Philosophy

When Did Socrates Come Home?

Socrates says he got back from Potidaea the evening before. The fighting and the length of his absence point to different dates, and each date puts a different Athens outside the wrestling school.

The opening gives the evening of Socrates’ return and leaves the year uncertain. Two readings put the gym scene on opposite sides of the outbreak of war.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The evening is clearSocrates says he got back the previous evening. Athens has only just heard that men the people at the gym knew were killed.
  • The battle points to 432Thucydides puts a pitched battle at Potidaea in 432 BC. The siege and Alcibiades’ account of Socrates in winter complicate an immediate return.
  • The absence points to 429By the time Socrates comes back, Charmides has grown up. A later battle was fought at Spartolus, and Thucydides says the Athenians retreated to Potidaea before going home.
  • The date changes the settingA date of 432 puts the conversation before war with Sparta. A date of 429 puts it after plague and invasion had reached Athens.

Charmides 153a–c, 154a–b · Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War 1.56–66, 1.63.3, 2.47–54, 2.65, 2.70, 2.79, 2.79.7 · Symposium 219e, 220a–d, 220d–e · Voula Tsouna Introduction

The opening sets the scene precisely, and then refuses to say when it is. “We had got back from the army at Potidaea the evening before,” Socrates says, and “after so long away” he heads for his old haunts. Chaerephon asks how he survived the battle, and Socrates explains in an aside that “Shortly before we left there had been a battle at Potidaea, and the people here had only just heard the news.” The fighting was very heavy, and many people they knew were killed. Every detail suggests a definite moment, and yet the moment can’t be pinned to a year. The dialogue gives us the evening of the homecoming and leaves the year to work out.

The background is clear enough, since Potidaea, a city in the northern Aegean that paid tribute to Athens, revolted in 432 BC, Athens sent an army, and there was a pitched battle near the city that year. The Athenians won and lost a hundred and fifty men, including their commander Callias. The siege that followed lasted until the city surrendered in the winter of 430/29. Socrates served there, and in the Symposium Alcibiades describes how he endured the winter barefoot and saved Alcibiades’ life in battle. Scholars disagree over whether the homecoming in the Charmides belongs to 432 or to 429.

The case for 432 rests mainly on the battle. The great battle at Potidaea itself was fought in 432, with real Athenian losses, and the dialogue’s phrase “a battle at Potidaea” fits it naturally. On this reading Socrates came home soon after that fight, and the news of the dead was fresh. The difficulty is that the siege had only just begun in 432 and would last for years, and the Symposium has Socrates enduring the northern winter with the army, which suggests he stayed on rather than coming home at once. Defenders of the early date reply that he could have come home for a while and gone back to the siege later, though nothing in our sources says so.

The case for 429 rests on the length of the absence. Socrates says he has been away “so long,” and he asks about the young men who have grown up while he was gone, learning that Charmides, a boy when he left, is now the most admired youth in the city. That fits an absence of about three years far better than a few months. The difficulty here is the battle, since the heavy Athenian defeat of 429 took place near Spartolus in the Chalcidice after Potidaea had surrendered, and calling it “a battle at Potidaea” is a stretch, although Thucydides says the defeated Athenians fled to Potidaea before returning home. Xenophon son of Euripides was among the commanders in both episodes.

The choice matters because the two years belong to different worlds. In 432 Athens was not yet formally at war with Sparta, Pericles was at the height of his power, and the city was prosperous, confident and anxious about a looming conflict. In 429 the war was two years old, the countryside had been ravaged, and the plague that broke out in 430 had killed a large part of the population, Pericles dying that year. A conversation in a crowded wrestling school reads very differently against the first background than against the second.

Each setting also colors the conversation in a particular way. In 432 the cheerful crowd and the talk of beauty and charms belong to a city that doesn’t yet know what the war will cost. In 429 the same scene becomes a moment of normal life snatched from a city full of mourning and disease, and the dialogue’s silence about the plague becomes either remarkable or a sign that this isn’t the right date. Neither reading is forced on us, and a reader can feel the scene shift depending on which world he places around it. Plato may simply not have cared about the exact year, since the scene does its work whichever date one picks, and that possibility deserves a place among the others.

The right response to the uncertainty is to keep it visible. It would be easy to pick a date and write as if it were settled, and some summaries of the dialogue do exactly that, but the evidence genuinely points both ways, and an invented certainty would quietly decide questions about the dialogue’s mood that the text leaves open. The Diotimos edition marks the date as disputed, and that marking is not a failure of scholarship but an accurate report of what the sources allow. Uncertain dates are common in ancient history, and the habit of choosing one and forgetting the doubt is how many confident errors find their way into textbooks.

My verdict is that the dramatic date of the Charmides should remain an open question, with 432 favored by the battle and 429 by the length of the absence, and neither able to rule out the other. The two dates place the conversation in very different Athenses, one on the brink of war and one in the middle of war and plague, and a careful reader can hold both possibilities in mind. Plato gave the scene a precise evening and an uncertain year, and the honest thing is to leave it exactly that way.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Which combination best summarizes why the article treats 432 as plausible but not decisive?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.