Renaissance
What Pater Sees in a Pupil-Less Eye
Pater’s pale marbles invite him to look away from the face and read the whole body. Greek sculptors sometimes gave those faces a much more definite gaze.
The Renaissance (1893)Painted marble and inlaid bronze give the statue back some of the attention Pater takes away from its eyes. His way of looking still helps a viewer notice what a shoulder, hand or shift of weight can express.
Orientation
At a Glance
- What Pater noticesPater says an eye without a pupil draws no more attention than the hands, lips or feet of the figure.
- A gaze preserved in bronzeThe Charioteer at Delphi retains inlaid eyes, an example of the distinct gaze an ancient maker could give a figure.
- What colour could addPaint could bring out details of hair and eyes on marble, changing the distribution of attention in the finished work.
- A reason to look at the bodyPater’s account can still make a viewer attend to posture and balance even when the face has plenty to say.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, pp. 137–138, pure form and the pupil-less eye · Winckelmann, note 309 · Winckelmann, p. 141, eyes, hair and the movement of the whole body
Stand in front of almost any ancient marble head in a museum and you’ll notice the thing Pater noticed, which is that it doesn’t look back at you. “In it, no member of the human form is more significant than the rest,” he writes, “the eye is wide, and without pupil; the lips and brow are hardly less significant than hands, and breasts, and feet.” A few pages later he adds that “The eyes are wide and directionless, not fixing anything with their gaze,” with “the brows without hair,” and that the hair is “withdrawn from attention,” its texture and color lost. From these details he builds a whole theory of sculpture as an art of repose. The trouble is that many Greek figures once had features that gave their gaze a much more definite presence.
Some of the evidence comes from the figures themselves. Colour on ancient marble could pick out details of the face and hair. The bronze Charioteer of Delphi retains its inlaid eyes. The museum describes white enamel and brown and black stone used to distinguish the parts of the eye.
So a blank gaze can be the result of what time has taken away, including paint and inlays. Pater half knows this, since he grants that sculpture “has had, indeed, from the beginning an unfixed claim to colour,” but he treats the color as “more or less conventional” and moves on. The question of painted sculpture had been argued in Europe since early in the nineteenth century, so this wasn’t secret knowledge even when Pater first wrote. His account makes most sense if we take it as a response to many works as he could see them.
But it would be a mistake to throw the passage out, because Pater is really doing two things at once, and the second one is valuable. He is also offering a theory of attention, a set of instructions for what a viewer might notice. A face without a gaze stops pulling your eyes toward itself, and once the eyes stop pulling, the rest of the body can speak, the way a dancer’s whole figure reads from the back row of a theater where nobody can see her eyes, so that the turn of a shoulder, the weight on one leg or the angle of a wrist carries as much feeling as a smile. That’s what he means when he says the lips and brow are “hardly less significant than hands, and breasts, and feet.”
This runs against one of the strongest habits human vision has. A portrait often gives the viewer a reason to look for a meeting of eyes. Pater asks how else we might direct that attention. Pater’s ideal asks you to unlearn that, to look at a body the way you’d look at a landscape, taking it in as a whole instead of hunting for the eyes, and many Greek sculptors really did spread expression through the whole figure through posture, balance and the set of the limbs.
The directionless gaze also serves his larger argument about repose. A statue that stares at something has a situation, a story about what it’s looking at, while a statue that looks at nothing in particular escapes into what Pater calls “the repose of his unchanging characteristics,” presenting a type rather than a moment. That’s the sculptural equivalent of a sentence with no tense, and it fits his claim that sculpture “unveils man” in the “tranquil godship in him, as opposed to the restless accidents of life.”
So we have to keep the preference and the claim apart. The claim, that Greek sculpture was made with blank eyes, faint hair and a deliberate equality of features, leaves out the gaze and hair some artists took pains to make visible. The preference, that the best way to look at these bodies is to let the face stop dominating and read the whole figure, is a real insight into how the surviving works can be seen, and it happens to describe some genuine Greek achievements in balance and posture. Pater’s own best phrase for those achievements is his remark that the Greeks gave their figures “a mobile, a vital, individuality” in spite of sculpture’s limits, which is a claim about bodies in motion, and it holds up whether or not the eyes were painted.
My verdict is that Pater’s pupil-less eye is a theory of looking dressed up as a fact of history. He took the condition in which the statues reached him and made it a principle of the art, even though surviving inlays show that some makers gave their figures a distinct gaze. Read as advice on how to look at what survives, though, the passage is excellent, because it trains your attention away from the face and onto the whole body, which is where the sculptors put most of their skill.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author describe Pater’s pupil-less eye as “a theory of looking dressed up as a fact of history”?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does separating Pater’s historical claim from his viewing preference change the way we judge the value of his interpretation?→
- If missing paint and inlays shape modern responses to ancient sculpture, can those responses still produce valid insights about the surviving works? Why or why not?→
- What might viewers notice about posture, balance, and gesture when they resist the impulse to search first for a statue’s gaze?→