Philosophy

What the Panel Should Leave to the Engineers

A citizens’ panel wants to help plan a light-rail line. The engineers know what the trains can do, but the panel still has to ask which neighborhoods the line should serve.

A light-rail proposal tests the Charmides’ distinction between expertise and the public good. Ireland’s Citizens’ Assembly offers a real example of how citizens can hear expert advice and make recommendations.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • What engineers can establishEngineers can say whether a bridge will carry the trains or whether a proposed grade is too steep. Citizens need enough explanation to judge the advice they receive.
  • Whom the line should serveA feasible route still leaves choices about access, disruption, and what else the city could do with the money.
  • Where facts and values meetA ridership forecast depends on assumptions about where people will live and how they will travel. A panel can ask what happens when those assumptions change.
  • A real division of responsibilityIreland’s Citizens’ Assembly heard expert testimony, deliberated, and sent recommendations to Parliament. The process gave citizens a role without transferring the legislature’s authority.

Charmides 171d–172a, 172a–d, 172e–173c, 173c–d, 174b–d, 174d–e · Mary Laffoy, Opening Statement to the Joint Oireachtas Committee p. 1, p. 2, p. 3

Imagine a mid-sized city planning a light-rail line from its downtown to its growing suburbs. The engineers have produced studies of possible routes, costs and ridership, and the council, wary of a project that will disrupt neighborhoods for years, has convened a citizens’ panel of forty residents chosen by lot to study the options and make recommendations. On the first morning, a panel member asks the question that will hang over every session, which is how much of this they are actually supposed to decide, and how much they should simply take from the experts. It’s a good question, and the honest answer is that nobody in the room knows yet, including the engineers.

The Charmides gives a first cut at an answer. In Socrates’ dream, temperance would make sure that every pilot, doctor and general was genuine, so that the crafts would do their own work without error, and yet whether that work made us do well and be happy “we cannot yet learn.” The crafts, as the later argument shows, achieve their own results “No less” without the knowledge of good and bad, but whether those results are done “well and beneficially” belongs to a different knowledge. The craft’s own standard of success leaves open whether its results help the people who receive them.

Some questions in the rail case clearly belong to the engineers. Whether a bridge can carry the trains, what gradient the cars can climb, how the signals must be spaced for safety, and what the construction will cost under various designs are questions of craft, and a citizens’ vote cannot establish those answers. A citizens’ panel that voted to put the tracks on a slope the trains can’t climb would be making the very mistake the temperate city was designed to prevent, letting people act outside what they know. Even here, though, the engineers owe the panel explanations it can follow, since a judgment the panel can’t understand is one it can only take on trust.

Other questions clearly don’t belong to the engineers, since which neighborhoods should get stations, whether to prioritize a district with few transit options or a route with higher projected ridership, how much disruption to impose on whom, and how much of the city’s budget to spend on this rather than on schools or housing are questions about what the city should pursue and who should bear the costs. No engineering study can answer them, since they are questions about the good of the community, and the Charmides would place them under a knowledge that no craft contains. The dream has no way to answer these questions. That gap is why Socrates pauses before saying that its well-run administration would make anyone happy.

The hardest questions are the ones in between, and they are where the dialogue’s neat division starts to strain. A ridership forecast looks technical, but it depends on assumptions about how people will live, where the city will grow and how much a minute of a commuter’s time is worth, and each assumption carries a judgment about values. A cost-benefit analysis looks like arithmetic, but the weight it gives to future benefits against present costs is a choice about how much the present owes the future. A good panel needs the engineers to show where these judgments are buried, so that the citizens can examine them instead of accepting them as facts. Asking for the assumptions gives the panel a way to understand why the estimate changes when the city makes different choices.

Ireland’s Citizens’ Assembly put a related division of responsibility into practice. In her opening statement to a parliamentary committee, chair Mary Laffoy described how 99 citizens were recruited at random using demographic quotas. The Assembly heard expert testimony and considered the Eighth Amendment over five weekends between November 2016 and April 2017. Its recommendations went to the Irish Parliament. This example has no tracks or bridges, but it shows what the city in our example would have to arrange. Experts and citizens need time to ask each other questions, and everyone needs to know who is responsible for the eventual decision.

This is also where the modern problem goes well beyond the dialogue’s imagined city. Socrates’ picture has only two kinds of people, those who know and those who are ruled, and it imagines temperance identifying every expert without error. A modern city has elected officials, budgets, courts, environmental reviews, public comment and a press, and its real question isn’t how to find the people who know, but how to share judgment among many parties who each know part of the picture and none of whom can be trusted with all of it. The Charmides names the knowledge that decides ends, but it gives no account of how a community could exercise it together.

A city could start by asking its engineers what would make each route feasible and its panel what the route would have to achieve to be worth building. The answers will meet in places such as the ridership forecast. A panel member who asks to see what the forecast assumes is doing part of the work of deciding whom the line will serve. Socrates’ dream gives us a reason to ask that question. It leaves the city to decide how the people with different answers will reach a decision together.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article’s use of the Charmides, why is successful technical work insufficient by itself to establish that a project benefits the community?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.