Renaissance
What Venetian Painters Keep from the Alps
Pater prefers the quiet shapes of a French riverbank. Venetian painters, he says, make a harsher landscape serve their figures by carrying over only some of its colors and lines.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater compares the ease with which light can shape a riverbank to the choices Venetian painters make about mountains, fields and buildings. Titian’s landscape and Dürer’s view of Arco bring the distinction into focus.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The quiet riverbankPater finds the French riverside easy for light and shade to bring into one prevailing tone.
- A harder landscapeThe sharp outline of the Alpine background makes it harder to treat the landscape as a single mood.
- What painters keepPater notices cool color, calming slopes, turrets and pale fields. He hears them as an accompaniment to the figures.
- A contrast on paperDürer’s view of Arco preserves the shape of a recognizable place, which clarifies what Pater means by taking only elements from a landscape.
The Renaissance · The School of Giorgione, pp. 90–91, French rivers and Venetian mountains
For a Victorian reader who knew Ruskin’s writing on mountain beauty, the Alps were an obvious place to look for impressive scenery, so when Pater says that “for most conditions of the picturesque” a riverside in France beats “a Swiss valley,” he’s going against the taste of his age. The word picturesque had a precise history, going back to the eighteenth-century travel writers who used it for scenery that would look good in a picture, and that is a useful sense to keep in mind here. He’s asking which kind of place makes the better raw material for a painter, and his answer is the quiet one.
His reason is that “on the French river-side, mere topography, the simple material, counts for so little,” and “all being very pure, untouched, and tranquil in itself, mere light and shade have such easy work in modulating it to one dominant tone.” A low riverbank is like an actor who lets the lighting do the work, while an Alp is the scene-stealer who insists on being himself whatever the light is doing. French painters had already proved the point, with Daubigny working from a studio boat on rivers including the Oise from the late 1850s, and Pater’s theory explains why that modesty pays, since a landscape with little character of its own lets the light give it one.
That leaves Venice as a problem, and Pater says so. “The Venetian landscape, on the other hand, has in its material conditions much which is hard, or harshly definite,” since behind the lagoon and the plain rise the Dolomites, about as hard and definite as mountains get, and Titian himself was born among them at Pieve di Cadore. If Pater’s theory is right, Venetian painters were working with the worst possible raw material, and his answer is that “the masters of the Venetian school have shown themselves little burdened by them,” keeping from the Alpine background “certain abstracted elements only, of cool colour and tranquillising line.” What they took was the temperature and the shape of the mountains, the blue cool of distance and the long calming slopes, rather than the mountains themselves.
They also kept some concrete things, and Pater names them, “the brown windy turrets, the straw-coloured fields,” which they use “but as the notes of a music which duly accompanies the presence of their men and women.” Look behind the two women in Titian’s Sacred and Profane Love, painted around 1514–15, and you’ll find exactly that kit, with a walled town climbing a hill toward its castle on one side and a village church, shepherds and riders with dogs chasing a hare across the fields on the other. The parts feel like country a viewer could know, while their arrangement follows the needs of the painting, since the landscape is there the way an accompanist is there, playing under the singers.
Compare what a northern painter did with the same mountains. On his first Italian journey Albrecht Dürer made watercolors of places he passed. In the Louvre’s view of the valley of Arco, dated to about 1495, the fortified town still gives the view a recognizable setting. That’s topography as the subject, the mountains recorded for their own sake. The Venetian paintings Pater has in view put recognizable features to a different use, which is why Pater can say they present only “the spirit or essence” of a certain sort of landscape.
His name for the result is “a country of the pure reason or half-imaginative memory,” and the memory part fits better than he might have known. Titian left Cadore as a boy to train in Venice, so the mountains in his backgrounds were remembered country in the most literal way, though it is hard to say which particular slopes or peaks he remembered when he painted a landscape. Memory edits like that, since nobody remembers a childhood landscape as a map, only as a skyline, a color of the fields and the feeling of a certain kind of afternoon, the way a road trip comes back to you years later as a few bright frames.
You could object that Pater’s account is as selective as the paintings, and that it undersells how specific Venetian painters could be when they wanted, with Bellini placing real-looking hill towns with real care and Titian loading his backgrounds with recognizable buildings. You could also point to pictures from Giorgione’s circle where the landscape seems to take over, where a storm or a stretch of country carries more of the feeling than the figures do. Both points are fair, and the second is the stronger, but Pater can answer that even the specific towers are chosen for their color and outline, and that in the stormiest of those pictures the landscape is still tuned to the people in it.
So what Venetian painters keep from the Alps is something like a key signature, the cool color and the tranquil line, plus a handful of concrete notes like a brown turret or a pale field, and Pater is right that this conversion turns topography into a setting for human presence. His French-river argument explains why it had to happen, because the mountains were too loud to leave as they were, and they had to be quieted before light and figures could take the stage. I think his own selectivity, picking a few details and calling them notes, is the best evidence that he understood what the painters were doing.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does Pater consider a French riverside better pictorial material than a Swiss valley under most conditions?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If Venetian painters turn Alpine topography into a setting for human presence, what may be gained—and what may be lost—in that transformation?→
- How does the article’s comparison of landscape to musical accompaniment shape your understanding of the relationship between setting and figures?→
- Does the idea of “half-imaginative memory” strengthen Pater’s interpretation of Titian’s backgrounds, or does it make the interpretation harder to verify? Why?→