Renaissance
What Happens When a Lemon Becomes a Patch of Yellow?
Pater loosens a familiar object into color, smell and texture. His revised wording and his Preface suggest an exercise in attention with a disquieting edge.
The Renaissance (1893)A method for looking closely can feel like a claim about what the world is made of. The two editions of the Conclusion show where Pater gives readers room to tell those claims apart.
Orientation
At a Glance
- An everyday thing comes apart under attentionPater asks readers to distinguish the color, smell and texture they usually take in as one object.
- Two readings grow from the same exerciseA painter can use it to see more clearly, while a philosopher can ask whether experience ever reaches past impressions.
- The revisions make room for appearanceIn 1893 reflection “plays” on things and their cohesion “seems” suspended, wording that leaves room for the object to remain.
- Words let us compare what we noticeThe Preface asks critics to distinguish their impressions, an activity that needs words capable of holding a fleeting quality in view.
The Renaissance · 1893 Conclusion, an object loosens into impressions · Note 330, the move from bodies to perception · 1873 Conclusion, the earlier account of reflection · 1873 Conclusion, note 344 on “swarm” and “group” · Preface, knowing one’s own impression distinctly · John Ruskin, The Elements of Drawing, “the innocence of the eye” · David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature I.4.6, personal identity · John Stuart Mill, Examination of Sir William Hamilton’s Philosophy, Chapter XI
At first, Pater says, “experience seems to bury us under a flood of external objects, pressing upon us with a sharp and importunate reality, calling us out of ourselves in a thousand forms of action.” Then comes the turn, and it arrives with a magician’s flourish. “But when reflexion begins to play upon those objects they are dissipated under its influence; the cohesive force seems suspended like some trick of magic; each object is loosed into a group of impressions,” which he lists as color, odor and texture “in the mind of the observer.” Take a lemon on the kitchen counter and look at it long enough, and it stops being a lemon you might slice and becomes a yellow, a sharp smell, a waxy pebbled surface, and if you keep going, Pater says, “the whole scope of observation is dwarfed into the narrow chamber of the individual mind.”
There are two ways to hear that, and they lead to very different essays. On the first, Pater is describing a method, the sort of exercise a drawing teacher gives, and the teacher had already written it down, since Ruskin in The Elements of Drawing (1857) asked students to recover “the innocence of the eye,” seeing flat stains of color merely as stains, without registering what they stand for, so that a page can be seen for a moment as a patch of white. On the second, Pater is making a claim about reality, and the philosophers had written that down too, since Hume called the self “a bundle or collection of different perceptions” and Mill, in 1865, defined matter as the “Permanent Possibility of Sensation.” Pater’s word “impressions” is Hume’s technical term, which makes the second reading tempting.
The case for the stronger claim is real, and it deserves to be stated at full strength. The “cohesive force” sounds like something that was never quite there to begin with, since it can be “suspended like some trick of magic,” and the next sentences push hard, with the “thick wall of personality through which no real voice has ever pierced” and a world outside “which we can only conjecture to be without.” That’s the language of a skeptic who thinks we never touch anything but our own sensations, and the debates over Mill in the 1860s give that reading a contemporary setting. If Pater meant only a drawing exercise, he picked some alarming words to describe it.
But look at the grammar and the revisions, which both point toward method. The whole sequence is conditional, a series of things we do, “when reflexion begins to play” and “if we continue to dwell in thought,” so it describes an exercise you start and could stop. Two changes in the final text make the metaphysical claim less categorical. In 1873 reflection “begins to act upon those objects” and “the cohesive force is suspended like a trick of magic,” while in 1893 reflection “begins to play” and the force only “seems suspended,” and the note on the earlier text points to a later sentence where the 1873 “swarm of impressions” became a calmer “group.” Both texts use “group” when the object first comes apart. The word “seems” carries most of the weight, since it moves the dissolution from a fact about objects to a fact about how they appear under a certain kind of attention.
The clearest test is Pater’s remark about language, because the dissolved world is “not of objects in the solidity with which language invests them, but of impressions.” If that were a claim about reality, language would be lying to us every time we used a noun, and Pater’s own sentence would be part of the lie, since color, odor and texture are nouns too, and “impression” itself is a noun that turns a flicker into a thing you can hold. He can’t describe the dissolution without the solid currency of words. To “invest” someone is to dress them in robes of office, so language dresses objects in solidity, and a robe is a garment someone puts on, not a forgery.
On the method reading, that’s exactly what language is for. Nouns pack impressions into objects so you can act, reach for the lemon, slice it, and reflection unpacks them so you can look, and a person who can do both at will is the critic Pater wants. His Preface says that “the first step towards seeing one’s object as it really is, is to know one’s own impression as it really is, to discriminate it, to realise it distinctly,” and you can’t discriminate an impression without the words that hold it still long enough to compare it with another. The Conclusion’s own famous list, “strange dyes, strange colours, and curious odours,” is language investing impressions with just enough solidity to be noticed.
I’ll admit that the method comes with a mood, and the mood is not a drawing lesson. Anyone who has stared at a word until it stops looking like a word knows that a perfectly innocent exercise can produce a real metaphysical shiver, and Pater lets that shiver run, all the way to the “solitary prisoner” and his “dream of a world.” That’s the flirtation with the stronger claim, and it helps explain the passage’s unsettling effect. Pater’s own note says he omitted the Conclusion in 1877 out of concern that some younger readers might be misled.
What’s left when reflection loosens an object is a set of qualities that were always there and are now being noticed one by one, the yellow apart from the lemon, the smell apart from the fruit. Pater describes a method and lets the metaphysics hang in the air as an atmosphere, and his revisions toward “seems” and “play” show which way he finally leaned. The language test gives the method reading more weight, because the strong reading would saw off the branch the whole essay sits on, since a world that language only falsifies couldn’t be discriminated in words at all, and discriminating in words is the one thing Pater never stops asking us to do.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article treat Pater’s revision from “is suspended” to “seems suspended” as especially significant?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If reflection is an exercise that one can start and stop, what determines when dissolving an object into impressions improves perception rather than merely disrupting ordinary understanding?→
- Does Pater’s reliance on language genuinely weaken the metaphysical reading, or could language remain useful even if it never gives direct access to reality? Why?→
- How do Pater’s unsettling images of isolation affect the article’s claim that metaphysics is mainly an atmosphere surrounding a method?→