Renaissance

What It Means to Shape a Life Like a Statue

Hegel imagines Greek thinkers and artists giving their lives a coherent form. Pater sees something similar in Winckelmann.

Sculpture gives Hegel a way to describe a person’s coherence. The historical lives behind his examples show how much of their outline was also cut by other hands.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Hegel borrows a sculptor’s termsPlastic character means that the shape a person gives to a life can be recognized from several sides.
  • Fortune is something elseThucydides’ exile and the accusations surrounding Pheidias show how much lay outside any individual’s control.
  • Pater finds a guiding motiveWinckelmann’s commitment to ancient art gives a recognizable direction to a life with many changes of circumstance.
  • The form is partly made afterwardThe critic who describes a life as a whole also chooses which changes, accidents and dependences to bring into view.

Pater hands the floor to Hegel for one of the boldest claims in the chapter. In what Hegel calls “those beautiful days of Greece,” everyone who acted, created or thought had a “plastic character,” a sculptural one, and “They are great and free, and have grown up on the soil of their own individuality, creating themselves out of themselves, and moulding themselves to what they were, and willed to be.” He names “Pericles himself, Pheidias, Plato, above all Sophocles, Thucydides also, Xenophon and Socrates,” and calls them “ideal artists of themselves, cast each in one flawless mould.” Then Pater turns the ideal toward his own subject and says Winckelmann possessed this key to the Greek spirit “in his own nature.” The question is what sculpture adds to this picture of self-making, and whether it fits anyone’s actual life.

A useful parallel comes from Pindar’s advice to become what one is through learning. Nietzsche later used a related phrase in the subtitle of his autobiography. Hegel’s version gives that old advice a sculptor’s shape. A statue is a single form that holds together from every side, with no hidden interior and no loose parts, and a person with “plastic character” would be like that, self-consistent and legible all the way through, so that what he does and what he is coincide. That’s what sculpture contributes, the image of a self with one outline, carved from its own material rather than assembled from outside influences.

Now look at the actual men on the list, because their lives were less self-made than Hegel suggests. Plutarch tells of accusations against Pheidias and Pericles’ associates. Thucydides says he spent twenty years in exile after his command at Amphipolis, an experience that let him observe both sides of the war. Xenophon was banished from Athens, and Socrates was executed by the city. Those public pressures matter to the shape each life eventually took.

So the “flawless mould” was often cracked by the city that made these men famous. Hegel puts Sophocles “above all,” and the dramatist’s long public career gives an example in which artistic work and civic service could coexist. For the rest, what looks like self-creation in retrospect was a lifelong negotiation with prosecutors, voters, wars and exile, and their solid outlines are partly the work of later admirers, Hegel included, sculpting them into statues after the fact.

Hegel’s real claim is about character rather than fortune, though, and that’s a stronger position. He isn’t saying these men controlled their circumstances or escaped them. He’s saying each one met his circumstances as a whole person, with a single recognizable cast of mind, so that Thucydides in exile is still unmistakably Thucydides and Socrates facing the hemlock is still Socrates. On that reading the statue isn’t a picture of a lucky life but of a consistent one, and the “perfection of one remaining undiminished by that of the others” describes a society in which strong individuals could coexist, which is the kind of society Hegel wants those figures to represent.

Pater’s move to Winckelmann takes that reading and runs with it. Winckelmann’s nature, he says, was “itself like a relic of classical antiquity, laid open by accident to our alien, modern atmosphere,” and his guiding motive, “like some central root-fibre, it maintained the well-rounded unity of his life through a thousand distractions.” “Interests not his, nor meant for him, never disturbed him,” and he “was ever jealously refining his meaning into a form, express, clear, objective.” That’s a portrait of a man whose life had one outline, drawn by a single passion for the antique.

The portrait fits his work much better than it fits his life. His books and letters really do show a single devotion, and his prose has the clarity Pater praises, but the life itself was shaped by poverty, patrons, a strategic conversion, years of service in other men’s libraries and a violent death in Trieste. Pater’s own metaphor gives this away, since a relic “laid open by accident” owes its shape to chance as much as to will. A few pages later he admits that modern people can’t solve the problem of a unified life “as in Pericles or Pheidias, by the direct exercise of any single talent,” which quietly concedes that Winckelmann’s coherence came at the cost of narrowness.

My verdict is that Hegel’s ideal of the self as sculpture works as a description of character and fails as a description of fortune, both for the Athenians on his list and for Winckelmann. What sculpture adds is the image of a self with one consistent form, and that image is worth keeping as a goal, a life organized around a central devotion so that it reads clearly from every side. But the lives themselves were cut by other hands too, by courts, wars and accidents, and Pater’s best touch is to let his own metaphors admit it, describing Winckelmann as a fragment of antiquity that history happened to uncover rather than a statue that carved itself.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What distinction allows the article to defend Hegel’s sculptural ideal despite the hardships faced by his Greek examples?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.