Renaissance

What the Prisoners Ask You to Finish

One figure turns its head and another seems to shoulder the block itself. Pater asks what the viewer supplies when Michelangelo leaves so much marble uncarved.

The four Florentine Prisoners make different demands on the eye. The rough stone can leave an action legible while giving a viewer room to imagine a story around it.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The figures stop at different stagesThe Bearded Slave offers a comparatively legible torso. In the Atlas, much of the head is still held inside the block.
  • A gesture can survive a rough surfaceThe position of an arm can suggest a turn or a wish to hide even when the face and hands are hard to read.
  • A name can encourage a storyThe uncarved stone above Atlas resembles a burden. The name gives that mass a mythic explanation that the sculptor’s marks leave open.
  • The eye completes a movementPater asks us to finish the half-emergent form. The strongest invitation may be to join the visible points of a body into a lift or a turn.

Most visitors to the Accademia in Florence walk through a long hall toward the David and pass four giant marble men who never got out of their blocks, their surfaces still furrowed with the parallel grooves of the claw chisel. The group is known by names such as the Young Slave, the Bearded Slave, Atlas and the Awakening Slave. The names are worth a second look, because two of them describe a type of body while the other two describe an action that viewers decided they could see. In other words the labels are a record of what people have been finishing in these statues for centuries, which makes them the perfect test for Pater’s claim about what the unfinished marble asks of us.

Pater says Michelangelo achieves an ideal expression “by an incompleteness, which is surely not always undesigned, and which, as I think, no one regrets, and trusts to the spectator to complete the half-emergent form.” Just after it he adds that “his persons have something of the unwrought stone about them,” which leaves the question of what exactly we complete, and there are three serious candidates, which are a missing contour, a bodily action, or a story about creation in which the figure is struggling to free itself, and the four Prisoners, cut to four different depths, let us try each one.

Their history already pushes viewers toward the third answer. The four figures were intended for the tomb of Julius II and stayed in Florence when the project changed. They were later installed in the Grotta Grande at the Boboli Gardens. In an artificial cave, rough marble could look like rock still giving birth to a body. The figures are now in the Accademia.

Start with the Bearded Slave, the most finished of the four, whose torso is fully modeled and whose thighs are bound with straps of cloth, with only the hands and part of an arm left rough. Here the viewer completes almost nothing, perhaps the outline of the fingers, and the figure reads as a figure. If completing a contour were the main work unfinished marble gives us, the Bearded Slave would be the least interesting of the group, and it’s the one that gives the eye the least to do.

The Young Slave, who stands more than eight feet tall, is a different case, since one raised arm partly hides his face while the other crosses his hips. His pose gives us more to read than his expression. What viewers supply isn’t an outline but a feeling, shame or exhaustion or the wish to hide, and they get it from the action of the arm across the face, which is fully legible even where the surface is still rough with the marks of the claw chisel.

The Atlas is where the creation story takes over. His head is still buried in the block, so the mass of uncarved marble above his shoulders looks like a weight he’s carrying, and viewers named him after the Titan who holds up the sky. That’s the most seductive completion of all and the least reliable, because the burden is simply stone where a head was going to be, and the myth is something we’ve laid over an accident of carving, the way you might see a face in a cloud. To be fair to the story, it has deep roots, because Michelangelo’s poetry describes the form a sculptor seeks as contained within the marble, and generations of guides have read the Prisoners as souls straining toward freedom. That reading gives the statues a moral, and it’s easy to see why visitors love it, but it describes the sculptor’s method and our hopes more than anything the Atlas is actually doing.

The Awakening Slave, nearly nine feet of twisting marble and one of the roughest of the four, shows why the action reading has a real basis in the stone. Vasari describes a method of bringing the most projecting parts forward first, comparing it with a model that rises out of water. The wax Prisoner in the V&A lets us see how a small figure can mark out the pose. In the marble, those forward points give the eye enough to imagine the rest of the turn.

So my verdict is that what the spectator truly completes is the bodily action. The rough contours don’t need finishing, because the chisel has already laid down the high points of a movement and the eye joins them into a lift, a twist or a flinch, and that’s the part of Pater’s claim the stone itself supports. The story about creation, the figure fighting its way out of the rock, is something we bring, encouraged by the grotto, by names like Atlas and Awakening, and by Pater’s own lovely phrase about the half-emergent form, and it’s a fine story as long as we remember that it’s ours.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Which interpretation does the author ultimately believe is best supported by the unfinished stone itself?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.