Renaissance
What Leonardo Carried Out of Verrocchio’s Workshop
Pater finds the goldsmith’s shop in the care Leonardo gives to a painted surface. Leonardo’s own note on soldering offers a more direct connection.
The Renaissance (1893)The detail in the pictures Pater names may belong to several painters. Leonardo’s recollection of the cathedral globe helps explain how the workshop remained part of his thinking.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The shop worked across materialsVerrocchio’s workshop made objects for sacred and ordinary use as well as paintings and sculptures. Pater sees the range as part of Leonardo’s training.
- Pater sees that training in small detailsNeedlework, carved gems and colored stones catch his eye. He links their precision to the care a metalworker gives to an object’s finish.
- Attribution changes the examplesThe Louvre assigns the Virgin of the Balances to a follower. A detail in that picture can help describe the school without proving Leonardo painted it.
- The cathedral globe offers a direct linkVerrocchio’s workshop made the gilded copper globe above the cathedral. Leonardo later recalled how its metal was joined.
The Renaissance · Leonardo da Vinci, pp. 69–70, what the workshop made · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 70, Verrocchio’s ambitions · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 70, beautiful toys and precise surfaces
When Leonardo’s father took him to Andrea del Verrocchio’s shop, he wasn’t enrolling him in an art school, since he was apprenticing him to a busy Florentine business that made almost anything that could be cast, carved, chased or painted. Pater lists what lay about the place, “reliquaries, pyxes, silver images for the pope’s chapel at Rome, strange fancy-work of the middle age, keeping odd company with fragments of antiquity.” A pyx is the small box that holds the consecrated bread of the Mass, and a reliquary holds a saint’s remains, so the shop’s daily work was making beautiful containers for holy things. Pater adds “drinking-vessels, ambries,” meaning cupboards, and “instruments of music,” all made “fair to look upon.”
Pater’s picture of Verrocchio himself is of a craftsman whose ambition was hidden under a cheerful trade. Beneath “the mere well-paid craftsman, chasing brooches for the copes of Santa Maria Novella, or twisting metal screens for the tombs of the Medici,” he says, lay a desire to expand what Italian art could do. The metal screen is real and still there, in the Old Sacristy of San Lorenzo, where Verrocchio’s tomb for Piero and Giovanni de’ Medici, finished around 1472, sits behind a grille of twisted bronze ropes so convincing that you want to touch it to check it isn’t actual cord. The same workshop worked in bronze as well as other materials, so a boy there learned to treat a statue and a candlestick as related problems of material, proportion and finish.
From that crowded, glittering shop Pater draws a thesis about Leonardo’s whole career. Just as Verrocchio anticipated Leonardo, “so, to the last Leonardo recalls the studio of Verrocchio, in the love of beautiful toys.” Pater’s examples are “the vessel of water for a mirror,” the “lovely needle-work about the implicated hands in the Modesty and Vanity,” the cameos that hang “all round the girdle of Saint Michael” in the Virgin of the Balances, and “the agates in the Saint Anne,” all marked by “a hieratic preciseness and grace, as of a sanctuary swept and garnished.” The habits of a goldsmith’s apprentice, in other words, survive into the finish of a master’s late pictures.
That last phrase deserves a second look, because “swept and garnished” comes from the King James Bible, where an unclean spirit returns to find its old house empty, swept and decorated, and moves back in with seven worse spirits. Pater surely meant only the cleanliness and ornament of a tidy shrine, but it’s a slightly eerie phrase to borrow for Leonardo’s polish, and it fits the strangeness he finds in him elsewhere. The image he wants is of a picture as carefully dressed as an altar on a feast day, every jewel and stitch in place, and that’s a real quality of Leonardo’s work.
The problem lies in the evidence Pater chooses to prove it. A version of Modesty and Vanity is catalogued after Bernardino Luini, a painter who absorbed Leonardo’s manner. The Louvre assigns the Virgin of the Balances to a follower. Such pictures can show how a style spread without establishing which details Leonardo himself painted. His Saint Anne gives Pater’s comparison a firmer example.
There’s better evidence, and it comes from Leonardo himself. Around 1468 Verrocchio’s shop took on one of its most spectacular jobs, the great copper globe for the cathedral lantern, hammered from sheets of copper soldered together, gilded and hoisted into place in 1471, while the teenage Leonardo was in the workshop. Decades later, in a notebook from his last years, Leonardo jotted a reminder to himself to think of the soldering used to join the globe of Santa Maria del Fiore. The old apprentice, working on some new problem, was still reaching back to a technique he’d watched as a boy.
The technical evidence of his painting points the same way. The Leonardo who spent his life testing varnishes, oils and pigments, and who obsessed over the sheen of a curl of hair or a fold of drapery, was working like a metalworker who knows that surface is everything. Pater’s instinct to link the shop’s tiny objects with the paintings’ ceremonial finish is sound, and the link runs through materials and method, through soldering and polishing and the patience to get a small thing exactly right, more than through any particular jewel on any particular saint. You can see it in the tiny highlights on a string of pearls or the glint along a curl in his portraits, painted with the care a goldsmith gives to a setting.
So here’s my verdict on Pater’s workshop thesis, which holds, and it’s one of the more original ideas in the essay, that a painter of cosmic ambitions never stopped being a craftsman trained among pyxes, cups and bronze ropes. Some of his examples now tell us more about the spread of Leonardo’s manner, and he left the best proof unused, Leonardo’s own memory of soldering a copper globe for a cathedral. The workshop survived in him, just as Pater said, and it shows most clearly in the habits of a man who kept thinking like a metalsmith long after he’d left the bench.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article regard Pater’s use of Modesty and Vanity and Virgin of the Balances as problematic?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If some of Pater’s chosen paintings are attributed to Leonardo’s followers, how should that change—but not necessarily destroy—his broader argument about the workshop’s influence?→
- Why might habits of handling materials, polishing surfaces, and perfecting small details provide stronger evidence of apprenticeship than recurring decorative motifs do?→
- How does the article balance Leonardo’s “cosmic ambitions” with his identity as a craftsman, and what does that pairing suggest about the relationship between artistic vision and technical skill?→