Renaissance
What Changes When You Can Take a Picture Home?
Pater credits Giorgione with painting small, movable scenes that people could live with. An exchange of letters from 1510 shows how much two owners wanted to keep theirs.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater’s framed picture can become as familiar as a book or an instrument. The records of Isabella d’Este and Taddeo Contarini show how a picture’s meaning could change when it entered a home.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Portable scenesPater credits Giorgione with making framed images of conversation, music and play for people to take home.
- Two pictures worth keepingIsabella d’Este’s agent found two night scenes by Giorgione and reported that their owners had commissioned them for themselves.
- Inside a Venetian collectionMarcantonio Michiel saw the Three Philosophers in Taddeo Contarini’s house in 1525.
- What the frame changesA picture in a private room can be seen again and again. Pater imagines it becoming a source of stimulus or solace.
The Renaissance · The School of Giorgione, p. 93, genre and living with pictures · The School of Giorgione, note 216
Pater makes a big claim in a small sentence. Giorgione, he says, “is the inventor of genre,” the French word for kind that art historians use for pictures of everyday life, and he spells out what he means as “those easily movable pictures which serve neither for uses of devotion, nor of allegorical or historic teaching.” Their subjects are “little groups of real men and women, amid congruous furniture or landscape,” or “morsels of actual life, conversation or music or play, but refined upon or idealised, till they come to seem like glimpses of life from afar.” The images are ordinary in subject and strange in mood, and they’re built to travel.
The physical act of moving the picture is what Pater lingers on. “Those spaces of more cunningly blent colour, obediently filling their places, hitherto, in a mere architectural scheme, Giorgione detaches from the wall,” and “he frames them by the hands of some skilful carver, so that people may move them readily and take with them where they go, as one might a poem in manuscript, or a musical instrument.” The comparison is exact, because a manuscript and a lute are things you own and use privately, at your own pace, unlike a fresco or an altarpiece that you visit on someone else’s schedule. It’s the difference between going to a concert hall and carrying an album around in your headphones for a year.
The evidence from Giorgione’s own day backs Pater up. When the young painter died in the autumn of 1510, Isabella d’Este, the collector in Mantua, wrote to her agent in Venice asking about a night scene said to be in Giorgione’s estate. Taddeo Albano replied in November 1510 that it was no longer a question of the estate. He knew of two night pictures, but neither was for sale because its owner had commissioned it for himself. Some years later the Venetian connoisseur Marcantonio Michiel went round the city’s houses writing down what he saw, and at Taddeo Contarini’s house he recorded a canvas of three philosophers in a landscape. Michiel says Giorgione began the work and Sebastiano finished it.
Pater’s list of what such pictures are for is worth slowing down on. They serve “as a means of self-education, stimulus or solace, coming like an animated presence, into one’s cabinet, to enrich the air as with some choice aroma, and, like persons, live with us, for a day or a lifetime.” A cabinet here is a small private room, the kind of study where a Venetian kept books and coins and instruments, and the three uses run from learning to see by looking at the same thing every day, to being woken up by it, to being comforted by it. The perfume image is the boldest, since it suggests a picture can change the air of a room the way incense or flowers do, without anyone looking at it directly.
Something changes in the picture itself once it moves indoors. A painting like The Three Philosophers can set a mood even when its story remains open. Interpretations of the figures vary. The rock face and the three people at the edge of it are there to study whatever their names turn out to be. In a house the same people can see it again and again, so it can reward the kind of attention that only builds up with time, the way a song you’ve lived with for years keeps giving up details. And inside its carved frame it has to make a whole world on its own, since it no longer borrows meaning from the chapel or the altar around it.
Something changes in the viewer too, and just as much. Looking becomes a matter of choice and of habit, and taste becomes personal, since you’re living with what you picked, a habit that helped sustain collecting and the close study of pictures. Michiel’s notebook is an early record of that culture, written by a visitor who noted which works he saw and who owned them. There’s an irony in that last step, because the pictures Giorgione’s generation freed from the wall ended up back on walls, in galleries where you visit them once on vacation, which is exactly the relationship Pater says they were made to escape. Pater sees the line running straight from Giorgione to his own culture, calling this “art which has played so large a part in men’s culture since that time.”
The word “inventor” needs a discount, though, and a fair one. Venetian households could already own portraits and devotional paintings. Bellini’s workshop produced both, and a Bellini of Saint Francis was in the same house as the Three Philosophers by 1525. What’s new in Giorgione is the combination, a portable picture with neither a devotional nor a teaching job, made for mood and for company. Mobility also had a price that Pater reports a page later, when he describes wealthy collectors with no critical standard buying up so-called Giorgiones until imitations flooded the market, so the same portability that made the pictures companions made their authorship a mess.
So what changes when you can take a picture home is the relationship, from an image you visit to an image you live with, and Pater is right that Giorgione is where that change becomes visible in Venice, even if “inventor” is a storyteller’s word. The exchange in 1510 gives the idea a concrete shape. Even an agent acting for Isabella d’Este reported that the owners meant to keep the pictures they had ordered for themselves. I think that refusal says more than any theory about what a portable picture is, since it’s what you say about a companion and never about a piece of furniture.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article argue that Pater’s label of Giorgione as the “inventor” of genre needs qualification?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If living with a picture makes looking a matter of habit and personal choice, how might repeated private viewing shape taste differently from a single visit to a public gallery?→
- The article says a portable painting can offer self-education, stimulus, or solace. Which of these purposes seems most dependent on repeated viewing, and why?→
- Does the article’s evidence justify calling Giorgione an “inventor,” or would another description better capture his role in the development of portable, secular pictures?→