Renaissance

Why Do Rival Stories Make Love Responsible for Giorgione’s Death?

Vasari tells of fatal contagion and Ridolfi repeats a story of betrayal. An inventory and a note in a copy of Dante tell a different kind of story.

Records place Giorgione’s death in Venice’s plague of 1510, while the love stories reveal how early biographers shaped the end of a painter’s life.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Two stories turn on a loverVasari attributes the plague infection to Giorgione’s visits to his lover, while Ridolfi records a version in which a pupil betrays him.
  • An inventory places the deathArchival records link his last illness and death to the Lazzaretto Nuovo, a Venetian quarantine island.
  • An inscription gives a dateA death notice in a 1497 copy of Dante gives September 17, 1510, and records that Giorgione was thirty-six.
  • Pater hears an echo in the artPater’s account of a fleeting kiss makes it easier to see why early biographers wanted the artist’s death to resemble the art they associated with him.

Pater tells the end of Giorgione’s life like a novella. Around “his thirty-fourth year,” at one of the musical parties he gave for friends, the painter met a lady and fell in love, and “they rejoiced greatly,” says Vasari, “the one and the other, in their loves.” Then Pater notes that “two quite different legends” about her “agree in this, that it was through this lady he came by his death.” In Ridolfi’s version, “being robbed of her by one of his pupils, he died of grief at the double treason,” and in Vasari’s, she was secretly sick with plague, and “Giorgione took the sickness from her mortally, along with her kisses, and so briefly departed.” The question is why both biographers needed a woman to kill him.

Start with what the documents actually say, since they’ve improved a lot since Pater’s day. In early November 1510 Isabella d’Este’s agent in Venice confirmed that Giorgione had died of plague, and in 2011 the historian Renata Segre published records showing he had been sent to the Lazzaretto Nuovo, a quarantine island in the lagoon, and that he died there. The surviving inventory and its supplement valued the listed goods at eighty-nine ducats. In 2019 scholars published a note found in a copy of Dante in the University of Sydney Library, recording that Giorgione of Castelfranco died of plague in Venice on 17 September 1510, aged thirty-six. That makes him a couple of years older than Vasari’s thirty-four, so even the age in the legend is a little off.

Vasari’s story is built to explain the death itself. It turns contagion into a kiss, so that the disease that killed thousands of anonymous Venetians that year becomes a private, almost chosen fate, the lover dying of love. Vasari had a taste for endings like this, since he says Raphael too died after indulging his amorous pleasures beyond measure, coming home with a fever his doctors mistreated. A death that rhymes with a life satisfies a biographer, and Giorgione, the musician who painted lovers in meadows, got a death that rhymes with his pictures.

In 1648 Ridolfi repeated the plague story and offered an alternative that makes grief the cause of death. In his telling the thief was a pupil, whom he names as Pietro Luzzo of Feltre, and the “double treason” is a lover’s and an apprentice’s at once. That plot carries a painter’s anxiety as much as a lover’s, because the nightmare of a master with followers is that they’ll take what’s his, his manner as well as his mistress. By Ridolfi’s time the market was crowded with so-called Giorgiones by other hands, and a story about a pupil stealing the master’s beloved sits very comfortably beside a history of pupils absorbing the master’s style. The names and biographies of painters associated with Feltre became entangled in later accounts. For Ridolfi’s story, Luzzo’s role as a pupil matters more than the uncertain identification.

Pater himself shows why love seemed the right cause. Describing the subjects Giorgione’s school liked to catch in an instant, he lists “the embrace, rapid as the kiss, caught with death itself from dying lips,” which is very close to Vasari’s account of the painter’s death. The legend and the pictures feed each other, since the paintings are full of lovers, music and pauses, and readers who had absorbed them wanted a biography in the same key. Plague is random and anonymous, and love gives the death a face, so both stories reach for the one cause that makes his death feel like one of his paintings.

The evidence can be weighed separately from the romance, and it’s worth doing carefully. The plague is documented three times over, by a letter written within weeks, by the quarantine records and by the Sydney note, while the woman is documented by nobody who knew him. The Lazzaretto Nuovo tells us where Giorgione was held. The record gives no chain of transmission. It leaves Vasari’s account of the infection unconfirmed and gives no support to death from grief.

There’s a fair case for the romance too, and it deserves stating. Vasari’s first edition appeared in 1550, close enough to preserve some memories from the painter’s circle. That possibility gives the story interest without making it evidence for the source of an infection. Vasari also had his own reasons to make the story tender instead of squalid, since a painter dying among the poor on a quarantine island makes a grim last chapter for one of the heroes of his book. Even so, a true detail can be chosen and shaped to fit a story, and the fact that Vasari made the lady the cause, instead of a neighbor or a servant or a patron, is the part that belongs to literature rather than to the record.

So my verdict is that the rival stories make love responsible because both biographers needed his death to rhyme with his art, one by turning contagion into a kiss and the other by turning followers into thieves. The documents give us plague, an island, a date and a small estate, and they never name a woman as the source of his illness. When Pater says the two legends “agree in this,” he’s pointing at the giveaway, since what rival legends agree on is usually what an audience wanted to believe, and what Giorgione’s audience wanted was a painter who died the way his figures live.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What conclusion does the article consider best supported by the surviving historical records?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.