Renaissance
What Gets Through Pater’s Wall of Personality?
The Conclusion imagines every mind sealed inside its impressions, then asks readers to study a friend’s face. Pater’s later novel gives that attention a practical test.
The Renaissance (1893)The wall makes direct access to another person difficult to imagine. Pater still has room for shared art, careful attention to friends and, in Marius, action on someone else’s behalf.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The wall describes a point of viewEvery sound or face reaches a person through their own perception, even when others encounter the same event.
- A friend’s face tests the limits of the imagePater asks readers to study the people around them closely, even after imagining the mind as a solitary prisoner.
- Attention can turn a person into a spectaclePlacing a friend beside a work of art raises the question of whether the friend is being understood or simply observed.
- Marius acts on the other person’s behalfPater’s later novel gives a friend’s safety greater weight than its main character’s own comfort.
The Renaissance · 1893 Conclusion, the wall of personality · Note 331, the boundary of a point of view · 1893 Conclusion, a friend’s face and the gifts of others · 1893 Conclusion, art comes to the reader · Note 324, Pater directs readers to Marius · 1873 Conclusion, the original wall passage · Matthew Arnold, To Marguerite: Continued · Walter Pater, Marius the Epicurean, Chapter XXVIII
The darkest sentence in the Conclusion sounds like a life sentence. Experience, Pater says, “is ringed round for each one of us by that thick wall of personality through which no real voice has ever pierced on its way to us, or from us to that which we can only conjecture to be without,” so that every impression belongs to “the individual in his isolation, each mind keeping as a solitary prisoner its own dream of a world.” Picture a subway car at rush hour where everyone is wearing noise-canceling headphones, each person sealed inside a private soundtrack, close enough to touch and not hearing a thing. The note glosses “personality” as the boundary of an individual point of view, and the question is what kind of isolation that boundary really creates.
Matthew Arnold had already pictured the problem in 1852, in the poem now usually called “To Marguerite: Continued,” where human beings are islands, “in the sea of life enisled,” and the famous line runs “We mortal millions live alone.” But Arnold’s islands at least feel the sea around them and ache with the memory that they were once a single continent, while Pater’s version is colder, a prisoner and a dream with no longing in it at all. Still, the key word in his sentence is “real.” One way to read Pater’s “real” is that voices reach us only as impressions of our own, the way you can hear a friend talking through an apartment wall, muffled and partial, and still know perfectly well that it’s them.
Then, barely a page later, other people come flooding back into the essay. Among the things worth grasping “While all melts under our feet,” Pater lists “the face of one’s friend,” and he goes further, warning that “Not to discriminate every moment some passionate attitude in those about us, and in the very brilliancy of their gifts some tragic dividing of forces on their ways, is, on this short day of frost and sun, to sleep before evening.” Failing to notice the people around you counts as sleeping through your one short day, so whatever the wall does, it doesn’t excuse you from looking at the people on the other side of it.
The worry is the company the friend keeps in that list. “The face of one’s friend” comes right after “work of the artist’s hands,” as one more exquisite thing to catch before it melts, and what we’re asked to notice is their “passionate attitude” and their “tragic dividing of forces,” as if friends were a gallery of fates to be appreciated. Nothing in the sentence says the friend is noticing you back, or that anything passes between the two of you, so the relation runs in one direction, from the watcher to the watched. That’s the collector’s eye, and it’s the real risk in Pater’s ethic, more dangerous than the wall itself.
There’s a better reading available, though, and it starts with that phrase about forces dividing. To see in a friend’s gifts the forces already pulling apart “on their ways” is to see them as mortal, and that’s where tenderness starts, since you love a face more when you know it’s passing. And if the wall means that you never get raw access to another mind, then friendship becomes a matter of interpretation, of reading a face with the full care Pater wants you to give a painting. On that view the friend is the person you discriminate most finely, which is a pretty good description of what it means to know someone well.
Art crosses the wall in Pater’s last sentence, which ends the essay by saying that “art comes to you proposing frankly to give nothing but the highest quality to your moments as they pass, and simply for those moments’ sake.” Art comes to you, and so does Pater’s own prose, which keeps addressing its reader directly, as in “Only be sure it is passion.” An essay that announces that no real voice ever pierces the wall, and then spends three pages talking straight to you, is behaving as if voices do get through, and I think its behavior is more trustworthy than its theory. Two people at the same concert each have their own impressions, and they still share the music and can argue about it afterward on the way home.
Pater gave his own fuller answer in 1885, and his note to the Conclusion points readers there for “the thoughts suggested by it.” At the end of Marius the Epicurean, Marius and his friend Cornelius are arrested together, and Marius arranges Cornelius’s release, in part by bribing the guards, and takes the danger on himself. He then dies of fever among country people who tend him and treat his death as a martyr’s. The young man who began as a connoisseur of impressions ends by acting for a friend across every wall the Conclusion describes, which suggests that Pater knew where the watcher’s ethic needed to lead. He wrote the novel more than a decade after the Conclusion, and in places it reads like a long, patient reply to his own darkest paragraph.
The isolation in the Conclusion is a claim about knowledge, about never getting another mind straight, and its language of prisons and dreams overstates even that. Friendship survives Pater’s analysis as the most demanding form of the attention he preaches, a close reading of someone you can’t fully reach. The real danger is the collector’s coldness, the friend as one more exquisite object, and the essay’s direct address to its reader and the friendship at the end of Marius both suggest a way through that danger.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What does the article ultimately claim Pater’s “wall of personality” primarily limits?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If we can know another person only through our own impressions, what would distinguish careful interpretation from merely projecting our assumptions onto them?→
- Does Pater’s intense attention to a friend necessarily objectify that friend, or can such attention become a form of tenderness? What would make the difference?→
- Why might the article regard Pater’s direct address to his reader as more trustworthy than his stated theory of isolation?→