Renaissance

What Happens When the Standard Giorgione Turns Out to Be a Titian?

Crowe and Cavalcaselle used the Pitti Concert as their test for Giorgione’s work. Now attributed to Titian, it can still tell us something about the style they saw.

The changing attribution of the Pitti Concert shows why a painting can be an excellent example of a shared style and a poor test of one artist’s hand.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The old benchmarkCrowe and Cavalcaselle treated the Pitti Concert as a model for deciding which paintings were genuinely by Giorgione.
  • A changed nameThe Uffizi attributes the Concert to the young Titian and recognizes Giorgione’s influence in it.
  • Different evidence for different questionsEarly descriptions and dated inscriptions give scholars points of comparison independent of how accomplished a painting seems.
  • What the picture still tells usThe Concert remains evidence for a style circulating in Venice even though it cannot isolate Giorgione’s own hand.

Pater reports the critics’ method plainly, and almost admiringly. The Concert in the Pitti Palace, he says, with “its sustained evenness of perfection, alike in design, in execution, and in choice of personal type,” became for Crowe and Cavalcaselle, the “new Vasari,” “the standard of Giorgione’s genuine work,” and in it they found “sufficient to explain his influence, and the true seal of mastery.” With that standard in hand they cleared out pictures that didn’t measure up, sending a Louvre Holy Family to a minor Friulian painter “in consideration of certain points where it comes short of this standard.” Then, the connoisseur Giovanni Morelli argued for Titian. The Uffizi now agrees, dating the picture around 1510 and calling it Giorgionesque in spirit.

The case that the standard collapses is easy to make. The method was circular from the start, since Giorgione was defined by the Concert and everything unlike the Concert was declared not Giorgione, so if the Concert is really young Titian, the Giorgione of 1871 was largely a portrait of young Titian in someone else’s name. Pater’s own phrase gives it away, because a seal is the mark that proves a document genuine, and a seal that turns out to belong to another family makes every document stamped with it suspect. It’s like calibrating a bathroom scale with the wrong weight, where every reading after that is off by the same hidden amount. And because the rejected pictures were sent off to other painters, the error spread outward too, quietly shaping the catalogs of lesser men who inherited work they may never have done.

There’s a second problem that has nothing to do with the name. The standard was “sustained evenness of perfection,” which is a test of a painter’s best day, and any painter’s ordinary days fail it. A method that measures every candidate against a masterpiece risks overlooking works made for different purposes, even if the benchmark itself is correctly attributed. Pater seems to have felt this, since right after reporting the verdict on the Holy Family he adds that “such shortcoming however will hardly diminish the spectator’s enjoyment,” which is a polite way of saying the critics were grading on a curve nobody could pass.

The case against collapse is stronger than it first looks. What the critics praised was a set of qualities, an evenness of handling, a tact in choosing faces, a calm and a finish that Pater sums up as “distinction,” and qualities don’t change their nature when a label moves. The Concert still shows what the painters around Giorgione could do in 1510, and the very qualities that made it the touchstone are the ones critics now call Giorgionesque in the young Titian. In that sense the standard survives as a measure of a style, even though it has failed as a test of a single hand.

Morelli’s own story shows how hard it is to escape this trap. He mocked Crowe and Cavalcaselle’s tiny Giorgione and built a bigger one around the Sleeping Venus in Dresden, which he identified with a picture the Venetian connoisseur Marcantonio Michiel had seen in the 1520s. But Michiel’s own note says Titian finished that Venus, painting its landscape and its Cupid, so Morelli’s new touchstone also carried evidence of collaboration. Morelli’s favorite weapon was the small detail, the shape of an ear or a fingernail that he thought a painter repeated without thinking, and he aimed it squarely at the “new Vasari,” but details like that cannot on their own settle where one painter’s work ends and another’s begins. In Venice around 1510, painters finished each other’s work and borrowed each other’s manners, so any single picture chosen as the pure sample was likely to be a little mixed.

A more reliable comparison can begin with several paintings supported by different kinds of evidence. The altarpiece in Castelfranco, which survives in the painter’s hometown, the Three Philosophers and the Tempest that Michiel saw in Venetian houses, and the portrait of a young woman called Laura, with Giorgione’s name and the date 1506 written on its back, give modern scholars a documented core to measure against. The Laura matters most of all, because an early inscription on the reverse names the painter and dates the work. It provides an unusually direct comparison without being a signature by Giorgione. It’s a plural standard, several pictures instead of one, and it rests on what people wrote down at the time instead of on what a later critic found most perfect.

The defenders of the old method deserve a hearing here. Documents need interpreting too, Michiel could be wrong, and the documented core still has to be read with an eye, since nobody can attribute anything from paper alone. The Concert also hasn’t gotten any worse as a painting, and Pater’s verdict that it is “among the most precious things in the world of art” stands no matter whose brush it was, so the error was in what the critics asked the picture to prove, not in what they saw in it.

So my verdict is that the attribution undoes the standard as a test of authorship and leaves it standing as a measure of a style. What really fails is the idea that one perfect picture can define a painter, because it confuses an artist’s peak with his range and assumes that a sample from a busy, collaborative workshop is pure. The Concert can still teach you what the Giorgionesque looks like at its best. It just can’t tell you who Giorgione was, and the critics who asked it to were measuring a whole career with a ruler borrowed from a younger painter working in the same milieu.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, why does reattributing the Concert to Titian undermine Crowe and Cavalcaselle’s method?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.