Renaissance
Why Pater’s Gods Are Shown After the Action
Apollo has shot his arrow and Venus already holds the apple. Pater sees a whole story in what the sculptor leaves behind.
The Renaissance (1893)Putting an action just before or just after its climax gives a still figure a different kind of life. Pater’s two gods show how repose can contain a history.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Apollo’s arrow has gonePater reads the figure as a god in the instant after the act that cleared the ground for his oracle.
- Venus already has the prizeThe apple lets a still figure carry a memory of the contest and a hint of the war the story sets in motion.
- Lessing leaves room on both sidesLessing’s examples include Medea before her act and Ajax in the aftermath of his frenzy.
- The still figure has a pastPater’s choice of the finished action makes it possible to recognize what happened without waiting to see its outcome.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, Apollo, Venus and the finished action · Winckelmann, the Venus of Melos as a visible ideal · Note 305, the Venus of Melos · Vatican Museums, the Apollo Belvedere · Louvre, Venus de Milo and the nearby apple-holding hand · Lessing, Laocoön, Medea and Ajax
There’s a famous movie habit where the hero walks calmly toward the camera while a building explodes behind him and he doesn’t even turn around, because the job is done and turning around would suggest some doubt about it. Pater spots the same instinct at work in Greek sculpture, two thousand years before Hollywood. “When a more complex and significant action is permitted,” he writes, “it is most often represented as just finished, so that eager expectancy is excluded, as in the image of Apollo just after the slaughter of the Python, or of Venus with the apple of Paris already in her hand.” It’s a sharp observation about timing, and it explains more about his idea of Greek repose than almost anything else in the chapter.
Start with the Apollo, since his story is the simplest of the two. In the old Greek story the young god shot the monstrous serpent Python at Delphi and founded his oracle on the spot, and Pater uses a familiar reading of the Apollo Belvedere as the god just after he has loosed an arrow. The pose supports the reading, although the particular target is an interpretation. Nothing is left pending in that pose, since the serpent is dead and the shrine is as good as founded, and what the statue gives you is a god standing in the clear air that his victory has made, with the whole story compressed into his calm.
The Venus works the same way with an even longer story behind her. The apple is the golden prize that Paris awarded her in the beauty contest of the goddesses, so the contest is over and she has won, and since her bribe was the promise of Helen, the Trojan War is already set in motion in that small round thing in her hand. The Venus of Melos may be one of these figures. The Louvre notes that a hand holding an apple was found near the statue, while the pose also allows for a different reconstruction in which she holds a shield. Either way, the goddess holds a finished victory and a coming catastrophe, and she doesn’t seem troubled by either.
It helps to set Pater beside Lessing, who argued in his Laocoön (1766) that a painter or sculptor should never show the climax of an action and should choose an instant that gives the imagination room to move. One of his examples was an ancient painting of Medea shown before she kills her children, still torn between love and rage. Pater’s rule agrees that the climax must be avoided and then sends the imagination in the opposite direction. Lessing’s Medea points forward and builds suspense, while Pater’s gods point backward and invite memory, and memory, unlike suspense, is compatible with repose. Lessing himself admired another painting by the same ancient artist, Timomachus, which showed Ajax after his fit of madness, sitting among the animals he had slaughtered and coming to his senses, so even he granted that the moment after could be full, as long as it was charged with what had just happened.
That’s the deeper reason the rule matters to Pater. Greek sculpture, he says, shows “a motion ever kept in reserve, and very seldom committed to any definite action,” and the actions it prefers “would be without significance, except in a divine person,” like “binding on a sandal, or preparing for the bath.” The just-finished act is the one way a significant action can enter that world without breaking its calm, since it gives the figure a past without pushing it into a plot. You know what Apollo did, and you don’t have to wonder what happens next.
There are obvious counterexamples, and Pater’s “most often” leaves room for them. Myron’s famous Discus Thrower catches an athlete at the very peak of his wind-up, the most suspenseful instant in all of sport, and Praxiteles made an Apollo poised to stab a lizard climbing a tree trunk, which is technically a moment before. But the Discus Thrower is a mortal athlete, and the lizard-slaying Apollo turns suspense into a joke, since nobody is biting their nails over the fate of a lizard. And Pater’s own example of sculpture at the climax is the Laocoön, which he treats as a sign that the art had begun to stray.
The best way to understand the rule is as a piece of theology. In the examples Pater chooses, the completed act makes divine confidence visible, which is why the Apollo can look almost bored with the dead dragon and the Venus can hold the most dangerous apple in history with perfect composure. Showing the act as finished is a way of showing what it means to be divine, to have your victories as settled facts rather than live events, and the repose Pater loves is the visible form of that certainty. Even the Python’s death works this way in the myth, where the god kills the serpent to clear the ground for his oracle, and the statue shows the new owner standing on ground already cleared.
My verdict is that Pater’s observation about timing is one of the most useful things in the chapter. It explains how Greek figures can carry whole stories without becoming illustrations of them, by placing the story behind the figure instead of in front of it, and it shows why the mortal subjects, the athlete winding up and the priest wrestling snakes, keep straining his rule. The gods walk away from the explosion without looking back, and the sculptors who showed them that way were telling you something exact about the difference between a god and everybody else.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, how does Pater differ from Lessing even though both avoid depicting an action's climax?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a sculpture shows the aftermath rather than the approach to an action, how does that change the viewer's role in reconstructing its story?→
- Does the uncertain reconstruction of the Venus of Melos—as holding an apple or perhaps a shield—strengthen or weaken the article's argument about finished action? Why?→
- Do the Discus Thrower, the lizard-slaying Apollo, and the Laocoön genuinely challenge Pater's rule, or do the article's distinctions between mortal and divine subjects adequately account for them?→