Renaissance
What Pater’s Wrestler Owes to a Restorer
The young man in Berlin raises his hands in a gesture made by a later restorer. Pater’s reading begins with that gesture.
The Renaissance (1893)The so-called Praying Boy lets us separate the effect of an ancient bronze, the contribution of modern arms and the story Pater tells about a victorious wrestler.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A reading starts with the handsPater sees a young athlete offering thanks after a victory.
- The arms belong to a later periodThe Berlin museum identifies the arms as additions, which makes the exact gesture uncertain for the ancient figure.
- The head and body still give cluesThe surviving bronze suggests an upward movement even though it leaves the original hand positions open.
- The restored work has a historyPater describes a real object that circulated and was copied in its composite form, with an interpretation added at each stage.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, the Adorante and the wrestler’s prize · Note 315, the restored arms of the Praying Boy · Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, bronze youth known as the Praying Boy · German Archaeological Institute, the Praying Boy’s provenance and interpretations · Museum of Classical Archaeology, Cambridge, the raised pose and restored arms
Pater closes his description of Greek sculpture’s youthful ideal with one statue that seems to gather everything together. It’s “the adorante of the museum of Berlin, a youth who has gained the wrestler’s prize, with hands lifted and open, in praise for the victory,” and Pater says it is “the image of man as he springs first from the sleep of nature, his white light taking no colour from any one-sided experience.” The edition’s note points out the problem, which is that the Berlin museum identifies the arms as modern additions. So the gesture at the heart of Pater’s reading, the lifted, open hands of praise, isn’t ancient, and the Discussion question is how much of his interpretation survives that fact.
The statue’s travels show how much its meaning has depended on those arms. The bronze is said to have been found on Rhodes and is documented in Venice by 1503. It passed through a succession of European collections before Frederick the Great acquired it in 1747. Its changing names and homes show how differently collectors understood the same figure. The name “praying boy” stuck because of the raised arms that restorers gave it in the seventeenth century.
So the first thing to say is that Pater’s reading depends on the restoration in a very specific way. The prayer, the praise and the openness of the hands all come from the added arms, and without them the statue could be reaching for anything, or holding something, or forming part of a group, which the Berlin museum itself thinks quite likely. Pater’s sentence about the gesture is a fine description of a seventeenth-century idea of what an ancient youth might be doing. The restorers’ guess wasn’t absurd, but it was a guess, and the suggestions made since then range from an athlete to a shepherd to one figure in a lost group.
The “wrestler’s prize” is a different case, since nothing in the statue or its history points to wrestling at all. Pater follows a tradition of interpreting the figure as a victorious athlete and specifies a wrestler’s prize, a detail the surviving bronze cannot confirm, and it has less authority than the gesture, which at least exists in metal.
But a good part of what Pater says rests on the ancient body, and that part holds up. The torso, legs and head are a real Hellenistic bronze, usually dated around 300 BC and linked to the circle of Lysippus, and its youthful modeling, its balance and its unforced stance are exactly what Pater means by “Fresh, unperplexed.” His larger claim that the figure is “characterless, so far as character involves subjection to the accidental influences of life” is about the face and body, and it’s a fair description of the original. His “white light” is plainly a metaphor, since the statue is dark bronze, and it describes a quality of innocence in the modeling rather than a color. The upward tilt of the head and the lift of the shoulders are ancient too, which is presumably why the restorers raised the arms in the first place, so the impulse toward the sky that Pater felt isn’t entirely their invention.
There’s also a strong case that Pater’s reading has authority as an interpretation of the object he actually knew. For three centuries the praying boy existed in exactly that form, studied, copied, admired and loved by Frederick the Great, and its restored version is a real historical artifact, a collaboration between a Hellenistic sculptor and a seventeenth-century restorer. Audiences in the eighteenth century saw King Lear almost entirely in Nahum Tate’s rewrite, where Cordelia survives, and a critic who praised that ending was describing a real play, just not Shakespeare’s. Pater is doing something similar, giving a sensitive reading of the composite statue that Europe had built and loved. That composite had its own influence, too, since casts and copies of the praying boy went out to palaces and gardens across Europe, so later audiences could encounter the restored gesture well beyond Berlin.
The danger lies in treating that reading as evidence about Greek life, which is exactly how Pater uses it, as the single instance in which “All these effects are united.” His argument needs an ancient image of the athlete as worshipper, and the image he found turns out to be the work of a later age that shared his wishes. That’s a warning about how ideals get confirmed, since collectors who wanted a praying Greek boy made one, and critics who wanted the same thing found it waiting in the museum.
My verdict is that Pater’s response keeps its authority in two of its three layers. As a reading of the ancient body it’s perceptive and largely right, and as a reading of the restored statue that stood in Berlin it’s a fine piece of criticism of a real object. As evidence for how Greek athletes thanked their gods, though, it has none, because the gesture belongs to the restorers and the particular sport belongs to his reading, and the honest way to read his sentence now is as a portrait of three makers, the ancient sculptor, the seventeenth-century restorer and the Victorian critic, each adding something the others didn’t put there.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article regard Pater’s claim about a “wrestler’s prize” as less authoritative than his description of raised hands?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the raised arms are not ancient but shaped the statue’s identity for centuries, should they be treated mainly as a distortion, as part of the object’s history, or as both? Why?→
- What criteria should determine whether an interpretation of a restored artwork tells us about the original culture, the restoring culture, or the critic’s own ideals?→
- How does separating the ancient body, the seventeenth-century restoration, and Pater’s Victorian interpretation change what it means to call his reading perceptive?→