Philosophy

Who Said What Knowledge Is?

Socrates and Critias can agree that medicine and building are kinds of knowledge. Asking what makes those examples count is a further question, and Critias’ definition gives it particular force.

The dialogue can make progress by starting with agreed cases. The trouble comes when a virtue is supposed to recognize knowledge itself across every field.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The cases they start withSocrates and Critias agree that medicine concerns health and calculation concerns the even and the odd. These examples let the inquiry go forward without a general definition of knowledge.
  • What makes a case countThe examples help distinguish one field from another. They leave open what makes someone’s grasp of a subject knowledge in the first place.
  • A modern parallelRoderick Chisholm calls it particularism to start from cases we take ourselves to know and work toward a criterion. That gives us a way to describe one feature of Socrates’ method.
  • Plato gives the question roomThe Theaetetus tests three proposed accounts of knowledge. The inquiry ends without an agreed definition, and Socrates suggests that its participants can still learn something about their limits.

The argument runs on examples that nobody questions, and it’s worth noticing how much rests on them. Socrates says, “If temperance is knowing something, then clearly it would be a kind of knowledge, and knowledge of something,” and takes medicine and house-building as familiar examples. Calculation and weighing come up when the two men distinguish what a discipline is about from what it produces. The question of what temperance is gets examined with great care. When they need examples of knowledge, they can point to doctors and builders.

That’s a perfectly sensible way to begin. Roderick Chisholm’s discussion of the problem of the criterion gives us a way to describe it. How do we tell which beliefs count as knowledge? A criterion would give us a standard, but to see that the standard works, we seem to need some examples we already count as knowledge. Chisholm calls it particularism to start with such cases and work toward a general account. Socrates and Critias are pursuing a different question, but we can see why it helps them to start with examples they can both recognize.

So what do the examples establish? Medicine concerns what’s healthy. Calculation concerns the even and the odd. Some crafts also produce something we can point to, as building produces a house. Later, Socrates asks how someone who knows medicine would examine a doctor’s words and deeds. The examples show several things we look for in a particular field. We can identify what it concerns, ask what its practitioners do and see how someone familiar with the work checks it.

The examples leave open what makes any of these things knowledge in the first place. A person can offer a treatment as medicine and still have a poor grasp of what it does. When Socrates asks whether knowledge of knowledge could distinguish “that, of these things, this one is knowledge and that one is not knowledge,” he doesn’t specify what the power would be picking up. Whatever separates the doctor from the person who only seems to be one, the title alone leaves the question open.

A doctor could practice medicine without a general definition of knowledge. Critias’ examiner has a different job. The whole point of the proposed power is to recognize knowledge across the fields. A ticket inspector needs some way of telling that a ticket is valid, even when the paper and printing look exactly right. In the same way, we can ask what would let Critias’ examiner distinguish knowledge from a convincing imitation. The dialogue gives him that job before we find out how he would do it.

Plato gives the question room in the Theaetetus. Theaetetus proposes perception and then true opinion. He later recalls hearing that knowledge is true opinion accompanied by an account. None of the three proposals survives the examination. Socrates suggests that the inquiry can still make Theaetetus less harsh with his companions if he comes away less ready to think he knows something he doesn’t. That possibility makes the end of the dialogue less bleak. It also leaves us with a sense of how much Critias is asking of a power that would recognize knowledge in one stroke.

There’s a fair defense of the Charmides’ method. Socrates can grant for the sake of argument that the proposed power would recognize knowledge in general and still ask how it could tell which kind of knowledge it was looking at. The distinction between medicine and the other crafts makes that challenge intelligible. We don’t have to resolve the deeper question of what knowledge is to see why someone would need a further grasp of medicine to make the doctor’s examination work.

My verdict is that the examples are strong enough for the question Socrates puts to Critias. They let him show why recognizing knowledge in general wouldn’t by itself give someone the subject matter needed to judge a doctor. They don’t tell us what every case of knowledge has in common. That’s the question the proposed examiner still owes us an answer to. A person who can point out a house that a builder made has something concrete to show. Critias’ examiner needs to show us what he’s looking for too.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author connect Socrates and Critias’s use of familiar examples with Chisholm’s particularism?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.