Renaissance

What Philosophy Wakes Up After Analysis

A fragment from Novalis turns Pater’s Conclusion from dissolving experience to noticing it. A hand, a face and a sound on the hills give the new practice something to do.

Pater uses the Romantic fragment to change what he asks of philosophy. The first and fourth editions show how a sudden jolt becomes a sustained practice of attention.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Analysis ends with a moving impressionPater breaks down the apparent solidity of experience until he reaches an impression that is already passing.
  • Novalis makes inquiry an enlivening activityThe German fragment asks what philosophy can do to wake up the person who practices it.
  • A hand or a tone gives attention a place to startPater tests the new task of philosophy against particular things a reader might see, hear or think.
  • The revision makes attention a way of livingIn 1893 the call is for constant observation, and Pater describes its source as philosophy and speculative culture.

By the end of its second paragraph the Conclusion has hit bottom, since experience has shrunk to impressions, the impressions to a vanishing instant, and the self to “that strange, perpetual, weaving and unweaving of ourselves,” which is where, Pater says, “analysis leaves off.” Then a new paragraph opens with Pater’s version of a German fragment, “Philosophiren, says Novalis, ist dephlegmatisiren, vivificiren,” which the edition translates as “To philosophize, says Novalis, is to dispel sluggishness, to bring to life.” It feels like a coach who has just walked the team through the terrifying stats on the other side and then claps once and says that’s exactly why we’re going to win.

Novalis was the pen name of Friedrich von Hardenberg, an early German Romantic who studied at the mining academy in Freiberg and worked at the saltworks based in Weißenfels. In the fragment Pater draws on, the next sentences object to treating philosophy like a dead thing that can be dissected and put back together. Pater recasts the opening as “to philosophize” and keeps the two verbs that describe what the activity can do to a living mind. Philosophy, on this view, is an activity done to the person who philosophizes, and the person comes out of it changed.

The first verb carries a double meaning that suits Pater perfectly. In the old medicine of the four humors, phlegm was the cold, sluggish one, so to dephlegmatize is to shake off dullness, which is the sense the edition gives. In the chemistry of Novalis’s time, dephlegmation could also mean removing water from spirits to concentrate what remained. His scientific training makes that resonance worth hearing in the word. Read that way, philosophy distills you, and Pater’s own verb a few lines earlier fits it exactly, since what is real in our life “fines itself down,” the way a refiner fines a wine or a metal.

Heard that way, the chemistry changes what the preceding analysis can be for. The analysis that seemed to dissolve the world was doing the work of a still, boiling off the watery bulk of habit and solid objects until something sharp remained, the “single sharp impression” at the bottom of the glass. So when Pater turns, he isn’t contradicting the analysis, he’s announcing what it was for. Philosophy took things apart, and now the same discipline is told to wake you up, and Pater says so plainly, writing that its service “towards the human spirit, is to rouse, to startle it to a life of constant and eager observation.”

The revisions of 1893 show him carefully tuning that new job description. In 1873 the service belonged to “philosophy, and of religion and culture as well,” and its aim was “to startle it into a sharp and eager observation,” while in 1893 religion drops out, as the note on the earlier text points out, and the sentence gains “to rouse” and “a life of constant” observation. The first version is a jolt, a cold splash that wakes you for a moment, and the second is a way of living, which makes the hinge sturdier, since Pater is asking for wakefulness that continues after the initial shock.

The new verbs need objects, and Pater supplies them right away. “Every moment some form grows perfect in hand or face; some tone on the hills or the sea is choicer than the rest; some mood of passion or insight or intellectual excitement is irresistibly real and attractive to us,” and then the kicker, “for that moment only.” The repeated “some” is the point, because you can’t know in advance which hand will find its perfect shape or which slope will catch the light, so the eye has to stay ready, the way photographers wait through the whole late afternoon for the ten minutes when a hillside goes gold. The list moves from bodies to landscape to the inner weather of moods, so the waking covers everything the analysis had dissolved. The list even ends inside the mind, with insight and intellectual excitement, so thinking itself becomes one of the things you’re meant to catch at its peak.

Then come the practical questions, which read like a training plan for the senses. “How may we see in them all that is to be seen in them by the finest senses? How shall we pass most swiftly from point to point, and be present always at the focus where the greatest number of vital forces unite in their purest energy?” In 1873 the second question asked “How can we pass,” and the change to “How shall we” turns a doubt about ability into a statement of resolve. Hume, at the end of the first book of his Treatise, escaped the gloom of skeptical analysis by going off to dine and play backgammon with friends until his speculations seemed cold and ridiculous, and Pater takes the opposite exit, turning the same gloom into a reason to look harder.

The Novalis sentence is the hinge on which the Conclusion turns from analysis to practice. The chemical echo lets us imagine that what has been taken apart can yield a more concentrated impression. The hand, the face and the hillside keep the new philosophy from becoming a mood, since they give the reader something definite to catch, and the 1893 changes make observation a whole way of life rather than a single startle. Pater demotes philosophy from builder of systems to waker of sleepers, and in his book that’s a promotion.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article interpret Pater’s turn from analysis to the Novalis aphorism?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.