Renaissance
Why Hegel’s Memnon Is Still Waiting
Pater imagines a statue waiting for Greek light to give it a voice. The monument that inspired the image had its own Egyptian history and acquired its Greek name much later.
The Renaissance (1893)A broken portrait of Amenhotep III drew ancient visitors who thought they heard Memnon. Its history makes a better example of how viewers bring stories to stone than of how one culture gives another a voice.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A figure for architecturePater borrows Hegel’s Memnon to picture a building that can hint at a mood a poem could put into words.
- The monument before the storyThe two colossi represent Amenhotep III and belonged to the pharaoh’s temple near Thebes.
- An audience listensStrabo heard a sound near the broken figure but doubted that he could identify where it came from.
- A name supplied by visitorsThe identification with a figure from the Trojan War shows how people brought their own stories to an Egyptian monument.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, pp. 136–137, architecture and the waiting Memnon · Winckelmann, note 308 · Winckelmann, p. 137, the complexity of the other arts · Winckelmann, p. 147, media and historical forms of expression
Pater builds his history of the arts like a staircase, and he gives the bottom step a haunting image. “The art of Egypt, with its supreme architectural effects,” he writes, “is, according to Hegel’s beautiful comparison, a Memnon waiting for the day, the day of the Greek spirit, the humanistic spirit, with its power of speech.” The idea is that architecture can only hint at what its makers felt, so that a whole civilization built in stone stood there like a giant statue waiting for sunlight to make it sing. It’s a gorgeous sentence, and it does real work in Pater’s argument, but the statue it names has a history that complicates every part of the metaphor.
The staircase itself is clear enough, and Pater sets it out in a few strong sentences. Architecture, he says, “begins in a practical need” and can express its maker’s spirit only “by vague hint or symbol,” so that its moods “lurk about architectural form as volatile effects, to be gathered from it by reflexion.” Sculpture comes next, dealing “immediately with man,” and after it painting, music and poetry, “the special arts of the romantic and modern ages.” Near the end of the chapter he states the scheme outright, matching sculpture to “the unperplexed, emphatic outlines of Hellenic humanism,” painting to the Middle Ages and music and poetry to the modern world. It’s Hegel’s ladder of the arts, in which each medium suits a stage in the mind’s growing knowledge of itself.
Now for the statue itself, which deserves a closer look than either Hegel or Pater gave it. The so-called Colossi of Memnon are enormous seated figures of Amenhotep III near Thebes. The northern figure was damaged in antiquity, and a sound was reported around dawn. Visitors associated it with Memnon, the Ethiopian king of Greek myth who died at Troy, greeting his mother Eos.
The tourists left their reviews carved into its legs, like entries in a stone guestbook. The geographer Strabo says he heard a sound at the first hour and could not determine its source. When Hadrian and Sabina visited in 130 CE, Julia Balbilla commemorated the visit in Aeolic Greek. Her poems record both silence and sound. The tradition that a later repair silenced the figure is part of the monument’s afterlife too.
Look at what that history does to Hegel’s picture. The sound was associated with the damaged statue, and its cause remains uncertain. The name was Greek too, laid over a pharaoh’s portrait by visitors who wanted the monument to belong to their own stories. So the Memnon who waits for the Greek day is already a Greek invention, and the speech his visitors heard gives the broken monument a story drawn from their own world, which makes the metaphor a more accurate picture of how Greeks and Europeans heard Egypt than of Egypt itself.
The assumptions underneath the metaphor need checking too, starting with Egypt’s supposed silence. Ancient Egypt had a long written tradition that included tales, hymns and instructions. A visitor who could not read that writing had met a limit of their own knowledge. Nor was Egyptian art mainly architecture in Pater’s sense, since the Memnon itself is a portrait statue, and Egyptian sculptors could carve figures as alert as the Louvre’s Seated Scribe, found at Saqqara in 1850. The figure gives us something the ranking obscures. An Egyptian sculptor had already found a way to make a person’s attention visible in stone.
Still, the image does capture something Pater cares about, and he’s more generous to architecture than his staircase suggests. His own sentence about the architect is full of feeling, since the builder “closes his sadness over him, or wanders in the perplexed intricacies of things, or projects his purpose from him clean-cut and sincere, or bares himself to the sunlight,” and late in his life Pater wrote moving essays on the cathedrals of Amiens and Vézelay. The point of the Memnon is that architecture’s spirit has to be gathered by a viewer who brings the light, and that’s a fair description of how buildings mean, even if it’s an unfair description of a civilization.
My verdict is that the waiting Memnon supports Pater’s history of artistic media as a metaphor for how each art expresses mind, from the hint of a building to the speech of a poem, and fails as a claim about Egypt. To hold together, it needs an Egypt with no voice of its own and a Greece whose light alone can make stone speak, and the actual statue answers both assumptions, since the figure already had a name and a purpose in Egypt before visitors associated a sound with the Greek Memnon. Read that way, the Memnon is still waiting, and what it’s waiting for is a viewer willing to hear Egypt in its own language.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article say the statue’s history most importantly complicates Hegel’s metaphor?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does interpreting another culture become an act of listening, and when does it become the imposition of the interpreter’s own story?→
- Can Pater’s metaphor remain valuable if its historical picture of Egypt is rejected? Why or why not?→
- What responsibilities does a viewer have when meaning must be “gathered” from a building, statue, or other work rather than stated directly?→