Renaissance
What Pagan Columns Keep Inside a Roman Church
Ancient columns survive in a Christian nave. Pater uses such pieces to argue for continuity, but the stones carry different kinds of history.
The Renaissance (1893)The basilica, a reused capital and stone taken from an amphitheater show three ways the ancient world could survive. Each preserves something different.
Orientation
At a Glance
- An ancient detail in a Christian settingSome of the capitals in Santa Maria in Trastevere were carved with the heads of Egyptian gods before they were reused in the church.
- A building type can stay in useThe basilica survives as an architectural arrangement, while a reused shaft preserves an individual piece of stone.
- A quarry keeps only the materialCutting an amphitheater apart keeps its stone in circulation at the expense of the building it belonged to.
- Pater’s larger claim needs more evidenceA reused object can make continuity visible without telling us whether later viewers knew what it once meant.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, reused shafts, basilicas and ancient stone · Winckelmann, Pater’s argument against absolute divisions · Turismo Roma, Santa Maria in Trastevere and its columns · Dale Kinney, the carved capitals from the Baths of Caracalla · Archaeological Park of the Colosseum, quarrying and consecration · Metropolitan Museum of Art, Raphael’s study of antiquity · Internet Culturale, Raphael and Castiglione’s letter to Leo X
Go into Santa Maria in Trastevere in Rome and look at the columns lining the nave, twenty-two ancient granite shafts generally associated with the Baths of Caracalla, and you’ll notice that they don’t quite match, because nobody carved them for this building. Some Ionic capitals incorporated during the twelfth-century rebuilding originally bore heads identified as Isis, Serapis and Harpocrates. The figures were damaged or removed during a nineteenth-century restoration under Pius IX. That nave is Pater’s sentence in stone, since he says Christian art was “still dependent on pagan examples, building the shafts of pagan temples into its churches, perpetuating the form of the basilica, in later times working the disused amphitheatres as stone-quarries.”
The sentence is doing a job inside a bigger argument, and it helps to see the job before judging the evidence. Pater is attacking the “trenchant and absolute divisions” of art history, the habit of setting pagan against Christian and treating the Renaissance as a fashion that switched on at a fixed date, and against it he offers “the deeper view,” which “preserves the identity of European culture” and holds that “the Renaissance was an uninterrupted effort of the middle age, that it was ever taking place.” The stones are meant to make that visible, as relics that “Christian art had buried in itself, ready to work wonders when their day came.” It’s the logic of a sample in a hip-hop track, where an old record sits inside a new song for years until some kid digs out the original and a whole lost sound comes back.
But the three things in Pater’s list aren’t the same kind of keeping, and the differences matter more than he lets on. The basilica was a Roman building type, a big hall for law courts and business, and when Constantine began building churches in the fourth century the Christians took over its long nave and its apse as the shape of their worship, so the form stayed alive by being used every week for a thousand years. The temple shafts are objects moved from one setting into another, and they carry their history along whether or not anybody cares about it. The quarried amphitheaters are different again, since a quarry keeps old stone in circulation by cutting it up for raw material, and nothing of the original survives except the substance.
The columns are the most photogenic evidence and also the most ambiguous. The columns brought substantial pieces of ancient stone into the church. Their mismatch shows that the builders could use them without reproducing their original setting. The heads endured for centuries, although what medieval worshippers made of them is harder to recover. In that little story, knowledge didn’t wake the relics up to “work wonders,” it got them defaced, which runs the opposite way from what Pater’s image promises.
The quarry is worse for the thesis, and this is where the dates start to bite. The Colosseum supplied stone and other building material for centuries. Pope Benedict XIV issued an edict against desecrating it in 1744 and dedicated its arena to the Passion and the martyrs for the Jubilee of 1750. The archaeological park places the end of the quarrying around the middle of the eighteenth century. So the stage Pater files under “later times” belongs largely to the Renaissance itself, which means the age that rediscovered antiquity was also the age that broke it into building blocks.
Raphael, who turns up a page later in Pater as the painter who slipped pagan blitheness into Christian pictures, is the perfect witness here. Leo X gave Raphael responsibility for ancient marbles found in Rome in 1515. A few years later Raphael and Baldassare Castiglione prepared a letter to the pope lamenting how much ancient sculpture and ornament had been burned for lime. The supervision of marble for building and the desire to preserve the ancient city met in the same career, which gives you a truer picture of how antiquity actually passed into the Renaissance than any column standing in a nave.
That leaves a gap between the image and the thesis, and Pater’s own page shows where it lies. The image says old things survive inside new ones, and the thesis says a culture’s mind never broke, but a column can stand for a thousand years in a church where nobody gives a thought to what it once meant, so physical survival proves very little about the continuity of attention. When Pater really argues the thesis he leans on something else, the medieval spirit “keeping unbroken the thread of its traditions” while it let the mind rest, “that when day came it might awake, with eyes refreshed, to those ancient, ideal forms.” That’s a claim about tradition and attention, and it doesn’t need the stones at all, while his report that to the ascetic the unearthed statues looked “as if an ancient plague-pit had been opened” shows that people at the time felt a rupture, whatever the columns were doing.
The antique stones inside the church make a great image and a weak proof, and the strongest item in Pater’s list is the least picturesque one, the basilica, a form kept alive by use. The shafts show prestige and convenience more than any memory of style, and the quarry shows that keeping and destroying were often a single act, carried out by the very people who were supposedly reviving the past. Pater is right that “trenchant and absolute divisions” falsify the history of art, but the truer picture is a salvage yard where things are kept, broken, forgotten and found again, and that’s a rougher sort of continuity than “an uninterrupted effort.”
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author consider the basilica the strongest example of continuity in Pater’s list?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How should historians distinguish between the survival of an object, the survival of a form, and the survival of cultural attention?→
- If preservation and destruction occurred together during the Renaissance, should that change what it means to call the period a revival of antiquity?→
- Does the author’s image of history as a salvage yard offer a more convincing model of cultural continuity than Pater’s idea of an uninterrupted effort? Why or why not?→