Philosophy

What Experts Say and What Experts Do

A doctor can speak truly about a condition and still fail to treat it well.

Socrates asks an examiner to look at what a doctor says and what the doctor does. The two tests reveal different things, even when both require medical judgment.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Two parts of the testSocrates asks whether the doctor’s statements are true and whether the doctor’s actions are right.
  • The patient in front of youAristotle says experience can outperform theory on its own because medicine treats a particular patient.
  • What an explanation can showIn the Gorgias, Socrates distinguishes a genuine craft from a routine by asking whether it can explain the causes of what it does.
  • Why recovery leaves a questionA patient may recover after a poor decision, so the result alone cannot settle whether the doctor chose well.

Charmides 170d–e, 171b–c · Gorgias 464d–465a · Aristotle, Metaphysics A.1, 981a12–b10

The test Socrates proposes has two parts, and they’re easy to read as one. A person who examines a doctor correctly, he says, will look at “whether the things said are said truly and whether the things done are done rightly.” The doctor’s words and deeds are both evidence. It’s worth asking what each one can show and whether either is easier for a person without medical training to judge.

Aristotle gives us a reason to distinguish them. In the Metaphysics, he says that experience can do better in practice than theory on its own. A doctor treats this patient, Callias or Socrates, and the person who knows the general rule may miss something about the case in front of them. You can imagine a trainee who can describe a procedure accurately and still needs a great deal of practice to carry it out.

The reverse is possible too. A practitioner might learn by experience what has helped patients with a certain complaint without knowing why it helps. Aristotle distinguishes knowing that something works from knowing the cause. In the Gorgias, Socrates says cookery masquerades as medicine and calls it a routine because it aims at pleasure and can’t account for what it does. A true claim about what happened is worth something on its own. An explanation that can say why it happened gives us something more to test.

That gives the two parts of the examination different jobs. Watching someone work can show where an accurate description has run ahead of their practical ability. Asking them questions can show how far they understand the choices they’re making. A good explanation goes beyond saying the right words, just as carrying out a procedure well goes beyond having heard how it’s done. Socrates’s test gives an examiner a reason to pay attention to both.

The action test looks more open to outsiders at first. Anyone can see that a patient gets better. But Socrates asks whether the doctor acted “rightly.” A treatment can be well chosen and fail, or poorly chosen and be followed by recovery. Outcomes matter as evidence. One outcome, on its own, leaves open what brought it about and whether there was a better decision to make at the time.

The speech test gives a fellow doctor something else to work with. She can ask why a colleague took a symptom to be significant, what would change their judgment, or why they chose one treatment over another. The passage in the Charmides asks whether what the doctor says is true. The demand for an account in the Gorgias suggests how far such questioning can go when an examiner wants to understand what stands behind a correct answer.

Both tests run into the same difficulty for Critias. His kind of temperance is supposed to know knowledge and the lack of it without knowing particular subjects. To check a doctor’s words, though, somebody has to know whether the claims are true about health and disease. To check the doctor’s acts, somebody has to know what would count as acting rightly in the case at hand. An outsider can observe both, and still have to rely on medical knowledge to judge what they observed.

My verdict is that Socrates’s two tests belong together because it’s possible to do well on one and still have something to learn from the other. Accurate words give us a way to ask what the doctor understands. An examination of the treatment gives us a way to see how that understanding holds up in a particular case. The fact of a recovery may be what brings us to the door. The examination begins when we ask what the doctor said, what the doctor did, and what we can learn from either about the recovery.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article argue that Socrates’s tests of a doctor’s speech and action should remain distinct?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.