Renaissance
What Makes an Empty Road Solemn?
A road in a Legros etching and a haystack under storm light help Pater distinguish what the artist sustains from what the weather gives for a moment.
The Renaissance (1893)A disappearing white road makes Pater’s argument about matter and form concrete. The etching holds a feeling throughout the scene that changing light can bestow on a field only briefly.
Orientation
At a Glance
- What the etching depictsA white road rises and disappears at the edge of a hill. That simple feature gives Pater a way into the problem of artistic form.
- Where the feeling beginsPater leaves open whether the solemnity began in the scene or in Legros’s own mood.
- What the artist holdsThe etcher carries that expression throughout the finished work, so the feeling belongs to the road as we see it.
- What the weather lendsPassing storm light can briefly give a haystack, trees and grass the unity that a picture can sustain.
The Renaissance · The School of Giorgione, p. 90, Legros’s road and storm light · The School of Giorgione, note 213
After a page of abstract talk Pater admits it needs grounding, saying that “this abstract language becomes clear enough, if we think of actual examples,” and the first example he reaches for is about as plain as a landscape gets. “In an actual landscape we see a long white road, lost suddenly on the hill-verge,” and that, he says, is the matter of one of the etchings of Alphonse Legros, the French-born printmaker who settled in London and taught at the Slade. Pater does not give the plate a title, but his description is enough to show what he finds in it. A road disappearing over a rise leaves the feeling to the way it is pictured.
Pater says the etching “is informed by an indwelling solemnity of expression, seen upon it or half-seen, within the limits of an exceptional moment, or caught from his own mood perhaps, but which he maintains as the very essence of the thing, throughout his work.” That sentence offers a couple of origins for the solemnity and shrugs at choosing between them, since maybe the road really looked that way for a rare minute and maybe Legros brought the feeling with him. Then the “but” moves the weight onto the one thing that doesn’t depend on where the feeling came from, which is that he maintains it. “Indwelling” matters too, because it says the solemnity lives inside the road instead of being pasted on top like a caption.
A road can carry a lot, and Legros knew it, as his etching Death of the Vagabond shows with its man lying under a leaning tree, which is solemnity delivered with a story and a body. Pater’s description gives us just the road climbing a rise and vanishing, which works like the last shot of a road movie, where the highway goes over the hill and drops out of sight while the credits start. “Lost suddenly” is the phrase that does it, because your eye follows the road to the top and then has nowhere left to go, so you’re left standing at the near end of the road, looking at a place you can’t see.
Think about what an etcher actually has to work with, because it explains a lot. In an etching like the one Pater describes, a printmaker can suggest a white road by leaving the paper bare and drawing the forms around it. Legros often used a spare set of marks in his landscapes. Each stretch of hatching and each change of tone then has to sit in the same key, or the mood cracks, the way one joke in a eulogy can break a room. That’s what maintaining an expression “throughout his work” looks like in practice, and it means the matter of the picture, a road, has literally become the shape left by the handling.
Then Pater turns to nature doing something similar by accident. “Sometimes a momentary hint of stormy light may invest a homely or too familiar scene with a character which might well have been drawn from the deep places of the imagination,” and the light he has in mind is “this sudden inweaving of gold thread through the texture of the haystack, and the poplars, and the grass,” which, he says, makes the scene look like a picture. The gold thread is the image he’d used a page earlier for Titian’s coloring, now borrowed by the weather, and the idea that a real field can look like a picture anticipates the paradox Oscar Wilde puts forward in The Decay of Lying, that nature imitates art.
Pater calls these effects “tricks of circumstance,” and the phrase is exact, since storm light is a trick in both senses, a lucky break and a bit of sleight of hand, and it lasts about as long as a cloud takes to cross the sun. In 1890–91 Monet painted stacks of wheat in changing light and seasons, returning to the same subject in one canvas after another, which shows how hard it is to hold an effect that nature hands out for free. So the haystack and the road differ in time and in choice, because the storm gives a scene its quality everywhere at once for a few minutes, while the etcher has to build the quality mark by mark and keep it going from one edge of the plate to the other.
The obvious objection is that the solemnity is just us. Roads mean journeys and departures and endings, any empty road at dusk feels heavy because of what we bring to it, and Pater himself allows that the feeling may have been “caught from his own mood perhaps.” But if association did all the work, every empty road would be solemn, and every phone photo of a highway taken from a car window would hit the way a Legros does, which plainly isn’t true. Association supplies a possibility that a road could mean something, and the handling decides whether that possibility gets realized or stays a cliché of the open road.
So what makes an empty road solemn is a single expression held across every part of the image, so that nothing in it is neutral and nothing argues with the mood, and that’s why Pater put this example first in an essay about art reaching for the condition of music, since the road’s matter means nothing apart from its handling. The storm light proves that ordinary places can carry that kind of expression for a moment, and I think Pater’s real point is that the artist’s job is to make the moment stay, which is the difference between being lucky with a haystack and being Legros with a road.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what matters most about the uncertain origin of the road’s solemnity?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a mood seems to “indwell” an image, how could we decide whether it belongs to the subject itself, the artist’s handling, or the viewer’s response?→
- Does sustaining one expression across every part of an artwork deepen its emotional power, or can conflicting details sometimes make an image more compelling?→
- If nature can transform an ordinary scene through a brief accident of light, what—if anything—distinguishes that experience from a deliberately created work of art?→