Renaissance
When Agreement Was Still Possible
Pater’s Pico and Michelangelo measure a change in what religious thought could hold together.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater imagines Pico making room for pagan thought in Christianity and Michelangelo looking back from a different Rome. The contrast reveals Pater’s account of the Renaissance and the limits of what it tells us about either man.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater makes the linkPater imagines Michelangelo reconciling the Greeks and Christianity as Pico had tried to do.
- Pico’s momentThe Pico essay describes a period when the accord of pagan learning and Christian faith could still be pursued in earnest.
- A change of climatePater places Michelangelo’s later life against a Roman Church he sees as less open to such adjustments.
- A difference the contrast leaves outMichelangelo’s late poems express a Christian devotion more specific than Pater’s image of the solitary traveller.
The Renaissance · Pico, the generous instincts of the age · Pico, religious devotion and the older gods · Pico, the imaginative reconciliation · Michelangelo, from Pico’s Florence to later Rome · Note 163, Filippo Neri’s circle and the Oratory · International Walter Pater Society, publication chronology
Pater makes the connection himself, and he does it by name. Describing Michelangelo’s old age, he says that in earlier days, when the Church’s beliefs “had been in a fluid state,” the artist might have been drawn into its controversies, perhaps “for adjusting the dreams of Plato and Homer with the words of Christ, like Pico of Mirandola.” The two men weren’t strangers to each other’s world, either, since the teenage Michelangelo lived in Lorenzo de’ Medici’s household in the early 1490s, the years when Pico was a familiar figure in Lorenzo’s circle. They breathed the same air of reconciliation, and Pater uses the older man as the measuring stick for what the younger one would later lose.
Pico’s moment, in Pater’s telling, was the moment when agreement still seemed a serious project. The essay opens by calling the attempt to reconcile Christianity with Greek religion one of “the generous instincts of that age,” an age “too serious to play with a religion,” and it calls Pico “one of the last who seriously and sincerely entertained the claim on men’s faith of the pagan religions.” His method was a vast system of correspondences, in which the creation story of Genesis and the cosmos of Plato’s Timaeus turn out to say the same thing, and fire burns on earth, gives life in the heavens and loves among the angels. He died in a Dominican habit “amid thoughts of the older gods,” and Pater calls his life “so perfect a parallel” to his writings. The detail that interests Pater most is that even in the final turn toward stricter religious devotion Pico did not “forget the old gods,” and a convert who keeps his tenderness for what he left behind is a reconciliation in living form.
But Pater doesn’t think Pico succeeded, and his reason sets up the comparison. The fifteenth century, he says, was “great rather by what it designed or aspired to do, than by what it actually achieved,” and the only reconciliation really possible for that age “was an imaginative one,” made by artists trained in Christian schools who took up pagan subjects, beside which “work like Pico’s was but the feebler counterpart.” So in Pater’s scheme the job passes from the philosopher to the artist, and the young Michelangelo, carving a battle of centaurs in Lorenzo’s palace around 1492, looks like exactly the person to do it.
By Michelangelo’s old age the frame had changed around him. Pater writes that a new kind of Catholicism “had taken the place of the Renaissance,” and that “The opposition of the Reformation to art has been often enlarged upon; far greater was that of the Catholic revival.” The Church, “fixing itself in a frozen orthodoxy,” had passed beyond the old artist, and some of his intimate associates came from the circle of Filippo Neri, whose Oratory, the note explains, received papal approval in 1575, after Michelangelo’s death. The point isn’t so much that Michelangelo’s mind changed as that the ground under it did. The temperature of the age dropped, and what had been fluid in Pico’s Florence had frozen solid in the Rome of the Counter-Reformation.
What the old man does instead is the most interesting part of the portrait. He “had long since fallen back on that divine ideal, which above the wear and tear of creeds has been forming itself for ages as the possession of nobler souls,” and he finds the Church soothing “as a traveller might be, resting for one evening in a strange city.” He lingers on as “a ghost out of another age,” dreaming “on the images under which that primitive world had conceived of spiritual forces.” The tenderness for the old gods survives in him, just as it survived in Pico, but it has lost its program, so that what was a system in Pico has become a private dream in Michelangelo.
That’s why the pairing works as a method rather than a coincidence. Pater treats each man as an instrument, something like a thermometer left out in two different seasons, and what each could sincerely believe tells you the temperature of his moment. Pico registers possibility, since his whole life was an argument that agreement could be reached. Michelangelo registers change, and he does so precisely because he outlived his time, which is why Pater says he dwelt on “the thought of Michelangelo as thus lingering beyond his time in a world not his own.” A man stranded by history measures the change better than anyone born into the new order, because he still carries the old one with him. Pico, who died at thirty-one, never had to find out whether his reconciliation would survive the next generation, while Michelangelo, who lived to nearly eighty-nine, watched the religious conditions around him change.
There’s a fair objection, and it’s that this turns individuals into symptoms. Michelangelo’s late faith wasn’t a vague ideal floating above creeds, since his late poems speak of a soul that neither painting nor sculpture can quiet anymore, turned toward the divine love that opened its arms on the cross. That’s devotion to Christ crucified, about as credal as faith gets, and it sits awkwardly with Pater’s picture of a spirit too independent to be the Church’s subject. A reader may suspect that “above the wear and tear of creeds” describes a Victorian don living after his own age of reconciliations more exactly than it describes the old sculptor.
As history of two individuals, then, the pairing simplifies, and Michelangelo’s late poems describe his faith in terms more explicitly Christian than Pater’s portrait does. As a way of locating the possibilities of religious thought, though, it’s genuinely illuminating. Pico shows a moment when the old gods could still be argued into the faith, Michelangelo a moment when they could only be dreamed of beside it, and Pater’s real subject is the narrowing between those two moments, a span of about seventy years in which an open question closed.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, why does Pater regard artistic reconciliation as more successful than Pico’s philosophical project?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- Does Pater’s use of Pico and Michelangelo as measures of their historical moments clarify the past, or does it reduce complex individuals to symbols? Why?→
- If the only reconciliation available to the fifteenth century was imaginative rather than philosophical, what distinction is the article drawing between what art and argument can accomplish?→
- How does the evidence from Michelangelo’s late poems alter—or perhaps strengthen—the article’s larger claim that the possibilities of religious thought narrowed during his lifetime?→