Renaissance

Why Hermione Comes to Life in Pater’s Dresden

Pater reaches for Shakespeare’s statue scene to describe what happened when Winckelmann encountered ancient sculpture.

Hermione’s movement lets Pater show what it means for something long considered lost to feel present again. Paulina’s staging also makes the comparison more complicated.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The figure movesHermione steps down when Paulina calls for music, and Leontes discovers that the hand he takes is warm.
  • An encounter changes the viewerPater uses the scene to describe how a body carved in stone could set Winckelmann’s imagination in motion.
  • Something preserved becomes visibleHermione explains that she kept herself alive in hope of seeing her daughter, which gives Pater’s revival a model in discovery.
  • Someone prepares the scenePaulina’s curtain and music recall the arrangements through which collectors and critics present the ancient past to others.

The paragraph builds to its image through a run of exclamations. When Winckelmann first meets ancient sculpture at Dresden, Pater says, “On a sudden the imagination feels itself free,” and he gives the mind’s response in a burst of inner speech. “How facile and direct, it seems to say, is this life of the senses and the understanding, when once we have apprehended it! Here, surely, is that more liberal mode of life we have been seeking so long, so near to us all the while.” Then comes the critique of what blocked it, the efforts “by mystic passion, and monastic reverie,” which “have deflowered the flesh,” and finally the image, “Hermione melts from her stony posture, and the lost proportions of life right themselves.”

The reference is to the last scene of Shakespeare’s The Winter’s Tale. King Leontes, mad with jealousy, has destroyed his wife Hermione, who was reported dead sixteen years earlier, and now her friend Paulina shows him what she calls a statue of the queen. Leontes marvels at its “natural posture” and asks whether the stone doesn’t rebuke him for being more stone than it. Paulina calls for music and commands, “be stone no more,” the figure moves and steps down, and Leontes, touching her hand, cries “O, she’s warm!” adding that if this is magic, “let it be an art / Lawful as eating.” Shakespeare keeps the audience in suspense as well, since nobody in the theater has been told that Hermione survived, and the scene works by letting everyone believe for a moment that art has done the impossible.

The first thing the image does is join a body’s movement to the mind’s release. The statue warms and moves, and in the same instant the onlookers’ frozen grief thaws, so the physical event and the emotional one are the same event. That’s exactly what Pater claims happened to Winckelmann at Dresden, where seeing bodies carved in stone freed his imagination from a culture of “mystic passion, and monastic reverie” that had “deflowered the flesh.” The stone body comes alive, and the mind that looks at it comes alive too. Pater’s verbs carry the same double action, since “melts” belongs to snow and stone alike, and “right themselves” describes both a body standing up and a balance being restored.

The details of the play make the choice even sharper. A gentleman in the previous scene reports that the statue is the work of “that rare Italian master, Julio Romano.” The reported attribution lets the audience expect a Renaissance work of art. The play is called The Winter’s Tale, and Pater’s paragraph begins with the Renaissance “in the midst of a frozen world,” when “the buried fire of ancient art rose up from under the soil,” so the thaw of the season and the thaw of history line up with the thaw of a woman. The sixteen-year gap in the play even mirrors the long burial of ancient art.

The most important detail is that Hermione was never a statue. Hermione says she preserved herself because Paulina gave her hope that Perdita was still alive. Shakespeare leaves the practical details of how she lived during those years largely outside the scene. That fits Pater’s claim with uncanny precision, since he says the liberal life of the Greeks was “so near to us all the while,” never really dead, only concealed by centuries that didn’t want to see it. The Renaissance, in this picture, didn’t resurrect antiquity so much as reveal it, the way Hermione’s apparent resurrection is really a revelation, and the image carries that historical argument inside a single line.

That’s how an individual experience does the work of a larger historical revival. Pater says that “Winckelmann here reproduces for us the earlier sentiment of the Renaissance,” and the comparison brings one man’s encounter into contact with a longer history. The discovery of the Laocoön in Rome in 1506 gives the recovery of antique bodies a concrete example. The play gives Pater a way to make that leap feel natural, because Hermione’s return is both a private reunion between a husband and wife and a public restoration that heals a kingdom and reunites a lost generation, exactly the double scale the paragraph needs.

There’s a subtler implication, too, which may cut against Pater’s enthusiasm. Hermione’s revival is staged, with Paulina managing the curtain, the music and the timing, and the onlookers are told to wake their faith before anything happens. Winckelmann’s Greece was staged in a similar way, assembled from Roman copies, restored marbles and the arrangements of collectors, so the life that warms in the stone is partly the work of the people who set the scene. That doesn’t make the experience false, any more than Leontes’ joy is false, but it reminds us that revivals always have a Paulina behind them. Pater’s own prose does some of Paulina’s work by directing our attention to the moment the figure seems to move.

My verdict is that Hermione rises in the Dresden paragraph because the scene joins bodily movement, the release of imagination and the return of something thought lost forever. The play’s details, the Italian master, the winter, the sixteen years, the woman who was alive and hidden all along, let one man’s encounter with sculpture stand for a whole civilization’s recovery of antiquity. And the theatrical staging of the revival adds a quiet note of realism to Pater’s rapture, since the past comes back to life when someone has prepared the scene, and the warmth is real all the same.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, why is Hermione’s movement an especially fitting image for Winckelmann’s encounter with ancient sculpture?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.