Renaissance
What to Keep Faint and What to Leave Out
Pater’s Tuscan reliefs and Greek sculpture teach two different habits of looking.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater admires the faint shadows of Tuscan relief and the strong outlines he finds in Greek sculpture. The comparison shows how a sculptor can direct attention by leaving out a detail or by making it just visible.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The Greek examplePater describes the simplification of hair as a way of drawing attention to the larger form of a figure.
- The Tuscan exampleLuca’s shallow relief can preserve a change in expression so slight that it depends on the direction of the light.
- Both practices involve selectionPater links Luca to Greek sculpture through the decision to retain only certain elements of form.
- Color changes the evidenceSurviving evidence of painted ancient sculpture complicates any account that takes the appearance of bare marble for the original effect.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, refinements of shadow · Note 117, the direction of light · Note 118, color in sculpture · Luca della Robbia, selecting what to retain · Note 123, the breadth of Greek art · Winckelmann, abstraction and line · Winckelmann, the reserve of the gods · Winckelmann, the treatment of hair · Note 309, surviving evidence of ancient color · Metropolitan Museum of Art, Chroma and ancient sculpture
Put two of Pater’s sentences side by side and they turn out to be about the same thing. The Tuscan relief sculptors, he says, “seek their means of delineation among those last refinements of shadow, which are almost invisible except in a strong light, and which the finest pencil can hardly follow.” In Greek sculpture, by contrast, “The hair, so rich a source of expression in painting,” is “withdrawn from attention; its texture, as well as its colour, is lost, its arrangement but faintly and severely indicated, with no broken or enmeshed light.” One strategy keeps a whisper of shadow, and the other refuses to let light break up on the surface at all. Pater never sets these sentences together himself, since one comes from his essay on Luca and the other from his essay on Winckelmann, but they read like two halves of a single argument about what a sculptor should do with light.
The Greek strategy is subtraction, carried out with great confidence. Pater says Greek sculpture finds its power in “broad, central, incisive lines,” and achieves this “not by accumulation of detail, but by abstracting from it,” purging away “All that is accidental.” Hair, he argues, is “mere drapery” compared with the eye or the lip, and a carved mass of curls would scatter light into glitter and pull the eye to the surface. Simplifying the texture makes the major lines easier to pick out, even from a distance. It’s what a good arranger does when he cuts a busy guitar part so the melody can carry over it.
The Tuscan strategy is attenuation, which is a different thing. The cue survives, but only just, at the edge of what the eye can catch, and the note on low relief explains that the strength of each shadow depends on the depth of the cut and the direction of the light. The effect Pater prizes, “the passing of a smile over the face of a child,” comes and goes with the conditions, so a viewer who arrives at the wrong hour or stands at the wrong angle may see nothing at all. It’s more like a pianissimo passage in a symphony, which you only really hear in a quiet hall on a good night. Pater’s other image for the same effect, “the ripple of the air on a still day over the curtain of a window ajar,” is itself a lesson in attenuation, a movement so slight you’d only notice it if you happened to be watching.
Pater himself puts Luca halfway between the Greeks and Michelangelo, sharing the Greek habit of “extracting certain select elements only of pure form and sacrificing all the rest,” along with something of Michelangelo’s studied incompleteness. So the Tuscans also leave things out, and Pater says they repress “all such curves as indicate solid form.” The difference isn’t really between keeping and omitting, then, but in what remains after the omission, since the Greeks leave strong, simple lines and the Tuscans leave faint, complicated shadows, and those two kinds of remainder make very different demands on the person looking.
The Greek remainder asks the viewer to stop wanting detail. That’s harder than it sounds, and Pater admits as much when he says that “To all but the highest culture, the reserved faces of the gods will ever have something of insipidity.” Leave out too much and the ordinary viewer sees blankness, a face without a story. Pater’s description of the eyes in the same passage shows the Greek strategy at full strength, since they’re “wide and directionless, not fixing anything with their gaze,” which removes even the cue of where a figure is looking. The Tuscan remainder asks the opposite, that the viewer go close, wait for the light and look patiently, and its risk is the opposite too, since a shadow that needs strong light can vanish in a dim church or a flat photograph and leave the work looking empty.
There’s a factual wrinkle in the Greek half of the comparison. Ancient sculpture often carried paint or other colored materials, as the edition’s note explains. In individual works, the loss of those materials can produce a degree of restraint that the sculptor never intended. The texture point survives better, since many Greek sculptors really did treat hair as a simplified mass, but the Tuscan shadows are on firmer ground, because they’re cut into the stone itself and last as long as the stone does, though they still depend on the light.
Which of the two strategies is the better one? The question is badly posed, because the two answer different problems. Subtraction emphasizes large forms and can sacrifice richness. Attenuation keeps a finer signal and makes it easier to miss. It’s worth noticing, though, that Pater’s own method as a critic, the patient discrimination of faint and passing impressions, makes him the ideal viewer of Tuscan relief, while his admiration for Greek breadth is admiration for a discipline he describes beautifully but rarely practices in his own prose. His sentences are long, qualified and full of fine shades, which is to say Tuscan rather than Greek.
Leaving something out can direct attention across a wider range of viewing conditions, at the risk of looking blank, while keeping something faint invites discovery and depends on the conditions, at the risk of disappearing. A viewer needs both habits, the willingness to accept what the Greek sculptor withheld and the patience to find what the Tuscan sculptor barely kept, and Pater’s pairing of them in one book is a good lesson in how many different ways a work of art can ask to be seen.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what most clearly distinguishes the Greek strategy from the Tuscan strategy?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If Greek subtraction risks appearing blank and Tuscan attenuation risks disappearing, how should a sculptor decide which risk is more worthwhile?→
- How do changing viewing conditions—such as distance, angle, and light—affect whether omission feels deliberate or merely empty?→
- What might it mean for a viewer to practice both habits the article recommends: accepting withheld detail and patiently seeking faint effects?→