Renaissance
What Chemistry Can Say About a Summer Swim
Pater begins with the shock of cold water, then follows the physical processes that make the sensation possible. The memory of the swim keeps the chemistry grounded.
The Renaissance (1893)The first example in Pater’s Conclusion is a pleasure readers can supply from memory. The later revisions make that remembered plunge an image for how consciousness moves.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The reader supplies the sensationThe remembered shock of a plunge gives Pater a concrete experience to analyze.
- The ingredients go beyond the swimmerPater points out that the substances and forces at work in the body are active outside it as well.
- One revision changes the feel of a sentenceThe change from “by” to “under” suggests a brain continually exposed to light and sound.
- Water connects the essay’s two halvesThe plunge becomes a way to picture the flood of objects and the quicker movement of thought.
The Renaissance · 1893 Conclusion, the plunge and the elements · Note 327, bodily sensation and moving water · 1893 Conclusion, water returns in the account of thought · 1873 Conclusion, physical life and the earlier wording · T. H. Huxley, On the Physical Basis of Life · Justus von Liebig, Chemical Letters, quoting Moleschott’s phosphorus maxim
You know the moment even if you’ve never read a word of Pater, because it’s August, the air is thick, and you jump off the dock into the lake, and the cold hits so hard that your whole body flinches and you come up gasping and laughing at the same time. That’s where the argument begins, since Pater tells you to fix on physical life “in one of its more exquisite intervals, the moment, for instance, of delicious recoil from the flood of water in summer heat.” Instead of describing the swim for you, he asks you to remember your own, so before any theory arrives the reader has already supplied the evidence out of a private stock of summers.
Then the scene changes faster than the water temperature. “What is the whole physical life in that moment but a combination of natural elements to which science gives their names?” Pater lists them, “phosphorus and lime and delicate fibres,” and points out that they’re “present not in the human body alone,” since we find them in “places most remote from it.” The gasp becomes traffic, “the passage of the blood, the waste and repairing of the lenses of the eye, the modification of the tissues of the brain under every ray of light and sound,” and all of it is made of “processes which science reduces to simpler and more elementary forces.” In three sentences your best afternoon of the summer has turned into a lab report.
Pater’s vocabulary belongs to the debates about matter and life that ran through the 1850s and 1860s. The Dutch physiologist Jacob Moleschott had written in 1850 that without phosphorus there is no thought, “Ohne Phosphor kein Gedanke.” In his 1868 lecture “On the Physical Basis of Life,” Thomas Huxley proposed that different forms of life shared a material basis in protoplasm. Pater’s phosphorus and lime bring that contemporary language into an essay about what it feels like to be alive.
So why would Pater open with pleasure, of all things, when he could have picked something duller? The answer is that it’s the hardest case he could choose. If you wanted to make the reduction easy, you’d start with digestion or a stubbed toe, something already half mechanical, but the plunge is the moment when you feel most yourself and most alive, the moment that seems to be about you and nothing else. It’s like a magician who calls the most skeptical person in the room up on stage, since if the trick works on the hardest volunteer it works on everyone. If science can describe even that gasp as elements in motion, then nothing in physical life gets a pass.
What keeps the passage from being a cold debunking is the order of operations. The memory comes first and the chemistry second, so the remembered gasp is the ground the analysis has to stand on, and Pater never asks you to stop finding it “delicious.” He redescribes the pleasure without canceling it, and the redescription keeps reaching outward, because the same phosphorus and lime that make your shiver happen also lie in rocks and soil and places nowhere near you. The swim stays yours, and it also turns out to be connected to everything, which makes it bigger rather than smaller. It’s like a slow-motion replay of a great catch, where breaking down every muscle and every frame doesn’t make the play less amazing, and if anything you watch it again with more respect.
The edition’s two texts show how carefully Pater handled this paragraph. In 1873 the eye’s lenses were “wasting and repairing,” and the brain’s tissues were modified “by every ray of light and sound,” while in 1893 the phrasing becomes “the waste and repairing” of the lenses and modification “under every ray of light and sound.” The change from “by” to “under” is tiny, but it makes the brain sound like something lying in the light, exposed and receptive, rather than something being struck, and that fits a passage whose whole point is that you’re immersed in forces rather than hit by them. It’s the swimmer’s position applied to the nervous system.
The note on this passage puts its double life well, observing that the experience of the water “first supplies an example for scientific analysis and then furnishes a metaphor for the movement of consciousness.” The cold flood comes back a paragraph later as “a flood of external objects” pressing in on the mind, and as the shore and the midstream of thought, so the swim is test case and template at once. The chemistry doesn’t win the argument so much as it hands the water image to the rest of the essay, which then uses it to describe what it’s like to think.
The plunge is the perfect test case precisely because it’s both the strongest evidence against reduction and the best image of flux, and Pater wins by refusing to choose between them. Pater uses the language of the elements to bring the swim into sharper focus. It still feels like the best afternoon of the summer. What the analysis really proves is that the moment is brief and made of passing things, and brevity, as the rest of the Conclusion shows, is the only premise Pater actually needs.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article argue that Pater begins with the pleasurable shock of a summer plunge rather than a more obviously mechanical bodily event?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the chemical redescription does not cancel the pleasure of the swim, what does it change about how the experience can be understood?→
- Why might an experience that feels most personal also be the strongest test of whether physical life can be reduced to elements and processes?→
- How does Pater’s reuse of water as both bodily experience and metaphor for consciousness complicate the apparent opposition between matter and thought?→