Greek Antiquity
What Is Memphis Doing Among Apollo’s Oracles?
Memphis joins a chain of oracular places in a hymn that gathers Apollo’s authority from many shores.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsApollo’s opening names lead through Greek and Anatolian sanctuaries to an Egyptian city with its own oracular practices. The article asks what the epithet can tell us about the hymn’s map.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The titles name a geographyThe hymn invokes Apollo at places associated with Delphi, Delos, Grynos, and Didyma among others.
- Memphis has an oracular settingThe note relates the Egyptian city to the oracles of Apis and the practice of seeking a dream at a sanctuary.
- The title has limited external evidenceThe edition finds no independent attestation of the Memphis epithet as an established title of Apollo.
- The transmitted name survives editorial changeSeveral neighboring epithets are editorial restorations, while the manuscripts already give the title of Memphis.
Orphic Hymns, XXXIV.1–10, with the apparatus and the notes on XXXIV.2 and XXXIV.2–9
The hymn to Apollo begins like a roll call of shrines. “Come, blessed one, Paian, slayer of Tityos, Phoibos, Lykoreus, / of Memphis, of splendid honour, hailed with iē, giver of prosperity, / golden-lyred, of the seed, of the plough, Pythian, Titan, / of Grynos, Smintheus, slayer of Python, Delphic, seer.” A few lines later come “of Branchos and of Didyma, Patarian, Loxias, holy, / Delian lord.” Most of these names place the god somewhere specific, and the edition’s note picks out the one that doesn’t seem to belong, “of Memphis,” which it calls “the only Egyptian name anywhere in the collection so far.”
Look at the other places and a pattern appears. Lykoreus points to Lykoreia on Parnassus above Delphi, and Pythian, Delphic and slayer of Python all point to Delphi itself. Smintheus is the Apollo of Chryse in the Troad, whose priest opens the Iliad. Grynos is the Gryneion in Aeolis, where Strabo knew a temple and an ancient oracle. Branchos and Didyma name the great oracle near Miletus run by the clan of the Branchidai, Patara is the Lycian town where, Herodotus says, the priestess was shut in the temple on the nights the god was present, and Loxias is Apollo’s oracular name. The list climaxes in line 9, where the god is “showing forth undefiled utterances and oracles.”
What these names add up to is a map of where you would go to ask Apollo something. Several of the sites lie on the coast of Asia Minor, close to where the hymns were probably used, and they are framed by Delphi and Delos, the most famous of all. One god, many addresses, the way Christians speak of Our Lady of Walsingham, an Anglican shrine, or Our Lady of Lourdes, without supposing there are several Marys. The local titles don’t divide Apollo into separate gods, they gather the places where his voice had been heard, so that a small group praying far from Delphi could call on the god of every oracle at once. For people who might never travel to any of these places, reciting the names was the next best thing to a pilgrimage.
Memphis belongs on that map, and the note argues that it fits the list “rather than breaking it,” because “the Apis bull there gave oracles, and the Serapeum had its incubation,” the practice of sleeping in a sanctuary to receive a dream from the god. Greek writers had long known Egypt as a land of oracles. Herodotus says that divination there belonged not to men but to certain gods, and lists among Egypt’s oracles one of Apollo, and he identifies Apollo with the Egyptian god Horus. Pausanias, describing an oracle of Hermes at Pharai in Greece, remarks that a similar method of divination was practiced at the sanctuary of Apis in Egypt. So when the hymn calls Apollo “of Memphis,” it extends his map to the most famous prophetic center of the oldest land the Greeks knew.
But extending a map isn’t the same as recording a cult. The note adds the crucial qualification, that the Greek title meaning “of Memphis” is not attested anywhere else as a cult title of Apollo. No inscription, coin or ancient writer gives him that name. So the epithet is best taken as the hymn’s own claim, a poetic statement that Apollo’s prophetic reach includes Egypt, perhaps reflecting a world in which Egyptian gods like Isis and Sarapis were worshipped in the cities of Asia Minor, but not evidence that anyone actually worshipped Apollo of Memphis at a particular altar.
The apparatus adds a twist that makes the question more interesting. The note on the opening lines counts “Seven emendations in six of the first nine lines” and concludes that “The epithet-register of this hymn as printed is substantially the editors’.” Patarian is Wiel’s correction for a manuscript word meaning far-worker, and the apparatus records that the manuscripts read “Bacchic” where Abel prints Branchos. So two of the oracle names on the map were supplied by editors, while “of Memphis,” the strangest name in the list, carries no apparatus entry at all. Even Grynos appears in Hermann’s regularized form, though the place itself stands in the manuscripts. The oddest item is the one the manuscripts are surest about, which is a good reason not to explain it away.
What does belonging to a geography of oracles mean for a god addressed in so many forms? It makes Apollo a god whose identity is bound up with places where people have asked him questions, and the hymn gathers those places as a way of gathering his authority. The request that follows in line 10 is “hear me as I pray for the peoples,” and a god of every oracle, from Delphi to Memphis, is a fitting god to hear a prayer offered on behalf of many peoples. The list works like a set of credentials, and Memphis is the one that shows how far the credentials reach.
My verdict is that Memphis appears among Apollo’s names because the hymn’s opening is a geography of oracles, and Memphis, with its oracular Apis bull and its sanctuary of dream incubation, was one of the most famous prophetic centers the Greek world knew. The title extends Apollo’s reach to Egypt as a poetic claim, not as evidence of an established cult, since the note confirms that no other source gives him that name. And because several of the other place names are editors’ restorations while Memphis is transmitted, the one name that looks out of place is the one most firmly part of the hymn the singers actually sang.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the article’s main explanation for including “of Memphis” among Apollo’s titles?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does reading the list of Apollo’s titles as a symbolic pilgrimage change your understanding of what reciting the hymn might accomplish for its worshippers?→
- What distinction does the article draw between extending a god’s poetic or prophetic reach and documenting an actual cult, and why does that distinction matter?→
- If the list functions as Apollo’s set of “credentials,” how does the inclusion of Memphis shape the authority claimed for him and the prayer offered on behalf of many peoples?→