Renaissance
When Unfinished Looks Finished
A weathered ancient statue and Michelangelo’s rough marble give Pater the same impression. Their surfaces came about in very different ways.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater’s idea of perfect finish puts an expressive effect beside the accident or choice that produced it. The Venus de Milo, Saint Matthew and the Rondanini Pietà let us separate those questions.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Time worked on the VenusThe Venus de Milo reached the Louvre in fragments. Pater imagines its worn surface making the figure seem about to emerge.
- A rough surface has a historyMichelangelo’s Saint Matthew belongs to an interrupted commission. The Rondanini Pietà preserves signs of repeated revision near the end of his life.
- Pater’s finish is an effectHe calls the surface perfect finish because of what it makes a viewer see. That judgment leaves open why work on a given sculpture stopped.
- Rodin chose where to stopRodin’s La Pensée sets a polished face against rough stone. Its surface gives a later example of an effect deliberately made.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, Michelangelo’s incompleteness and the Venus de Milo · Note 120, Michelangelo’s unfinished surfaces · Note 121, the Venus de Milo · Note 122, Michelangelo’s snow figure · The discovery of the Venus de Milo, Louvre · Vasari, Life of Michelangelo · Michelangelo’s Saint Matthew, Galleria dell’Accademia · Michelangelo’s Rondanini Pietà, Castello Sforzesco · Rodin’s La Pensée, Musée d’Orsay
Pater’s account of Michelangelo starts with a statue Michelangelo never touched. Time and accident, he says, with the Venus of Melos buried for centuries under a farmer’s furrows, worked “with singular felicity of touch” on its surface, “fraying its surface and softening its lines, so that some spirit in the thing seems always on the point of breaking out.” Michelangelo, he goes on, gets the same effect “by leaving nearly all his sculpture in a puzzling sort of incompleteness, which suggests rather than realises actual form,” and with that comparison he sets the terms of a debate that has run ever since, because he’s putting a gift of the soil and a working method on the same footing.
Then he raises the stakes, telling us that this incompleteness is Michelangelo’s way of etherealizing pure form, his equivalent for color, and adding flatly, “And it was in reality perfect finish.” Yet in the same breath he calls it a quality “which often is, and always seems, the effect of accident,” so he’s admitting that much of the roughness happened rather than being chosen while insisting that the result counts as finish anyway. The quality could come from the artist’s choice, from what happened to the object, or from the way a viewer sees it. Pater’s sentences move among all three possibilities.
The Venus offers a clear case of chance. She was found in fragments on Melos in 1820 and reached the Louvre in 1821 with her arms missing. Pater imagines the centuries underground softening her surface. The expressive effect belongs to his encounter with the statue in the condition in which it survived.
Pater’s next image complicates things, and it comes with a small slip. He says something of the wasting of the snow figure Michelangelo modeled for Piero de’ Medici “lurks about” all his sculpture, and he places that snowfall “in the court of the Pitti palace,” though Vasari says only that Piero, one winter when it snowed heavily, had the young sculptor make a statue of snow “in his courtyard,” which meant the Medici palace on the Via Larga, since the family didn’t acquire the Pitti until the middle of the next century. The snow statue was built to vanish, so its disappearance was a condition of the material from the start.
Several of Michelangelo’s marbles bear the marks of interrupted commissions. The Saint Matthew was one of twelve apostles he contracted to carve for Florence Cathedral in 1503 and remained incomplete after the pope called him to Rome, though he may have worked on it again after the cathedral contract was cancelled, the Prisoners were stranded when the tomb of Julius II shrank from a mountain of marble to a wall monument, and the Taddei Tondo, in London’s Royal Academy since 1830, was simply never completed. Vasari observes that the statues Michelangelo completed were mainly works of his youth, and those are the conditions of a busy career, with contracts cancelled, patrons dying and projects outgrowing their budgets.
Vasari also offers the best evidence for choice, though. He says that Michelangelo could abandon a piece over a defect and that his increasingly exacting judgment made it harder for him to finish work to his satisfaction. That turns stopping into a kind of decision. The Rondanini Pietà is the strongest case, a marble he was still cutting back days before his death in February 1564, reworking an earlier design so drastically that a detached arm from the first version still hangs beside the two thin figures. There the rough surface looks less like something abandoned than like a man thinking with a chisel, still changing his mind, and his own poetry supports that reading, since a famous sonnet of his says that the best artist has no idea that a single block of marble doesn’t already hold within its excess, so carving is a matter of removing what covers the figure.
The third candidate, the viewer’s encounter, has the most history on its side. Later sculptors learned from Michelangelo’s accidents and turned them into a style, as Rodin did when he let a head emerge from a rough-hewn block in La Pensée, and once audiences had been trained to read rough marble as feeling, every unfinished surface started to look intended. The edition’s note makes exactly the distinction that matters, separating the expressive quality Pater sees from the separate historical question of why any particular statue was left as it was, and the two questions can have entirely different answers.
My verdict is that an unfinished surface can be a kind of finish, but mostly for the viewer rather than the maker. The record points to different causes in different works, and a viewer can give any of those surfaces meaning, so Pater is right about the effect and wrong to call it “perfect finish,” since that credits Michelangelo with work done by soil, contracts and death. The honest way to look is case by case, treating the Saint Matthew as a stranded commission, the Rondanini as a late decision and the Venus as a gift of the ground, and then admitting that all three can move you in the same way, which is the most interesting fact Pater’s comparison uncovers.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What distinction does the article say is essential when interpreting an unfinished sculpture?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the cause of a sculpture’s unfinished state differs from the meaning viewers find in it, which should matter more when judging the work, and why?→
- What assumptions about artistic intention lead viewers to interpret rough or incomplete surfaces as expressive?→
- Does calling an unfinished work “finished” clarify the viewer’s experience, or does it erase the accidents and constraints that shaped the object?→