewer’s experienceA great sculpture can quiet the viewer’s senses even when the subject is full of life.
- Making takes immersionThe artist has to give intellectual and spiritual ideas a form that can be seen, heard or touched.
- A taste becomes a transgressionPater draws on Jonathan’s forbidden honey to describe the charge that ascetic prohibitions can give to sensory experience.
- Winckelmann has an unusual freedomPater imagines a critic who can handle pagan marbles closely without the conflict between attention and shame.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, the tranquil godship of sculpture · Note 310, Heiterkeit or repose · Winckelmann, the artist, the spectator and the senses · Note 316, Jonathan and the honey · Plato, Republic VII, the astronomy analogy in Jowett’s translation · Keats, letter to Benjamin Bailey, 22 November 1817 · 1 Samuel 14:43–45, Jonathan and the honey · Michelangelo, the late sonnet Giunto è già, with text
You know the feeling when you walk out of a good museum on a hot afternoon and everything in your head has gone quiet, as if somebody turned down a radio you didn’t know was playing. Pater knows it too, and he’s willing to grant the old line that art offers an escape from “the tyranny of the senses,” at least for the person doing the looking, who “may find that the spectacle of supreme works of art takes from the life of the senses something of its turbid fever.” Greek marble is the classic case, since it shows “the tranquil godship” in a person instead of the accidents of a busy day. Up to this point it’s the museum-as-spa theory, and he signs off on it.
Then he flips it, and the flip is the whole point of the passage. The calm “is possible for the spectator only because the artist, in producing those works, has gradually sunk his intellectual and spiritual ideas in sensuous form,” which means the quiet you carry home was manufactured by someone who went deeper into the senses instead of climbing out of them. Think of an air-conditioned room in July, where the cool air exists because a compressor out back runs hot and loud, and Pater wants you to remember the compressor, because the theory of art as escape forgets who did the work, and it quietly assumes that whatever refreshes the viewer must have been made in the same refreshed state.
His sketch of that worker is wild, and he builds it out of two borrowed pieces, a poet and a Platonic punchline. “He may live, as Keats lived, a pure life; but his soul, like that of Plato’s false astronomer, becomes more and more immersed in sense, until nothing which lacks the appeal to sense has interest for him.” The astronomer comes from the seventh book of the Republic, where Glaucon praises astronomy for making the soul look upward and Socrates shoots him down, saying that a man can gaze up at the sky and still direct his thought downward if he is concerned only with visible things. Pater takes Plato’s insult and turns it into a job description, so the artist is exactly the guy with his eyes on the ceiling. Keats fits the part too, since in November 1817 he wrote to his friend Benjamin Bailey, “O for a life of sensation rather than of thoughts!”
The difference between the two roles is a difference in where you end up, because the spectator goes in and comes back out, while the artist goes in and stays. “How could such an one ever again endure the greyness of the ideal or spiritual world?” Pater asks, and he says the painter “steeps his thought again and again” in color the way a dyer dips cloth in the vat. It’s the gap between a diner and a chef, where the diner has one great meal and goes home soothed, and the chef, after twenty years of tasting everything, can’t stand bland food anymore. The diner’s contentment rests on a palate that has been permanently changed, and Pater doesn’t treat that change as a sickness, only as the price of the job.
The German word at the center of the Greek ideal helps here, because Heiterkeit, as the edition’s note explains, means cheerfulness, clarity and serenity at once, and Pater renders it with a pair, “blitheness or repose.” Read with the spectator and the artist in mind, the pair suggests two sides of the experience. The viewer can receive repose from a work whose maker had to stay alert to surface and color. A Greek statue holds both, which is why it can calm you down without looking dead, and why Pater can’t accept a theory of art that keeps only the calm half.
The Christian setting turns the artist’s immersion into something hotter, and that’s where Jonathan and his honey come in. In First Samuel, Saul has sworn that none of his soldiers will eat before evening, and his son Jonathan, who never heard the oath, dips the end of his staff in wild honey, and when he’s found out he says, in the King James words Pater borrows, “I did but taste a little honey with the end of the rod that was in mine hand,” and Saul declares that he must die. The people intervene and save him. A faith that discredits “the slightest touch of sense” makes even a taste feel like a capital crime, so artists who keep tasting start to feel like rebels, and Pater says this “imparts to genuine artistic interests a kind of intoxication.” The rush comes from the guilt, the way a midnight snack tastes better when you’ve sworn off sugar.
Winckelmann is the strange case, because he’s a spectator by trade, and yet he handles the marbles with the closeness of a maker and none of the fever. “From this intoxication Winckelmann is free,” Pater says, and the next phrase is one of the best in the essay, since he “fingers those pagan marbles with unsinged hands, with no sense of shame or loss.” He can do it because, for the Greek, immersion in the sensuous was “religiously, at least, indifferent,” so that Greek sensuousness “does not fever the conscience” and stays “shameless and childlike.” Winckelmann borrows that indifference and gets the artist’s intimacy without the artist’s guilt, which is a rare deal and, if you’re Pater, a model for what criticism could become.
I buy Pater’s economics and doubt his one-way door. He’s right that the spectator’s calm is borrowed, and right that a criticism which praises art for cooling us off while frowning at the appetites of artists is biting the hand that cooled it. But the claim that an immersed artist can never again endure the gray of the spiritual world goes too far, and Pater’s own Renaissance supplies the counterexample, since Michelangelo in old age wrote a sonnet saying that neither painting nor sculpture could quiet a soul turned toward the divine love that opened its arms on the cross. Immersion is a strong tendency, and some artists do swim back to shore. What holds up in the passage is the debt itself and Winckelmann’s odd exemption from it, and those two together make this one of the sharpest pages in the essay.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What central assumption does Pater challenge in the theory that art provides an escape from the senses?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the spectator’s repose depends on the artist’s sustained immersion in sensation, what obligations—if any—does the spectator have toward the artist or the conditions of artistic creation?→
- Does the distinction between a spectator who returns from sensuous experience and an artist who remains immersed in it accurately describe artistic work, or does it make the two roles too rigid?→
- What does Winckelmann’s freedom from guilt suggest about whether artistic “intoxication” comes from sensory experience itself or from the religious and moral judgments placed upon it?→