Philosophy
Who Picks the City’s Goals?
A city can give every job to a genuine expert and still have to decide what those jobs are for. The Charmides leaves the decision open.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe expert city could choose its ends through specialist judgment, shared deliberation, or institutions that help correct mistakes. The dialogue gives the reader a way to weigh each answer.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The dream leaves the ends openThe dream’s doctors, pilots, and other experts can do their jobs well. Socrates still asks what would make their work good for the people they serve.
- A further expert might direct the workThe Republic joins philosophy and political power. That approach requires someone who understands the good the city should aim for.
- Citizens might deliberate togetherIn the Protagoras, Zeus gives everyone a share of respect and justice. The myth gives people a reason to hear from more than a few specialists on political matters.
- The city can plan for mistakesPopper asks how institutions can limit the damage from bad government. The Charmides shows the value of correcting a proposal even when the people making it are confident.
Charmides 172c–d, 173a–c, 173c–d, 174b–d, 174d–e, 175b–d, 176b–d · Republic 473c–d · Protagoras 319b–d, 322c–d · Karl Popper, The Open Society and Its Enemies Chapter 7
By the end of the dream, the problem is plain. Socrates has granted a city where every craftsman is genuine and every job is done right, and he still won’t grant that its people would do well and be happy, because, as he says, “that by acting knowledgeably we would do well and be happy, this, my dear Critias, we cannot yet learn.” A page later the missing ingredient has a name, the knowledge of good and bad, whose work is “to benefit us.” So an expert city needs someone, or something, to judge what its many competent activities are for, and the question for discussion is who that should be.
The first answer is another expert, someone who has the knowledge of good and bad and directs the city accordingly. That is one answer Socrates gives in the Republic, where Socrates says that cities will have no rest from their troubles until philosophers become kings or kings take up philosophy. It has a clear logic, since if there is a knowledge of what benefits a city and some people have it, then those people could direct the city’s activity toward its good. In the Charmides that knowledge is named but never located, so the expert answer asks us to find people the dialogue itself never finds.
The case for the expert deserves weight. People who understand water systems can explain what it takes to keep a city’s water clean. They can compare two plans and show how much each would cost or how many neighborhoods it would reach. If there were an expertise that could also tell us which neighborhoods the city ought to serve first, that would be a strong reason to listen. The question is whether the second judgment is the same kind of thing as the first.
A second answer is shared deliberation. In the Protagoras, Socrates describes Athenians hearing from experts about shipbuilding and from people of many occupations on public affairs. Protagoras answers with a myth in which Zeus gives everyone a share of justice and respect because a city can’t exist if only a few have them. The myth gives the people who share a city a reason to speak on its ends. They may also see parts of a problem a single expert could miss.
A third answer begins with what happens when rulers make mistakes. Karl Popper asks how political institutions can keep bad or incompetent rulers from doing too much damage. His question changes what we ask of a political arrangement. It should be possible to challenge a ruler, check a decision, and correct it when necessary. A city can try to do that even while it argues about who knows best.
The Charmides itself gives some support to each answer. It points toward a knowledge of good and bad, which favors the expert, but it never finds anyone who has it, and it can’t even define one virtue after an afternoon of trying, which makes it hard to say confidently who the experts in the city’s good would be. Its own method is shared inquiry, people working out a question together and correcting each other, which favors deliberation, and even its scene, a gathering of friends in a wrestling school, is a small model of a community thinking together. And its honest record of failure, its admission that they agreed too easily and conceded too much, looks a good deal like Popper’s insistence that the first task is catching our own mistakes.
The dialogue gives readers a reason to be cautious about the first answer. At the end, Critias and Charmides have settled what to do next, and Socrates asks if they’ll give him even a hearing. Their confidence about the plan tells us little about how much they know about temperance. A city would need some way to tell the difference before giving people the power to set its ends.
My verdict is that the expert city needs someone to judge its ends, and the dialogue gives a reader reason to take shared deliberation and correction seriously. The speakers test their ideas together and catch some of their own mistakes. They also leave their strongest account of benefit unfinished. The conversation shows what can be gained by asking why a decision is good before asking who can carry it out.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article argue that a city of genuine experts might still fail to make its people happy?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How could a city distinguish legitimate expertise about the common good from mere confidence or claims to authority?→
- When deciding which neighborhoods to serve first, what can technical experts establish, and what must citizens deliberate about together?→
- If no political arrangement can guarantee wise rulers, which forms of challenge and correction should a city prioritize, and why?→