Renaissance
What Did the Florentine Crowd Actually Come to See?
Vasari says Florence turned out for a Leonardo drawing of Saint Anne. The surviving drawing and a letter from 1501 point to different versions of the scene.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater reads the crowd’s excitement as a return of an older kind of wonder. The history of the drawing and of the Madonna he compares it with invites another reading of what might have drawn people to Leonardo.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A drawing draws a crowdVasari tells how Florentines spent two days coming to see Leonardo’s Saint Anne cartoon, a large study for a painting.
- A disputed identificationPater identifies the cartoon with the London drawing, which the National Gallery now dates to about 1506–08.
- A lamb in a letterPietro da Novellara’s letter of 1501 describes a composition with a lamb where the London drawing has the infant John the Baptist.
- An earlier story of acclaimPater compares the crowd to one said to have greeted a Cimabue. The commission for the Madonna in that story names Duccio.
The Renaissance · Leonardo da Vinci, pp. 81–82, the crowd and the Saint Anne cartoon · Leonardo da Vinci, note 196 · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 80, Saint Anne as a pretext for invention
Around 1501, in the scene Giorgio Vasari describes, Florence lined up to look at a drawing. Leonardo had come home after nearly twenty years in Milan, the Servite friars of the Santissima Annunziata, the church of the Most Holy Annunciation, had taken him in while he prepared their high altarpiece, and when his full-size cartoon of the Virgin, Saint Anne and the Christ Child was finished and set up in a room, men and women, young and old, kept coming for two days as if to a solemn festival. It reads like a Renaissance premiere with a line around the block. Pater loved the scene, and he turned it into evidence for a kind of looking he thought the modern world had lost.
In Pater’s version the cartoon “revived for a moment a sort of appreciation more common in an earlier time, when good pictures had still seemed miraculous.” For two days, he writes, “a crowd of people of all qualities passed in naïve excitement through the chamber where it hung, and gave Leonardo a taste of the ‘triumph’ of Cimabue.” The word in quotation marks points to Vasari’s story of Cimabue, whose great Madonna for Santa Maria Novella was supposedly carried from his house to the church with trumpets and rejoicing, so that his neighborhood came to be called Borgo Allegri, the joyful quarter. Pater’s argument is that the crowd at Leonardo’s cartoon was a late echo of that medieval wonder, an older kind of public feeling surfacing for a moment in a sophisticated city. He also tells us the cartoon is “now in London.”
The London part is where the trouble starts, because the drawing Pater meant, known as the Burlington House Cartoon in the National Gallery, shows Saint Anne, the Virgin, the Christ Child and the infant John the Baptist, and the gallery now dates it to about 1506 to 1508 rather than the traditional 1499 to 1500, noting that it’s neither pricked nor incised, which suggests a presentation drawing, made to be looked at rather than transferred to a panel. As the edition’s note says, the gallery won’t confirm that it’s the sheet in Vasari’s story. Then there’s an April 1501 letter preserved at Mantua, in which the Carmelite friar Pietro da Novellara describes a different composition. The Christ Child slips from his mother’s arms to grab a lamb while Saint Anne seems to hold her daughter back. No known drawing by Leonardo matches the description exactly, though a related design appears in the Louvre’s painting of Saint Anne.
Vasari muddies things further, when he says the drawing went to France and describes a composition containing both the little Saint John and a lamb. So the object at the center of Pater’s crowd could be the lost cartoon Novellara saw, the London drawing at an earlier date than the gallery now accepts, or a drawing that Vasari described imprecisely. And the comparison doesn’t help, because the huge panel associated with Cimabue’s procession, now called the Rucellai Madonna, was commissioned from Duccio of Siena by a confraternity at Santa Maria Novella in 1285. Each story needs to be read with a question about the identity of the object.
The other side has a strong case at this point, and it deserves a full hearing. If we can’t say what the crowd looked at, and if Vasari’s two crowd scenes resemble each other so closely, maybe the crowd is a literary device, the biographer’s applause track, laid under Leonardo’s homecoming the way Vasari laid it under Cimabue’s Madonna, to show that Florence knew greatness when it saw it. On that reading there’s nothing left for Pater’s argument to stand on, because a collective wonder that comes from a writer’s habits tells us about the writer, and the whole scene dissolves into Vasari’s craft.
I don’t think it dissolves, because the occasion is easy to believe even if the details aren’t. Leonardo’s movements drew close attention. Isabella d’Este was keen enough to know what he was making that she sought news through Novellara. Vasari says that the cartoon amazed the city’s craftsmen before he gets to the crowd at all. The festival may be Vasari’s flourish, but people coming to see Leonardo’s new idea is the least surprising event in his whole biography.
What would they have seen, whichever sheet it was? A Saint Anne with the Virgin and Child was an old Florentine subject, often built like a stack, with Anne behind Mary and the child in front, as in Masaccio and Masolino’s Sant’Anna Metterza of about 1424–25. Leonardo took that pyramid of generations and made it move. In London, Anne looks towards Mary as Mary follows the child. In the Louvre painting, Mary leans down after him as he turns to the lamb. That’s a new solution to an old design problem rather than a miracle in the medieval sense, and the people who’d grasp it best were the painters, sculptors and goldsmiths of a city that thought about drawing for a living.
If people did come in the numbers Vasari says, one reason may have been the chance to see what Leonardo could do with a traditional Florentine subject. That possibility holds for either composition. His argument about collective wonder survives, but it needs turning around. That wonder wasn’t a relic of an age when good pictures seemed miraculous, since it looks much more like the first stirring of a modern one, in which a public gathers around a new work by a celebrated artist because it’s new and because it’s his. Pater’s own best idea about Leonardo, that a subject like “the Virgin on the knees of Saint Anne” was “often merely the pretext” for his inventions, explains the crowd better than his nostalgia does, and the “naïve excitement” is the one phrase in the passage I’d strike.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author think the uncertainty about which cartoon the crowd saw does not destroy the case that people gathered to see it?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the gathering probably occurred but Vasari embellished it as a festival, which parts of the story can still serve as historical evidence, and why?→
- How should uncertainty about the cartoon’s identity change our interpretation of the crowd without forcing us to dismiss the scene altogether?→
- What assumptions about artistic audiences separate Pater’s idea of “naïve excitement” from the author’s account of a public responding to invention and celebrity?→