Renaissance

When an Impression Changes Meaning

Pater’s critic traces an impression back to a painting. His Conclusion asks what happens when the impression is all we can hold.

The Preface treats an impression as evidence about the effect of an artwork. The Conclusion uses the same habit of analysis to consider how quickly experience passes.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The impression is a clueThe Preface asks what a work really does to a particular reader or viewer. Identifying that effect helps the critic trace it to its source.
  • The apparent object comes apartIn the Conclusion, analysis breaks a seemingly stable thing into colors, textures, and other fleeting impressions. The observer’s experience becomes the object of inquiry.
  • The method carries overBoth passages break a complex experience into elements. The Conclusion extends the Preface’s comparison with chemistry to the body and mind.
  • Attention has a time limitPater still asks readers to discriminate among impressions, but a passing moment offers no second look. The stakes change when the critic’s discipline becomes a way to spend a life.

The Diotimos edition does you a favor before the book even starts, because its Key Words page warns you that one of Pater’s favorite words is going to switch jobs. In the Preface, the entry says, “the impression is the particular effect of a work on a particular person,” something the critic has to pin down precisely, while in the Conclusion “the word has a wider reach,” and impressions become “what experience resolves into when the apparent permanence of things falls away.” That’s a big move for one noun to make in a hundred and fifty pages, and if you read the ending with the Preface’s meaning still in your head, you’ll miss what Pater is actually claiming there and how he managed to talk himself into claiming it.

Start with the Preface, where an impression is evidence and it has an address. Pater’s critic asks of a song or a picture “What effect does it really produce on me?” and then whether it pleases and “what sort or degree of pleasure,” because the answers are “the original facts” he has to work with. Yet the point of all that self-scrutiny lies outside the self, since Pater borrows Matthew Arnold’s line that the aim of criticism is “to see the object as in itself it really is,” and his critic’s work is done when he can “indicate what the source of that impression is, and under what conditions it is experienced.” The impression is a symptom that points back to a cause, so it works like a lead in a detective story, with the painting still the suspect.

Now jump to the Conclusion, where the same word has stopped pointing anywhere. Pater takes ordinary objects and lets reflection play on them until “the cohesive force seems suspended like some trick of magic” and “each object is loosed into a group of impressions,” color, odor and texture, sitting “in the mind of the observer.” Then he keeps going, describing impressions as “unstable, flickering, inconsistent, which burn and are extinguished with our consciousness of them,” until each one shrinks to “a single moment, gone while we try to apprehend it.” There’s no suspect left behind these impressions, because the object turns out to have been a bundle of them all along, and the thing the Preface’s critic was trying to see has dissolved into the seeing.

What makes this more than a mood is how Pater gets there, because he uses the Preface’s own tool. In the Preface the critic treats a work’s effect the way a chemist treats a compound, “analysing and reducing it to its elements,” and recording its active property “as a chemist notes some natural element.” In the Conclusion the body is broken down first, into “phosphorus and lime and delicate fibres,” then the mind is broken into impressions, and then the decisive step arrives in a sentence that could be a stage direction, “Analysis goes a step further still.” So the Conclusion is less a new philosophy bolted onto an art book than the Preface’s chemistry run past the point where the Preface meant to stop, with the critic now putting his own experience in the test tube.

Once you see that continuity you can also see the exact change. The Preface asked of every impression where it came from, while the Conclusion asks how long it lasts, because analysis now tells us that impressions “are in perpetual flight” and that “each of them is limited by time,” so the word has traded a place for a duration. That explains why the ending suddenly fills up with clocks and heartbeats, “a counted number of pulses,” an “interval” before death, the need to pass “most swiftly from point to point,” since if an impression no longer leads you back to a stable object, the only thing left to manage is how many of them you catch before they’re gone.

The obvious objection is that this drives criticism into a dead end where nothing exists except my own flickering sensations, which would make the careful chapters on Botticelli and Luca della Robbia a waste of everyone’s time, but Pater doesn’t buy that, and neither do I. He keeps the Preface’s key verb, warning that “not to discriminate every moment some passionate attitude in those about us” is to sleep before evening, and discriminating is exactly what the Preface asked the critic to do with an impression, “to discriminate it, to realise it distinctly.” He also keeps pointing outward, to a form that “grows perfect in hand or face” and to “some tone on the hills or the sea” that “is choicer than the rest,” and those are things in the world, even if they only last a moment.

The introduction puts it neatly when it says that in the Conclusion “the discrimination practised in the Preface becomes an account of how to spend a life,” and what really changes is the pace. The Preface’s critic can go back to the Uffizi tomorrow and check his impression of the Venus against the Venus, which is still hanging there, so he can afford patience and second thoughts, while the person in the Conclusion can’t go back to a moment and has to do the critic’s whole job, noticing, sorting and naming, while the thing is still happening. That’s why the Conclusion reads like the Preface on fast-forward, and why it unsettled people, since a method built for slow afternoons in galleries is now being asked to run a whole life at the speed of a pulse.

So the word really does mean something different at the end of the book, but the new meaning grows out of the Preface rather than betraying it, and I think that’s the most daring thing in the whole volume. In the Preface an impression is where knowing a thing begins, and in the Conclusion it’s all of the thing you’re ever going to get, and Pater earns that shift honestly, through analysis, instead of slipping it in as a slogan. The chapters in between are the counterweight, since they show impressions that hold still long enough to be described and checked, and the best way to read the ending is as the Preface’s discipline under pressure, still discriminating, still naming sources where it can, and racing the clock where it can’t.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, how does the function of an “impression” change from the Preface to the Conclusion?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.