Renaissance

What Does a Life Gain by Narrowing?

Pater praises Winckelmann for devoting himself to one purpose. The reading notebooks show how widely he looked for the means to pursue it.

Winckelmann put the study of beauty first, while the work he did for Bünau and the notes he kept show how much his chosen aim drew from other fields.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The schoolmaster’s hoursOne visitor recalled that Winckelmann took only four hours to sleep between his late and early reading.
  • Pater sees a gain in focusPutting the knowledge of beauty first gives Winckelmann a purpose through several changes of work.
  • The library still called for rangeResearch for Bünau’s imperial history used skills that a narrow interest in sculpture could never have supplied.
  • The notebooks separate aim from appetiteThe surviving excerpts show Winckelmann drawing on science, medicine and travel alongside classical literature.

The scene is the most wearisome period of Winckelmann’s life. From 1743 to 1748 he was deputy headmaster of a small school at Seehausen in the Altmark, good with children but depressed by the work, and still, he wrote, he had “a longing desire to attain to the knowledge of beauty,” sehnlich wünschte zur Kenntniss des Schönen zu gelangen. “He had to shorten his nights, sleeping only four hours, to gain time for reading,” and Pater draws the lesson that “Winckelmann made a step forward in culture” because “He multiplied his intellectual force by detaching from it all flaccid interests,” renouncing “mathematics and law, in which his reading had been considerable, all but the literature of the arts.”

Pater returns to the theme when he compares Winckelmann with Goethe. “Doubtless Winckelmann’s perfection is a narrow perfection,” he admits, and “his feverish nursing of the one motive of his life is a contrast to Goethe’s various energy.” But what impressed Goethe was “the integrity, the truth to its type, of the given force,” and the secondary talents “which in most men are the waste part of nature, and drain away their vitality, he plucked out and cast from him.” A little later Pater generalizes, saying that “often the higher life is only possible at all, on condition of the selection of that in which one’s motive is native and strong; and this selection involves the renunciation of a crown reserved for others.”

The case for narrowing deserves its full weight, because it describes something true about how abilities grow. Attention is finite, and every hour spent on a secondary interest is an hour taken from the main one, so a person who cuts away the merely pleasant pursuits really does concentrate force, the way a lens concentrates light. Athletes, musicians and scientists all know this, because sustained practice can deepen a particular skill. Winckelmann’s achievement, a new way of seeing ancient art, plausibly needed exactly that kind of single-minded preparation. Pater’s own Conclusion would later urge readers to burn with a “hard, gem-like flame,” and Winckelmann is that ideal in biographical form, a life that burns brighter for having fewer things to burn.

The costs, though, were real, and Pater’s own words admit them. The winter schedule recalled by a visitor, with only four hours set aside for sleep, is a punishing one, and Pater later notes that Winckelmann’s “delicate constitution permitted him the use only of bread and wine.” The word “feverish” isn’t decoration, since the narrowed life ran hot and wore the body down, and Pater notes that “his hair is turning grey” before he has even reached the south, so the narrowing consumed most of his youth before it bought him his first freedom. There were institutional costs too, because a poor man devoted to one unprofitable passion has to find patrons, and the conversion that helped make Roman patronage accessible was an act Pater weighs against “absolute sincerity.”

The relinquished studies complicate the picture more than Pater lets on. When Winckelmann applied to Count Bünau in 1748, his new job gave him reason to keep using history and related disciplines. At Bünau’s library at Nöthnitz, he researched and excerpted sources for the count’s history of the German Empire. The abandoned studies paid his way to Dresden and to the antiquities that changed his life. The renounced interests turned out to be his ticket out of the schoolroom. Bünau’s library held some forty thousand volumes, one of the largest private collections in Germany, and a man who had really narrowed his reading would have been useless in it.

His lifelong reading habits tell the same story, in even greater detail. Winckelmann kept excerpt notebooks all his life, some seven thousand five hundred pages of copied passages, and scholars who have studied them find natural science, medicine, history, travel writing and English and French literature alongside the Greek. His History of Ancient Art explains the rise of Greek art partly by climate and partly by political freedom, which is the argument of a man who had read widely in history and political thought. Whatever he plucked out and cast from him, it wasn’t curiosity.

So the honest version of Pater’s ideal distinguishes two kinds of narrowing. Winckelmann narrowed his aim, putting the knowledge of beauty ahead of the career his schooling seemed to prepare him for. He left school teaching when library work gave him a better chance of pursuing that aim. He didn’t narrow his intake, and the wide reading fed the narrow purpose, the way a river gathers water from a whole landscape before it cuts one deep channel. A life that narrows both aim and intake usually ends in a specialist’s rut, which is the very “bloodless routine” that Pater fears.

My verdict is that a life gains a great deal by narrowing its aim, concentration, integrity and the “truth to its type” that Goethe admired, but that it gains most when the narrowing stops at the aim and leaves the mind’s appetite alone. Winckelmann’s case proves Pater’s point about selective devotion and quietly corrects it, since the relinquished studies kept serving him, the body paid a real price, and the institutions extracted their own fee. The ideal survives the complications, but in a humbler form, as a single fire fed by every kind of fuel rather than a flame that burns only what it was born to burn.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What distinction is central to the article’s revised version of Pater’s ideal?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.