Philosophy
What It Means to Undress a Soul
Socrates asks to examine Charmides’ soul, then puts his own claims under the same scrutiny.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates proposes to strip the boy’s soul and look at it before his body. That sounds like the creepiest possible description of philosophy, until you notice who else ends up undressed.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A proposal to look inwardSocrates borrows the wrestling school’s language of undressing and proposes that the men examine Charmides’ soul through conversation.
- An audience and a choiceA crowd gathers around the boy, whose guardian arranged the meeting under a pretext. Socrates offers to leave the question alone if Charmides would rather stop.
- Testing the answersWhen one answer fails, Charmides nudges Critias to defend it. Socrates suspects the idea came from the guardian.
- The examiner is exposedSocrates tells Critias he examines arguments to catch his own errors. He has already let his listener see him lose his composure.
“Then why don’t we strip that very part of him,” Socrates asks, meaning the soul, “and take a look at it before we look at his figure?” In a wrestling-school, stripping and looking were ordinary activities, but once the verb is pointed at a soul, it raises a real question about what Socrates thinks he’s doing. Is philosophical conversation a kind of disclosure, where the person reveals himself, a kind of testing, where someone probes him, a kind of vulnerability, where someone gets exposed, or just another kind of spectatorship, a more refined way of staring at a beautiful boy? It’s worth weighing each one, because the answer depends on who asks the questions and who stays on display.
Start with the uncomfortable reading, since it deserves to be taken seriously. The setting is a crowded gym, the subject is a beautiful teenager, the proposal is to undress him, and the people making the proposal are older men who have just been rating his body. On this reading philosophy is spectatorship with better manners, with the boy on display and the men asking the questions, and the crowd that comes “swirling round us in a ring” as the conversation begins only makes it worse, along with the fact that the boy’s guardian arranged the meeting under a false pretext, since it’s not easy for a kid to walk away from a question in front of that many people.
The opposite reading treats the stripping as disclosure, something the boy does rather than something done to him. A soul can’t be seen, so the only way it shows itself is through what a person says, and Socrates’ plan depends on the boy being willing to talk. On this view conversation lets Charmides reveal himself on his own terms, and his blush when Socrates asks whether he’s temperate is a small disclosure all by itself, since it shows a modesty no description of him had mentioned. The trouble is that disclosure has to be chosen, and a shy boy facing a crowd might not feel he has much choice.
Testing is the reading that sounds most like Socrates. His famous method is to ask someone for an account of something and then check whether the account holds up, and that’s exactly what happens next, when Charmides offers his definitions of temperance and Socrates examines them one by one. In this sense undressing a soul means stripping off the opinions a person has picked up and seeing what’s left underneath, and in Charmides’ case Socrates suspects that one of those opinions came from his guardian. That’s the version of undressing that stings, because nobody enjoys finding out that a line they were proud of isn’t really theirs, and the boy’s sly attempt to push the blame onto Critias shows he felt it.
Then comes the detail that changes the picture, because Socrates sets terms that bind the examiner as much as the examined. When he raises the question of whether the boy is temperate, he says they ought to look into it together, so that Charmides won’t be forced to say what he doesn’t want to, “and I in turn won’t set about my doctoring without looking into things.” He even offers a way out, “if not, let’s leave it,” which turns the examination into something the boy can refuse, and Charmides says he’d like nothing better than to go ahead. That word “doctoring” is a callback to the fake doctor’s visit Critias arranged, and Socrates is quietly turning a pretense into a real medical principle, that you don’t treat a patient you haven’t examined, and you don’t examine him without his say.
Later in the dialogue Socrates makes the point explicit. When Critias accuses him of just trying to win, Socrates says that when he refutes someone he’s doing what he would do to himself, examining what he says “for fear that I might ever, without noticing, think I know something when I don’t,” and that he examines the argument “for my own sake above all.” That’s an unusual thing for a cross-examiner to admit, since most of us go after other people’s mistakes precisely to avoid looking at our own. The man asking the questions is undressing too, and his narration of the afternoon proves it, since he has already confessed to his listener that the boy left him on fire and out of his own possession, which is about as exposed as a narrator can get.
So who remains on display, once you put all of this together? On the spectatorship reading only the boy does, stripped for an audience of older men, but in Socrates’ actual practice both of them are on display, and so is the argument itself, which is the thing really being stripped down to see whether it can stand. The crowd still watches, and that danger never fully goes away, but what it watches is two people being tested rather than one being looked at, which is a very different show.
My verdict is that undressing a soul, as the Charmides imagines it, is testing with vulnerability on both sides, closer to a doctor’s exam in which the doctor admits he might be sick too. It only escapes being a more sophisticated kind of staring because Socrates insists on consent, on doing it together, and on exposing himself along with the boy. The dialogue knows how easily the other version could happen, which is exactly why it builds in an exit, and why the most important words in the proposal may be the ones that come last, “if not, let’s leave it.”
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author regard Socrates’ phrase “if not, let’s leave it” as especially important?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does a conversation count as genuinely voluntary, especially if one participant faces social pressure from an audience or authority figure?→
- How does the author’s medical analogy change the moral relationship between the person asking questions and the person answering them?→
- Can mutual vulnerability fully prevent philosophical inquiry from becoming spectatorship, or does the presence of an audience always preserve that danger?→