Greek Antiquity
Why Ask a Conqueror for Peace?
The strength that drives off wild creatures is asked to keep sickness and ruin away from the people singing.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsThe hymn pairs Herakles’ all-conquering heart with his longing for a peace that can raise children. At the close, the dangers he is asked to fight are sickness, ruin, and harsh dooms.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The opening praises forceHerakles is described as strong-handed, unsubdued, and all-conquering.
- The enemy can be read as wild creaturesThe Greek for savage tribes can refer to untamed kinds of animals, which fits the beasts of the labors.
- Peace nurtures the youngThe grammar makes nurse of the young a description of the peace for which Herakles longs.
- The petition turns strength toward healingThe worshippers ask him to bring charms against sickness and drive away ruin with his branch and arrows.
The first lines of the hymn to Herakles are a wall of force, “Herakles of mighty spirit, great in strength, valiant Titan, / strong-handed, unsubdued,” “fierce in spirit,” “holding an all-conquering heart, great might,” and then, in the middle of all that muscle, comes a turn. He is the one “who made an end for mortals by driving off the savage tribes, / longing for peace, nurse of the young, of splendid honour.” In the Greek, “nurse of the young” belongs to peace rather than to Herakles, since it describes the peace he longs for, and the phrase comes from Hesiod, who said that in a just city peace, the nurse of children, is abroad in the land. So the toughest guy in Greek myth is praised for wanting the kind of peace in which kids get to grow up.
The suspicious reader has a fair point, and it should be put at full strength. Every conqueror in history has claimed to love peace, and the Roman historian Tacitus gave a chieftain in northern Britain the famous line that the Romans make a desert and call it peace. Herakles’ own record in myth is far from spotless, since he killed his own children in a fit of madness, murdered his guest Iphitos, and sacked cities when kings cheated him, Troy among them. A hymn that piles up words like “unsubdued” and “all-devouring” and then calls its hero a lover of peace might just be doing what victors always do, describing the quiet after their victory as the thing they wanted all along.
But the hymn picks its enemies carefully, and that changes the picture. The Greek for “savage tribes,” anēmera phyla, means untamed breeds, and phyla is used of animals as readily as of peoples, so the phrase covers the monsters of the labours at least as naturally as any human enemy, the lion, the Hydra, the boar, the man-eating mares and the birds of the Stymphalian marsh. The driving off is also “for mortals,” done on their behalf, and the hymn never mentions Troy, never mentions a sacked city or a conquered king. The conqueror it describes looks less like Alexander and more like a ranger who clears a valley of the things that eat people so that farmers can move in and raise their families there.
That’s why the peace in line 8 is described the way it is. Peace as the nurse of the young was an old Greek image, and Athens gave it a statue in the fourth century BC, the sculptor Kephisodotos’ figure of Eirene, Peace, holding the baby Ploutos, Wealth, in the crook of her arm, which survives in Roman copies. The point of such a peace is that children can be raised and fields harvested and wealth can grow up as safely as a child, and a hero who longs for that has his strength pointed at whatever threatens the nursery. On this reading the hymn’s wall of force and its turn to peace aren’t in tension at all, since the force is what makes room for the peace, the way a fence makes room for a garden.
Greek cult took Herakles in exactly this protective way, as a power you call on against harm. In the Athenian district of Melite he was worshipped as Alexikakos, the averter of evil, and an ancient commentator on Aristophanes says his statue there, by the sculptor Ageladas, was set up during the great plague at the start of the Peloponnesian War. People also wrote his name over their doors as a kind of security sign, “The son of Zeus, glorious victor, Herakles, dwells here, let nothing evil enter,” and Diogenes the Cynic, finding it on the door of a newly married man, added the dry comment “after war, alliance,” a joke at the expense of marriage that only works because everyone knew what Herakles on the door was for.
Then the hymn’s last lines change the enemy, and that’s where the question gets interesting. Herakles is asked to come “bringing every charm against sickness,” to “drive out evil ruin,” and to send “the harsh dooms away,” and the edition’s note sums it up by saying that “The cosmic Herakles of lines 1–13 is petitioned as a healer.” A breed of beasts can be driven off once and stay gone, but sickness comes back every season and ruin keeps finding new doors, so the protector’s job stops being a campaign and becomes a standing watch. That may be why the hymn calls him “untiring” and, a few lines later, “unshaken,” because against an enemy that keeps returning, the strength that matters most is the strength that never gets tired of showing up.
It also changes how you’d measure his success, which is the most modern thing about the request. A conqueror can count his victories, but a protector against sickness succeeds when nothing happens, the way public health works best when nobody hears about the epidemic that never came. In the Gospels, when Jesus is accused of casting out demons by the devil’s power, he answers with a picture of a strong man guarding his house and a stronger one who comes and overpowers him, and the stronger one is himself, force put to work setting people free. The hymn’s Herakles, “helper to all,” is cast in a similar part against sickness and ruin, and his strength finally shows in what is left alone, children growing up and fields bearing.
So my verdict is that the hymn makes force serve protection about as thoroughly as a hymn to Herakles could. The worry about conquerors who call their victories peace is a real one, but it fits empires that subdue peoples, and this hymn’s Herakles is aimed at beasts, sickness and ruin, never at a city, while the peace he longs for is the one that lets children be raised. When sickness becomes the enemy, nothing essential changes in what the strength is for, only in how long it has to keep at it, and that’s exactly why a conqueror of this kind is someone to ask for peace, since his whole career, as the hymn tells it, was clearing room for other people to live.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author think the hymn’s reference to “savage tribes” weakens the suspicion that Herakles represents imperial conquest?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What criteria should distinguish force that creates genuine peace from conquest that merely renames submission as peace?→
- How does Herakles’ violent history elsewhere in myth affect the credibility of the hymn’s portrayal of him as a protector?→
- If a protector’s success is measured by disasters that do not occur, how can a community recognize, evaluate, or question that protector’s power?→