Philosophy

What the Narrator Saw

Critias gives no clear answer. Socrates says he was ashamed in front of the company, and the difference between those two claims matters.

The man who questioned Critias is also the man who tells us how Critias felt. Plato gives the reader a way to hear the account and ask what the narrator could know.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • What the room could hearSocrates reports that Critias gives no clear answer to his challenge about knowledge of knowledge. Other people in the room could hear the answer too.
  • What Socrates infersSocrates says Critias seemed to catch his perplexity and tells us that Critias was ashamed. Shame is his explanation of the unclear reply.
  • Another glimpse of the narratorSocrates also tells his listener how badly he lost his composure when Charmides approached. His willingness to tell that story gives us a reason to take him seriously while still weighing what he infers.
  • The argument and the personCritias’ failure to supply an answer leaves the proposed knowledge unproved in the exchange. Whether he was ashamed is a separate question about what went on in the room.

Charmides 155c–e, 162c–e, 169c–d · Wayne C. Booth, The Rhetoric of Fiction excerpt on narrative authority · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.3.15

The Charmides is narrated by Socrates himself, telling the story afterward to an unnamed friend, and that choice matters most at one particular moment. When Socrates sets out his difficulties and asks Critias to show that knowledge of knowledge is possible and beneficial, he reports that Critias “too seemed to me to be forced by my perplexity to be caught by perplexity himself,” and then adds an account of what was going on inside him, that since he was “used to being admired on every occasion, he was ashamed in front of the company,” wouldn’t admit he couldn’t make the distinctions, “said nothing clear, but kept covering up his perplexity.”

It helps to separate what Socrates reports from what he interprets. The people in the room could have heard Critias’ answer and judged its clarity. Whether he was confused or ashamed, whether he cared about being admired, and whether he was trying to hide any of it are further judgments. The story gives us one participant’s account of them. They might be good guesses. We can ask what in the account gives us reason to share them.

To his credit, Socrates marks the interpretation as his. He says Critias “seemed to me” to be caught by perplexity, which is the language of inference, not of certain knowledge, and readers who notice that phrase are being invited to hold the rest loosely. He used the same hedge earlier, when he told us Critias “seemed to me as angry with Charmides as a poet is with an actor who makes a mess of the poet’s own verses,” so this narrator has a habit of marking his readings of Critias as readings. Still, the explanation of Critias’ motive, that he was used to admiration and ashamed before the company, comes without a hedge, and it’s exactly the kind of claim a narrator might make with more confidence than his evidence allows.

Wayne Booth, in The Rhetoric of Fiction, asks how a narrative gives its teller the authority to know what the story requires. In his discussion of Emma, he adds that the angle of vision shapes the moral judgment of the story too. Those are useful questions to bring to Plato’s scene. Socrates was in the room and heard Critias’ answer. He was also the one who asked the question. The story his listener hears carries the judgments of the person whose challenge had just gone unanswered.

There’s reason to take this narrator seriously. Earlier, he tells his friend about his own loss of composure. He saw inside Charmides’ cloak, was on fire, and was no longer in his own possession. He’s willing to leave that episode in the story even though it makes him look awkward. His account of Critias is also consistent with the impatience he attributes to him when Charmides handles the earlier definition. These details make his reading plausible while leaving room to ask what he could have seen from where he sat.

The distinction matters differently for the argument and for Critias’ character. His failure to show that knowledge of knowledge is possible leaves the proposal unproved in the conversation. It leaves open what he might have said under different circumstances. If we accept Socrates’ account of the shame, we take the unclear answer as a sign of pride getting in the way. That judgment belongs to the narrator’s account. We can assess the argumentative gap without making it our own.

Readers who knew what Critias later did had another reason to find the scene telling. Xenophon depicts him, as one of the Thirty, in a dispute with Theramenes over putting people to death. That history can make a reader quick to credit an unflattering account of Critias. It gives the scene an edge without giving us access to what he felt in the wrestling school. Plato still leaves that particular judgment in Socrates’ hands.

My verdict is that Socrates gives us a plausible reading of Critias, and he gives us a phrase that lets us hear it as his reading. Critias “seemed to me” to catch his perplexity. We can grant that no clear answer was given and leave the question of shame open. That way we can attend to what the argument achieved and still notice the person who is telling us what it felt like to be there.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what is the significance of Socrates saying Critias “seemed to me” to be perplexed?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.