Renaissance

What Freedom Looks Like Inside the Net

Pater asks what freedom art can show in a world governed by laws we cannot change. Goethe and Victor Hugo make the answer a matter of what their characters do.

Pater sets the freedom of defying a god against the freedom of meeting unavoidable conditions. Two novels test how much a choice can change within those conditions.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Necessity runs through modern lifePater says that modern readers understand necessity as a network of laws working through them as well as around them.
  • Art can show how a person meets a limitHis first answer is that a person has some freedom in the attitude they take toward circumstances they cannot change.
  • Goethe tests the chemical metaphorCharlotte and the Captain feel the attraction that the chemical analogy anticipates and still have decisions to make.
  • Hugo lets a decision change the outcomeValjean cannot repeal the law, but he can identify himself in court and spare another man from his sentence.

Pater ends the essay by asking what art is for now, and his answer starts with a broad definition, since poetry will mean “all literary production which attains the power of giving pleasure by its form, as distinct from its matter,” and its job will be “so to rearrange the details of modern life, so to reflect it, that it may satisfy the spirit.” Then he asks the real question, “And what does the spirit need in the face of modern life?” and answers it in four words, “The sense of freedom.” If you’ve ever had the creepy feeling that your phone knows what you’ll buy before you do, you already understand why that answer is harder to deliver than it sounds, because the modern difficulty is less a tyrant you could fight than a system you can’t see the edges of.

He’s blunt about what we’ve lost, and he puts it in a single heavy sentence. “That naïve, rough sense of freedom, which supposes man’s will to be limited, if at all, only by a will stronger than his, he can never have again,” and any attempt to show it in art would have “so little verisimilitude that it would be flat and uninteresting.” Think of Prometheus defying Zeus, a will against a bigger will, where necessity was “a sort of mythological personage without us, with whom we can do warfare.” For the modern mind necessity is instead “a magic web woven through and through us, like that magnetic system of which modern science speaks, penetrating us with a network, subtler than our subtlest nerves, yet bearing in it the central forces of the world,” which evokes a world of heredity, physiology and social law. The net runs through you as a god standing across from you could never do.

So Pater lowers the target and asks whether art can give the spirit “at least an equivalent for the sense of freedom.” His answer is that “Natural laws we shall never modify, embarrass us as they may; but there is still something in the nobler or less noble attitude with which we watch their fatal combinations.” In the romances of Goethe and Victor Hugo, he says, the net “becomes the tragic situation, in which certain groups of noble men and women work out for themselves a supreme dénouement,” using the French word for the untying of a plot. He ends with a question that’s half consolation and half dare, “Who, if he saw through all, would fret against the chain of circumstance which endows one at the end with those great experiences?”

The case for attitude as real freedom deserves a fair hearing first, because it’s older and tougher than it looks. Epictetus opened his handbook by sorting the world into what is up to us and what isn’t, and he put our judgments on the first list and nearly everything else on the second. Anyone who has watched a friend meet a terrible diagnosis knows that the way someone carries a fate is no small thing, since it shapes what they notice, how they treat the people around them, and what the whole ordeal ends up meaning. On this view the noble attitude is the one square inch nobody can take from you, and calling it an equivalent of freedom undersells it.

The worry is in Pater’s verb, though, because the noble people “watch” their fatal combinations, which turns them into spectators of their own lives, critics in good seats at a tragedy they happen to be starring in. Goethe’s Elective Affinities (1809) is the obvious test, since its title comes from chemistry and its characters literally talk through a double displacement reaction in which each pair exchanges partners, before living it out, with Eduard drawn to Ottilie and his wife Charlotte to the Captain. That’s Pater’s magic web in the moral order, laid out like a lab sheet. But the freedom the novel actually shows is Charlotte’s and the Captain’s renunciation, two people feeling the pull and choosing to separate. Their renunciation takes action.

Hugo puts even more pressure on the formula, and he built his books around the very web Pater describes. In the preface to Toilers of the Sea (1866) he says a triple necessity, the Greek anankē, weighs on us, the fatality of dogmas, of human laws and of nature, and he assigns one to each of his novels, Notre-Dame de Paris, Les Misérables and Toilers of the Sea, adding that the human heart is the supreme necessity of all. Yet the great scene of Les Misérables is Jean Valjean learning that another man is about to be convicted under his name, spending a night of agony over it, and then traveling to the courtroom in Arras to give himself up. Valjean doesn’t watch the combination, he walks into the courtroom and changes it.

That’s where I think Pater’s two options, the unimpeded will and the noble attitude, leave out the thing his own examples show best. Valjean can’t modify natural law or repeal the penal code, and nobody in Goethe’s novel can switch off attraction, but inside the net they choose which thread to pull, and that choice reshapes the ending even though it doesn’t break any rule. Pater’s own sentence half knows this, since the noble groups “work out for themselves” their resolution, and working out is an activity, something a person does with the materials at hand. The novels give freedom as constrained action, which is more than an attitude and less than a revolt.

So art can give a real freedom inside a web of law, but it’s the freedom of choosing within limits, and Pater’s word “attitude” undersells it. The attitude matters, and Epictetus is right that it can’t be taken away, but the novels Pater praises earn their blitheness by showing people who act, renounce, confess and pay, and his closing question about not fretting at the chain only works for someone who “saw through all,” which nobody in those books does. They don’t see through all, and that’s precisely why their choices count, because a person who could see the whole web would have nothing left to decide.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What does the author think Pater’s contrast between unimpeded will and noble attitude fails to recognize?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.