Philosophy
Why Plato Needs the Crazy Friend
Chaerephon’s enthusiasm gives Plato a way to test what self-control actually looks like.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesChaerephon jumps up, grabs Socrates’ hand, and gushes about the boy’s body. His brief turn in the spotlight sets the tone for a dialogue about self-control.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The friend at the doorChaerephon jumps up, runs to Socrates, and grabs his hand as soon as he sees his friend back from Potidaea.
- Enthusiasm spreadsWhen Chaerephon praises Charmides’ body, others agree, and the crowd’s attention settles on the young man.
- From body to soulSocrates takes up Chaerephon’s talk of undressing and suggests examining Charmides’ soul. Soon he must recover his own composure.
- Composure and candorChaerephon’s open excitement contrasts with Critias’s efforts to hide his perplexity. The contrast complicates what it means to have self-control.
If you only know Chaerephon from the Charmides, you know him for about a page and a half. He’s the one who spots Socrates coming into the wrestling-school and, “madman that he is,” jumps up from the middle of the crowd, runs over and seizes him by the hand, and a little later he’s the one calling across the room to ask whether the new kid hasn’t got a lovely face, before topping his own compliment with the claim that if the boy stripped you’d forget he had a face at all. After that he never speaks again, not once in the twenty-odd pages of argument that follow, and Plato doesn’t even bother to tell us whether he’s still in the room.
Outside this dialogue Chaerephon was a minor celebrity in his own right. He’s Socrates’ ride-or-die friend, the guy who went all the way to Delphi to ask the oracle whether anyone was wiser than Socrates, and in the Apology Socrates remembers him as vehement in whatever he set about, while Aristophanes, in the Clouds, made fun of him as a pale, half-dead inmate of Socrates’ “Thinkery.” So when Socrates introduces him here with the word manikos, “crazy,” he isn’t insulting him. It’s an affectionate nickname for a man who did everything at full speed, the way you’d describe the friend who shows up at the airport with a homemade sign and won’t stop hugging you.
There’s a decent case that Chaerephon is just there to get the scene moving. Somebody has to greet Socrates, sit him down and ask for the war news, and somebody has to say out loud what the whole room is thinking about Charmides’ body, and the excitable best friend is a stock character who can do both jobs quickly and then step aside. On that reading Critias could have handled the greeting and the crowd could have handled the gushing, and the dialogue would lose a bit of color and nothing else.
I think that undersells him, and the reason is that one word, manikos. In Greek ethics the opposite of being sōphrōn, temperate, of sound mind, is being out of your mind, and Plato opens a dialogue whose whole subject is sōphrosynē by introducing a man as crazy before he’s said a single word. That’s a loaded choice for a writer who thought hard about madness, because in the Phaedrus Plato has Socrates argue that the madness which comes from the gods is finer than the self-control that comes from human beings, which tells you he never treated madness as simply the bad opposite of temperance. Chaerephon’s madness is the lovable kind, loyalty and enthusiasm turned up to full volume, and putting him first makes the reader wonder what, if anything, is actually wrong with a man like that.
Look at the two things he actually does in his page and a half, because each one shows a different kind of attachment. First he grabs Socrates’ hand and needs to know he’s alive, which is friendship at its most physical and least guarded, the attachment of a man who loves his friend for who he is. Then, a few minutes later, he’s raving about a teenager’s body and egging the room on, which is attachment of a very different kind, and “the others all said the same as Chaerephon,” so his enthusiasm turns into the crowd’s chant. Between them those two moments lay out the two loves that the opening of the dialogue is going to sort through, the love of a friend and the love of a beautiful body, and Chaerephon brings both into the room with the same full-throttle energy.
Then Socrates takes that energy and does something with it. He picks up Chaerephon’s talk of stripping and turns it toward the soul, and a few lines later, sitting next to the boy, he finds himself in something like Chaerephon’s condition, “on fire” and beside himself, which is about as close to manikos as Socrates ever admits to getting. The difference is what he does next, because he steadies himself and starts a conversation, while Chaerephon, as far as the text goes, simply drops out of the story. Plato seems to be handing the scene from the friend who gets carried away to the friend who can get carried away and still talk his way back.
There’s one more contrast the opening sets up, and it’s with Critias, who is cool, connected and in control, the guardian who stages the boy’s entrance and arranges a fake doctor’s visit to get him into a chair. On paper Critias looks a lot more temperate than the guy sprinting across the gym. Later, though, when the argument corners him, Critias is the one who can’t admit he’s stuck, while nothing about Chaerephon is hidden at all, since the madman wears everything on his face and the composed man turns out to be managing appearances, which is a useful thing to have noticed before anyone tries to define temperance.
As a piece of plot the opening could survive without Chaerephon, since someone else could greet Socrates and someone else could praise the boy, but the argument would lose its first exhibit, a man with none of the everyday kind of temperance whom everyone loves, whom Socrates loves back, and who never once pretends to be anything other than what he is. Whatever temperance turns out to be, Plato makes sure we meet Chaerephon before we try to define it, so that we can’t mistake it for being cool and composed, or for the absence of the kind of fire that sends a man running across a room to grab his friend’s hand.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author consider Plato’s introduction of Chaerephon as manikos especially significant?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If Chaerephon lacks everyday composure but is loyal, sincere, and lovable, what qualities should count as genuine temperance?→
- How does the contrast between emotionally transparent Chaerephon and appearance-managing Critias complicate the assumption that calm behavior reveals good character?→
- Why might Plato introduce the dialogue’s central problem through Chaerephon’s behavior before allowing the characters to define temperance explicitly?→