Renaissance

Who Put the Secret in the Red Chalk Face?

Pater starts with a lit cheek and a shadowed face. His series of drawings and his language of clairvoyance give those small details a much larger meaning.

The face’s uncertain expression leaves room for interpretation. Pater turns that uncertainty into a theory of women who sense what others cannot.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A few features start the readingPater notices shadowed hair, a lit cheek and full eyelids. Those are particulars of the head as he remembers it.
  • The series changes what the features meanHe places drawings from several cities beside one another. The doubtful sex of the first head gives way to his idea of womanly beauty.
  • The hairstyles offer a comparisonIn a study for Leda, Leonardo gives elaborate braids more attention than the expression. That drawing helps separate an observed feature from the secret Pater reads into it.
  • Clairvoyance belongs to Pater’s accountHe calls the figures instruments that receive and pass on unseen forces. Those words tell us how he interprets the faces as much as how they are drawn.

Pater remembers a drawing that “every one will remember who has examined at all carefully the drawings by old masters at the Louvre,” a small head in red chalk. “It is a face of doubtful sex, set in the shadow of its own hair, the cheek-line in high light against it, with something voluptuous and full in the eyelids and the lips.” Beside it he places another drawing that “might pass for the same face in childhood, with parched and feverish lips,” wearing a necklace and a bulla, the amulet Roman children wore. Two heads, one lit cheek and a feverish mouth, and by the end of the paragraph Pater has built a whole order of beings out of them, which is the question for discussion here.

Here’s how the building goes, one confident step after another. Following “the thread of suggestion” through drawings “at Florence, Venice, and Milan,” Pater constructs “a sort of series, illustrating better than anything else Leonardo’s type of womanly beauty.” He calls them “Daughters of Herodias,” and says “they are not of the Christian family, or of Raphael’s,” before making the real leap. “They are the clairvoyants, through whom, as through delicate instruments, one becomes aware of the subtler forces of nature,” with “all that is magnetic in it,” and they are “nervous, electric, faint always with some inexplicable faintness,” able “to become, as it were, the receptacle of them, and pass them on to us in a chain of secret influences.”

Start with what the drawing itself can actually support. A cheek in light against shadowed hair, full lids, a mouth that seems about to change, these are the marks of Leonardo’s way of drawing a head, where the form emerges from shadow and the features are left just short of resolved. The uncertainty about the figure’s sex is also part of Pater’s first description. It matters because his later grouping gives the same head a more definite identity. So when Pater feels that the face is holding something back, he’s responding to a real effect of the technique, which leaves room for the viewer. Pater gives no catalogue identification, so the description alone leaves the drawing’s identity uncertain.

The grouping does much more of the work than the drawing does. The series across three cities is Pater’s own anthology. He gives the separate drawings an affinity by asking the reader to follow one feature from sheet to sheet. The name he gives it is telling, because no painting of Herodias’s daughter by Leonardo survives, and Pater himself admits on the next page that the subject comes down to us through versions by Luini and others. Notice, too, what happens to the “doubtful sex” of the first drawing. By the time the series is complete it has become “womanly beauty,” so the grouping quietly settles the very uncertainty that made the first face interesting.

One detail of Pater’s description does come straight from Leonardo, and it’s not the one you’d guess. He praises the “fantastic head-dresses knotted and folded so strangely to leave the dainty oval of the face disengaged,” and Leonardo really did draw hair like that, as his study for the head of Leda shows. The Royal Collection notes that in those drawings he spent little effort on Leda’s expression, just the usual downward glance, while giving all his attention to elaborate braids and coils, even drawing them from behind. The repeated coils give the hair a design that can be studied on its own. The strangeness was in the hair, and the face was left fairly plain.

Then there’s the vocabulary, which gives the game away. Clairvoyant, delicate instrument, magnetic, electric, nervous, faint, receptacle, these are the words of the 1860s, the high season of mesmerism and séances, when young women were often cast as “sensitives” through whom invisible forces passed. The vocabulary gives a nineteenth-century reader a way to picture the face as responding to something invisible. The metaphor of receptivity brings its assumptions along with it, that a woman is an instrument rather than an agent, that passivity is a form of spiritual refinement, and that faintness is a sign of depth.

The other side deserves its due, because Pater’s language isn’t pure Victorian invention. Leonardo himself defined force as a spiritual, invisible power that enters bodies and moves them, so a vocabulary of unseen forces has some root in his own thinking. And many of his figures really do seem tuned to something outside the frame, attending rather than acting, which is part of why they’ve haunted viewers for five centuries. Pater noticed that quality of attentiveness before most critics did, and several of these heads really do have the drowsy, half-lidded look Leonardo gave his angels. What he did with it was to turn a quality of the drawing into a theory of a kind of woman, and that’s the step a careful reader should decline to take with him.

My verdict is that the secret in the red chalk face is supplied mostly by Pater, with his decade lending the furniture. Leonardo supplies an invitation, soft modeling, an averted or half-closed gaze, elaborate hair around a plain face, and that invitation is genuine and worth describing. The grouping turns the invitation into a type, and the metaphor of receptivity turns the type into a psychic sisterhood. Keep the observation that these faces seem tuned to something we can’t see, because it follows from what Pater notices in the pose. The clairvoyance comes from the story he builds around that observation.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what is the most important effect of Pater’s grouping the drawings into a series?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.