Greek Antiquity
What Should an Initiate Remember After a Rite?
The hymn asks Mnemosyne to keep a rite’s words, actions, and purpose alive in its initiates.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsRemembering a rite could mean recalling what happened or carrying its intention back into life. The hymn’s petition brings these possibilities together when it asks Memory to send Forgetting away.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The closing prayerThe initiates ask Mnemosyne to awaken remembrance of the well-hallowed rite and send Forgetting away.
- Words to be recalledThe article turns to the gold leaves for examples of instructions an initiate would need to remember.
- A purpose in the breastThe hymn calls Mnemosyne a lover of wakefulness and describes her bringing stored intentions to mind.
- A rite carried into lifeThe comparison with the oracle at Lebadeia suggests how recollection can continue the work begun during a rite.
Orphic Hymns, LXXVII.5–10, with the note on LXXVII.9–10; LXXXV.5–8, with the note on LXXXV.8
The hymn to Mnemosyne closes with a precise request. “But, blessed goddess, rouse in the initiates the memory / of the well-hallowed rite, and send forgetfulness away from them.” The edition’s note says that the pairing of memory and forgetting frames “the whole book’s account of what an initiation is for,” and states it plainly, that “the rite is to be remembered.” The question is what remembering a rite would actually involve, since a rite is not a fact to be stored but an event made of actions, words and intentions, and a person can remember any of those without remembering the others.
The first possibility is the acts and words themselves. Ancient mysteries were made of things done, things shown and things said, and the initiate who remembered them could perform them again or recognize them when they returned. The gold leaves buried with initiates show memory in this sense, since they record instructions the dead must recall, to avoid the first spring by the white cypress and drink instead from the lake of Memory, and to say to its guardians that they are children of Earth and starry Heaven. The leaf from Hipponion opens by calling itself the work of Memory, so the rite’s words were written down precisely because forgetting them would be fatal, and the leaf from Petelia, now in the British Museum, was later rolled into a little case and hung on a chain, so that the instructions could be worn.
The second possibility is the purpose the rite planted. The hymn has just described Mnemosyne as “putting all things in mind, / whatever each man lays up always as purpose in his breast,” and the edition renders that word purpose throughout, the intention a person stores up and is reminded of. On this reading, remembering the rite means carrying forward what it asked of the initiate, the intention it formed, so that the memory is not a record but a resolve kept alive. That fits the goddess’s epithet in the same passage, “lover of wakefulness,” since a purpose has to be kept awake in a way a fact does not.
The company Forgetting keeps in the collection supports the second reading. In the hymn to Sleep, a few pages later, Hypnos is called “own brother to Lethe and to Thanatos,” and the note there observes that Lethe is named as a person only in that line and that she “is asked away at LXXVII.10.” So the forgetting the initiates ask to be spared is the sister of Sleep and Death, and memory of the rite is set against both of them. To forget the rite would be to fall asleep to it, and to let it die, while to remember it is to stay awake, which is just what a lover of wakefulness would grant.
The oracle of Trophonius at Lebadeia makes the same connection in practice. Pausanias, who consulted it himself, says that the inquirer first drank from two springs, the water of Lethe to forget everything he had been thinking of, and the water of Mnemosyne to remember what he would see below. When he came back up, the priests seated him on the throne of Memory and asked what he had seen and learned. The rite began by clearing the mind and ended by fixing in it what the descent had shown, and the throne of Memory was where the experience became something the inquirer could keep.
Plato gave the pairing its most famous philosophical form. In the myth that ends the Republic, souls on their way to rebirth cross the plain of Lethe and drink from the river of Unmindfulness, and those not saved by wisdom drink too much and forget everything, while Socrates hopes that we will cross that river well. Er himself, sent back to tell what he had seen, was not allowed to drink at all, so that he could remember and report. In the Meno he argues that learning is recollection, the soul remembering what it once knew, so that memory is the very form of understanding. For a Platonist, remembering a rite would mean remembering what the rite pointed to, and forgetting would be the soul’s ordinary condition, the sleep from which teaching and ritual try to wake it.
The Christian liturgy is built on exactly this kind of remembering. At the Last Supper Jesus tells his disciples to do this in remembrance of him, and the Greek word is anamnēsis, the same word Plato uses for recollection, while the Passover before it was given as a day to be kept for a memorial throughout the generations. The Prayer Book speaks of Christ instituting a perpetual memory of his death until his coming again, and the memory meant is not a recollection of facts but a continual renewal of what the rite accomplished, carried forward into the lives of those who share it.
My verdict is that the prayer asks for more than recall of acts and words, though it includes them, and that its real object is the purpose the rite planted, kept awake against Forgetting and her brothers Sleep and Death. The initiate is to remember the rite the way the inquirer at Lebadeia remembered his descent, by sitting on the throne of Memory and carrying what he saw back into life. A rite remembered in that sense is a rite continued, and the hymn’s closing pair of memory and forgetting asks the goddess to keep the initiates awake to what they have been given.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What does the author ultimately identify as the primary object of remembering a rite?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If remembering a rite means continuing its purpose, how might someone tell whether that purpose is genuinely still “awake” in their life?→
- Does the article’s distinction between recalling ritual words and sustaining ritual purpose hold firmly, or can the words and actions themselves preserve the purpose?→
- Why might forgetting be necessary at the beginning of the Lebadeian experience but dangerous after it, and what does that suggest about the proper relationship between memory and forgetting?→