Philosophy
Who’s Unbeatable Now?
A boast about Charmides’ beauty turns into a series of reversals over who holds the upper hand.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates says Charmides would be invincible if he had a good soul to match his looks, and moments later Socrates himself has been flattened by the boy without a word spoken. The opening keeps flipping who has power over whom, and the last page flips it one more time.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A condition on beautySocrates jokes that Charmides would be invincible if his soul were as fine as his body.
- Who is the prey?After a glimpse inside Charmides’ cloak, Socrates thinks of a poem in which a fawn strays into a lion’s reach. The soldier imagines himself as the fawn.
- The advantage shiftsWhen the two begin to talk, Charmides struggles to say what temperance is. Socrates’ questions give the boy room to examine his answers.
- The closing threatCharmides and Critias joke about compelling Socrates to continue their conversations. Their later roles in the oligarchic regime give the joke an unsettling echo.
Charmides 154d–e, 155c–e, 158c–159a, 162b–d, 176c–d · Symposium 220b, 220d–e · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19
“Heracles! What an invincible man you are describing,” Socrates says when the room finishes raving about Charmides’ body, and every part of that line has a little swagger to it. He swears by Heracles, the strongman of Greek myth, and the word he picks for invincible means something like “not to be fought,” the kind of word you’d use about an army nobody dares take on. It’s a soldier’s compliment, coming from a man who has just got back from the fighting at Potidaea, and for a moment the beautiful boy is being sized up like an opponent on a battlefield. Coming from someone who knows what real fighting looks like, it’s a measure of how seriously the room takes the boy’s looks.
The compliment comes with a condition, though, since the boy would be invincible only “if he has just one little thing more,” a well-made soul. So in Socrates’ book beauty alone doesn’t make you unbeatable, and beauty with excellence does. What, then, would excellence add to attraction, if beauty can already stop a room? Maybe the guarantee that the power won’t be abused, because a gorgeous person with a bad soul is a danger to everyone who falls for him, while a gorgeous person with a good soul is somebody you’d never need to fight, which is the deeper sense in which he’d be unfightable.
Then the boy sits down, and the veteran of Potidaea gets beaten without a single blow, and the man Alcibiades remembers walking barefoot over the ice and saving a comrade’s life in battle can’t hold his ground for a minute on a bench. The boldness Socrates walked in with is gone, knocked clean out of him, and when he glimpses inside the boy’s cloak he’s beside himself, reaching for a line of verse by the poet Cydias that warns the lover against coming “a fawn, into the lion’s presence, to be caught as a portion of meat.” Socrates says he felt he “had been caught by just such a creature” himself, and the image flips the usual picture, because in Athenian convention the older lover was the hunter and the boy the prey, while in Cydias’ line the lover is the fawn and the beautiful boy is the lion.
That’s the playful uncertainty at the heart of the opening. Socrates set a condition for the boy’s invincibility, and the boy beat him before the condition was even checked, so beauty on its own turns out to be plenty to overpower a philosopher, at least on a crowded bench. The supposed hunter becomes the prey, the battle-hardened soldier becomes a fawn, and the teenager who hasn’t said a word yet holds all the power in the room. The boy hasn’t done anything to earn that power, which is exactly why Socrates thought beauty alone wasn’t enough to make him admirable.
Socrates fights back in the only way he knows, by changing the game from looking to talking. In a conversation beauty doesn’t count for much, and the power shifts the moment the questions start, since Charmides blushes, hesitates, gives answers that don’t hold up and ends up borrowing a definition from his guardian. The lion turns out to be a teenager, and the fawn turns out to be the most dangerous questioner in Athens, which is good news for the boy, since the contest he loses is one he can learn from. Socrates never wins by humiliating him, either, keeping the tone gentle and inviting the boy to look at the questions with him, so the power he gains is the kind that leaves the other person room to grow.
Then the last page flips it all once more. Charmides decides he wants to be charmed by Socrates every day, his guardian orders him to do it, and when Socrates asks whether the two of them are going to use force, Charmides answers, “Count on force,” adding, “since this man here gives the orders.” Socrates surrenders on the spot, saying that “when you set about doing anything, and use force, no man alive will be able to oppose you,” and when the boy tells him not to oppose them, he says, “Then I won’t oppose you.” The boy who was invincible only on a condition has become unopposable after all, and what the two of them are forcing on Socrates, sweetly enough, is the chance to keep teaching.
Notice how he got there, because the route matters more than the result. The condition at the start was a well-made soul, and the dialogue has spent twenty pages failing to confirm that Charmides has one, since he doesn’t even know whether he has temperance, but the invincibility arrives anyway, through force and on his guardian’s orders. It’s a joke, and a sweet one, since all the boy wants is more conversation, but Plato’s readers knew that Critias would later lead the Thirty and Charmides would serve among the Ten in Piraeus, so the joke has a shadow running right through it.
My verdict is that the opening’s game of power is both funny and serious. Beauty overpowers the philosopher, the philosopher overpowers beauty in argument, and the dialogue ends with the boy invincible in exactly the way Socrates didn’t mean, by force rather than by excellence. The point of the condition, the one little thing, was that excellence is what makes power safe, and the last lines leave us with a young man who has the power without the proof, which is about as clear a warning as a comedy can give.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does Socrates initially treat Charmides’ beauty as insufficient for true invincibility?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If beauty can give someone power without effort or merit, what responsibilities—if any—come with that power?→
- Why might Socrates’ gentle style of questioning be a safer or more constructive use of power than either beauty or force?→
- Does Charmides’ desire for continued conversation make the ending reassuring, troubling, or both? What features of the article support your judgment?→