Renaissance

Why Greek Statues Never Have a Bad Day

Pater calls the Greek sculptor’s search for permanent form universality. Luca keeps the same care in choosing details and gives it to expressions that are about to change.

Winckelmann’s ideal helps Pater explain why a face can remain calm even on a moving body. Later Greek work complicates the pattern, and Tuscan relief gives Pater a different use for the same restraint.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Universality begins with selectionPater’s Greek sculptor keeps the features that will outlast an occasion. A passing mood can drop out while the body remains recognizable.
  • The selection has a priceA figure can retain calm and clarity across centuries. Pater thinks it then has less room to show one person’s feeling at a particular moment.
  • Michelangelo wants the individual historyHe looks for ways to let intense feeling emerge from stone without fixing it into a grimace. Pater sees that aim in his unfinished surfaces.
  • Luca uses restraint for another purposeTuscan relief selects sparingly, as Pater thinks the Greeks did. A few chosen lines and shadows can suggest the particular face or fleeting expression the Greek ideal tends to leave aside.

Pater’s account of sculpture has three parts, and the first rests on a German word he glosses for us as “breadth, generality, universality.” The word is Allgemeinheit (universality), which he credits to Winckelmann, Goethe and many German critics, and it names the law that led Pheidias and his pupils “constantly to seek the type in the individual, to abstract and express only what is structural and permanent, to purge from the individual all that belongs only to him, all the accidents, the feelings and actions of the special moment.” In plain terms, the Greek sculptor edited out the moment, and everything else in Pater’s scheme is measured against that edit. In his 1755 essay on imitating Greek works, Winckelmann praised their edle Einfalt und stille Größe (noble simplicity and quiet grandeur), and Pater’s German word belongs to the same family of thought, a calm achieved by subtraction.

The reason for the edit comes in a parenthesis that does a lot of work. In Pater’s account the sculptor removes the expressions that tend to look frozen when arrested. That gives him an answer to the hard realism he has just described, since a sculptor who carves no passing expression has nothing that can freeze. You can see the method in a section of the Parthenon frieze in the British Museum, where horsemen ride rearing, plunging horses in the great procession and their faces stay perfectly serene, as if the bodies were in a cavalry charge and the heads were at a concert. Polykleitos gives a related example. His lost Canon concerned bodily proportions, and the Doryphoros, or Spear-bearer, survives in Roman copies. An ideal arrangement of parts can give a body its character even when the person remains anonymous.

The result, Pater says, is that these works “came to be like some subtle extract or essence, or almost like pure thoughts or ideas,” and the phrase isn’t accidental from a man who spent years lecturing on Plato and published Plato and Platonism in 1893. A Greek statue on this account is something like a Form made visible, a body with every accident skimmed off so that only the type remains, and Pater draws the consequence himself, that this detachment from “a particular place or people” carried Greek influence far beyond its own age and won it universal acceptance.

A small story in Plutarch’s life of Pericles imagines this kind of selection at work. Plutarch says Pericles had an unusually long head and takes that as the reason he is so often shown in a helmet, so the most famous statesman of classical Athens comes down to us with his one distinctive physical feature tucked out of sight. The portraits that survive in Roman copies show a calm, idealized face under the helmet’s brim, the type of the statesman rather than the man with the odd skull, which is Allgemeinheit applied to a living person, with his accidents carefully purged.

The trade has a price, and Pater names it plainly. The Greek way “involved to a certain degree the sacrifice of what we call expression,” and its range of effects had “limits somewhat narrowly defined,” since a figure purged of the passing moment can’t show a particular soul in a particular hour. That’s why Pater’s second system belongs to Michelangelo, whose genius, shaped by the inwardness of the Middle Ages, wanted exactly what the Greeks threw away, “individual character and feeling, the special history of the special soul,” and had to find his own way of showing it without collapsing into caricature.

The third system is where the German word earns its place. Midway between the Greeks and Michelangelo, Pater puts Luca and the Tuscans, “partaking both of the Allgemeinheit of the Greeks, their way of extracting certain select elements only of pure form and sacrificing all the rest,” and of Michelangelo’s studied incompleteness. The Tuscans keep the Greek habit of selection, working through what Pater calls “a system of conventionalism as skilful and subtle as that of the Greeks,” but what they select is the passing, individual expression the Greeks left out, so their faces are personal without being heavy.

Pater’s Greeks deserve a little skepticism, though, because his picture emphasizes one possibility in classical sculpture. Later Greek artists also carved dying warriors, old women and straining athletes. The Dying Gaul in the Capitoline Museums, a Roman copy after a Hellenistic model, makes the strain of one body in one moment hard to miss. Much of what Pater knew of Greek sculpture also reached him through Roman copies and bleached surfaces, so his Greeks are tidier, whiter and more uniformly calm than the real ones were.

My verdict is that the scheme still works as a lens even if it simplifies the history. What Greek sculpture gains by removing a moment is permanence and reach, a figure that can’t freeze and that everyone, anywhere, can recognize, and what it loses is the individual soul in its passing state. Pater uses Allgemeinheit less as a rule than as a measuring rod, and against it Tuscan relief looks distinctive for a precise reason, since it keeps the Greek economy of selection and spends it on the fleeting expression that his Greek ideal leaves aside.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why, in Pater’s account, does the Greek sculptor remove expressions tied to a passing moment?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.