Philosophy
What Should We Expect at His Age?
Charmides can’t explain a saying he’s heard. Socrates makes allowances for his age and asks what Critias, with more years and study behind him, can make of it.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesMaking room for a beginner can be a kindness. Once Critias takes over and Charmides goes quiet, the dialogue gives us a chance to ask when an allowance becomes a lower expectation.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Socrates makes an allowanceWhen Charmides can’t explain the saying, Socrates says it’s understandable at his age. The remark takes some of the pressure off a young person answering in public.
- Critias is expected to knowSocrates names both age and study as reasons to expect more of Critias. Critias agrees to defend the saying and becomes the one who has to explain it.
- Age can matter in different waysThe Republic warns that young people can turn argument into a game. In the Theaetetus and Meno, Socrates also shows what young people can do with a question they can work on.
- Charmides comes back inCharmides leaves the long argument to Socrates and Critias. At the end he says that he still doesn’t know whether he’s temperate and asks for the charm to continue.
Charmides 162b–e, 162e–163a, 175e–176a, 176a–b · Republic 537d, 539b–d · Theaetetus 143e–144b · Meno 82b, 84a, 85b
The line comes just as Critias breaks into the argument. The boy has just suggested, with a sly laugh and a look across at his guardian, that “perhaps there is nothing to stop even the man who said it from not knowing what he meant,” and Critias, who has been on edge for a while, fixes his eyes on him and demands to know whether he really thinks the author of a saying doesn’t understand it just because the boy doesn’t. Socrates cuts in and gives the two of them different responsibilities. “But my good Critias,” he says, “it is no wonder that he doesn’t know, at his age.” To Critias he says, “You, though, may reasonably be expected to know,” citing his age and the study he’s put in. It’s a gracious sentence, and it’s worth asking exactly whom it’s gracious to and what it costs.
The first reading is that the line protects a novice, and it does. A young man who has just been caught repeating a saying he can’t explain, in front of a crowd and next to a guardian who’s losing patience, needs somebody to say out loud that not knowing is normal at his age. Think of a teacher telling a high schooler who freezes on a question borrowed from a graduate seminar that it’s hard material and he’s allowed to be new to it. It gives the boy a chance to save face when the question has become personal. Socrates says Critias seemed as angry with the boy as a poet with an actor who mangles his verses. It’s a lot of anger to aim at a kid, and the first job of Socrates’ line is simply to get the boy out of the line of fire.
The second reading is that the line puts the burden where it belongs, and that’s true as well. Socrates suspects that Charmides heard the saying from Critias. In any case, Critias is older, has given the subject some study and is about to agree with the definition. He has good reason to take his turn explaining it. It’s the expectation that the senior partner at a firm should know more than the summer intern. Here the older person is expected to make good on the knowledge his age and study are supposed to have brought him.
The third reading is the uncomfortable one, that “at his age” can harden into a ceiling. Excusing someone for not knowing can slide very easily into not expecting him to think, and you can watch that risk play out in the dialogue, because Critias agrees to take over and Charmides falls silent until the end. Socrates and Critias do the talking while Charmides sits beside them. The allowance that protected him also gives him a way out of answering. We do this to kids all the time, when we let them off a hard question because they’re young and then wonder years later why they never got into the habit of answering hard questions.
Plato did have a real reason to be careful about young people and argument. In the Republic, Socrates warns that youngsters can treat their first taste of argument as a game. They imitate those who refute them and go after others like puppies that love to pull and tear at anyone nearby. They can lose trust in what they once believed and give philosophy a bad name. In the proposed education for the city’s future rulers, a select group moves on to dialectic at about thirty. Charmides’ sly laugh has a little of the puppy about it. You can hear “at his age” as a reminder that it takes time to learn what to do with a skill for catching someone out.
But Plato also shows young people thinking brilliantly when they’re given the chance and the right kind of questions. In the Theaetetus, Socrates spends a whole long conversation on the nature of knowledge with a young man whom his teacher praises for being quick to learn and gentle and brave all at once, a combination the teacher says he has hardly ever met, and Socrates takes him seriously as a partner in the inquiry. In the Meno, he walks an enslaved boy through a geometry problem. The boy makes mistakes, then follows the questions far enough to point to the diagonal that gives the right result. The two scenes make it hard to equate youth with an inability to think.
That distinction resolves most of the tension in Socrates’ line, because the line is about accountability rather than capacity. The boy gets some leeway when he can’t explain a saying he’s heard. He’s already shown he can think about it. His remark that the author might not know what he meant is a sharp observation about borrowed slogans. The danger is only that the excuse becomes an exit, and for most of what follows it partly does, until the boy comes back at the very end and says what he thinks.
My verdict is that the line is fair as a way of distributing responsibility and kind as a piece of manners, but risky as a habit. It rightly puts the burden of explanation on the man who agrees to defend the saying and gives Charmides some room to be a beginner. It also leaves him on the sidelines for much of the discussion. At the close, Charmides says he doesn’t know whether he has temperance and asks to be charmed every day. He can come back to the question without claiming to have solved it. That’s what a good allowance at his age can make room for.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What distinction does the author use to resolve most of the tension in Socrates’ treatment of Charmides?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does relieving a beginner of responsibility create room for growth, and when does it instead discourage participation?→
- How might Socrates have protected Charmides from Critias’ anger while still keeping him actively involved in the inquiry?→
- What signs would help distinguish playful argument that develops judgment from argument used merely to catch or defeat another person?→